A new meshless approach for subject-specific strain prediction in long bones: Evaluation of accuracy

Fulvia Taddei, Martino Pani, Luigino Zovatto, Enzo Tonti, Marco Viceconti

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The Finite Element Method is at present the method of choice for strain prediction in bones from Computed Tomography data. However, accurate methods rely on the correct topological representation of the bone surface, which requires a massive operator effort, thus restricting their applicability to clinical practice. Meshless methods, which do not rely on a pre-defined topological discretisation of the domain, might greatly improve the numerical process automation, but currently their application to biomechanics is negligible. Methods: A meshless implementation of an innovative numerical approach based on a direct discrete formulation of physical laws, the Cell Method, was developed to predict strains in a cadaver femur from Computed Tomography data. The model accuracy was estimated by comparing the predicted strains with those experimentally measured on the same specimen in a previous study. As a reference, the results were compared to those obtained with a state-of-the-art finite element model. Findings: The Cell Method meshless model predicted strains highly correlated with the experimental measurements (R2 = 0.85) with a good global accuracy (RMSE = 15.6%). The model performed slightly worse than the finite element one, but this was probably due to the need to sub-sample the original data, and the lower order of the interpolation used (linear vs parabolic). Interpretation: Although there is surely room for improvement, the accuracy already obtained with this meshless implementation of the Cell Method makes it a good candidate for some clinical applications, especially considering the full automation of the method, which does not require any data pre-processing.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1192-1199
Number of pages8
JournalClinical Biomechanics
Volume23
Issue number9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2008

Fingerprint

Bone and Bones
Automation
Tomography
Cadaver
Biomechanical Phenomena
Femur

Keywords

  • Bone biomechanics
  • Cell Method
  • Computed Tomography
  • Meshless methods
  • Numerical model
  • Validation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
  • Biophysics

Cite this

A new meshless approach for subject-specific strain prediction in long bones : Evaluation of accuracy. / Taddei, Fulvia; Pani, Martino; Zovatto, Luigino; Tonti, Enzo; Viceconti, Marco.

In: Clinical Biomechanics, Vol. 23, No. 9, 11.2008, p. 1192-1199.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2730e2dca287463e9f3707a936af9211,
title = "A new meshless approach for subject-specific strain prediction in long bones: Evaluation of accuracy",
abstract = "Background: The Finite Element Method is at present the method of choice for strain prediction in bones from Computed Tomography data. However, accurate methods rely on the correct topological representation of the bone surface, which requires a massive operator effort, thus restricting their applicability to clinical practice. Meshless methods, which do not rely on a pre-defined topological discretisation of the domain, might greatly improve the numerical process automation, but currently their application to biomechanics is negligible. Methods: A meshless implementation of an innovative numerical approach based on a direct discrete formulation of physical laws, the Cell Method, was developed to predict strains in a cadaver femur from Computed Tomography data. The model accuracy was estimated by comparing the predicted strains with those experimentally measured on the same specimen in a previous study. As a reference, the results were compared to those obtained with a state-of-the-art finite element model. Findings: The Cell Method meshless model predicted strains highly correlated with the experimental measurements (R2 = 0.85) with a good global accuracy (RMSE = 15.6{\%}). The model performed slightly worse than the finite element one, but this was probably due to the need to sub-sample the original data, and the lower order of the interpolation used (linear vs parabolic). Interpretation: Although there is surely room for improvement, the accuracy already obtained with this meshless implementation of the Cell Method makes it a good candidate for some clinical applications, especially considering the full automation of the method, which does not require any data pre-processing.",
keywords = "Bone biomechanics, Cell Method, Computed Tomography, Meshless methods, Numerical model, Validation",
author = "Fulvia Taddei and Martino Pani and Luigino Zovatto and Enzo Tonti and Marco Viceconti",
year = "2008",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.009",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "1192--1199",
journal = "Clinical Biomechanics",
issn = "0268-0033",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A new meshless approach for subject-specific strain prediction in long bones

T2 - Evaluation of accuracy

AU - Taddei, Fulvia

AU - Pani, Martino

AU - Zovatto, Luigino

AU - Tonti, Enzo

AU - Viceconti, Marco

PY - 2008/11

Y1 - 2008/11

N2 - Background: The Finite Element Method is at present the method of choice for strain prediction in bones from Computed Tomography data. However, accurate methods rely on the correct topological representation of the bone surface, which requires a massive operator effort, thus restricting their applicability to clinical practice. Meshless methods, which do not rely on a pre-defined topological discretisation of the domain, might greatly improve the numerical process automation, but currently their application to biomechanics is negligible. Methods: A meshless implementation of an innovative numerical approach based on a direct discrete formulation of physical laws, the Cell Method, was developed to predict strains in a cadaver femur from Computed Tomography data. The model accuracy was estimated by comparing the predicted strains with those experimentally measured on the same specimen in a previous study. As a reference, the results were compared to those obtained with a state-of-the-art finite element model. Findings: The Cell Method meshless model predicted strains highly correlated with the experimental measurements (R2 = 0.85) with a good global accuracy (RMSE = 15.6%). The model performed slightly worse than the finite element one, but this was probably due to the need to sub-sample the original data, and the lower order of the interpolation used (linear vs parabolic). Interpretation: Although there is surely room for improvement, the accuracy already obtained with this meshless implementation of the Cell Method makes it a good candidate for some clinical applications, especially considering the full automation of the method, which does not require any data pre-processing.

AB - Background: The Finite Element Method is at present the method of choice for strain prediction in bones from Computed Tomography data. However, accurate methods rely on the correct topological representation of the bone surface, which requires a massive operator effort, thus restricting their applicability to clinical practice. Meshless methods, which do not rely on a pre-defined topological discretisation of the domain, might greatly improve the numerical process automation, but currently their application to biomechanics is negligible. Methods: A meshless implementation of an innovative numerical approach based on a direct discrete formulation of physical laws, the Cell Method, was developed to predict strains in a cadaver femur from Computed Tomography data. The model accuracy was estimated by comparing the predicted strains with those experimentally measured on the same specimen in a previous study. As a reference, the results were compared to those obtained with a state-of-the-art finite element model. Findings: The Cell Method meshless model predicted strains highly correlated with the experimental measurements (R2 = 0.85) with a good global accuracy (RMSE = 15.6%). The model performed slightly worse than the finite element one, but this was probably due to the need to sub-sample the original data, and the lower order of the interpolation used (linear vs parabolic). Interpretation: Although there is surely room for improvement, the accuracy already obtained with this meshless implementation of the Cell Method makes it a good candidate for some clinical applications, especially considering the full automation of the method, which does not require any data pre-processing.

KW - Bone biomechanics

KW - Cell Method

KW - Computed Tomography

KW - Meshless methods

KW - Numerical model

KW - Validation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=53649085095&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=53649085095&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.009

DO - 10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2008.06.009

M3 - Article

C2 - 18678436

AN - SCOPUS:53649085095

VL - 23

SP - 1192

EP - 1199

JO - Clinical Biomechanics

JF - Clinical Biomechanics

SN - 0268-0033

IS - 9

ER -