TY - JOUR
T1 - Age-related infertility and unexplained infertility
T2 - An intricate clinical dilemma
AU - Somigliana, Edgardo
AU - Paffoni, Alessio
AU - Busnelli, Andrea
AU - Filippi, Francesca
AU - Pagliardini, Luca
AU - Vigano, Paola
AU - Vercellini, Paolo
PY - 2016
Y1 - 2016
N2 - A diagnosis of unexplained infertility is commonly made when clinical investigations fail to identify any obvious barriers to conception. As a consequence, unexplained infertility includes several heterogeneous conditions, one being women with age-related infertility. However, the latter represent a peculiar and different situation. Women with age-related infertility may have a different prognosis and may benefit from different treatments. Unfortunately, since fecundity declines with age, discerning between unexplained infertility and age-related infertility becomes more and more difficult as the woman's age increases. In this opinion, with the use of a mathematical model we show that the rate of false positive diagnoses of unexplained infertility increases rapidly after 35 years of age. Using a threshold of 2 years of unfruitful, regular unprotected intercourse, this rate exceeds 50% in women starting pregnancy seeking after 37 years. The scenario is much worse using a threshold of 1 year. From a clinical perspective, extrapolating results obtained in a population of young women with unexplained infertility to those with age-related infertility is not justified. It is noteworthy that, if AssistedReproductiveTechnologies are unable to overcome age-related infertility, the older women erroneously labeled with unexplained infertility may receive inappropriate therapies. These may expose women to unjustified risks and waste financial resources. Unfortunately, the available literature about older women is scanty and does not provide valid evidence. Randomized controlled trials aimed at identifying the most suitable clinical management of older women with a normal infertility work-up are pressingly needed.
AB - A diagnosis of unexplained infertility is commonly made when clinical investigations fail to identify any obvious barriers to conception. As a consequence, unexplained infertility includes several heterogeneous conditions, one being women with age-related infertility. However, the latter represent a peculiar and different situation. Women with age-related infertility may have a different prognosis and may benefit from different treatments. Unfortunately, since fecundity declines with age, discerning between unexplained infertility and age-related infertility becomes more and more difficult as the woman's age increases. In this opinion, with the use of a mathematical model we show that the rate of false positive diagnoses of unexplained infertility increases rapidly after 35 years of age. Using a threshold of 2 years of unfruitful, regular unprotected intercourse, this rate exceeds 50% in women starting pregnancy seeking after 37 years. The scenario is much worse using a threshold of 1 year. From a clinical perspective, extrapolating results obtained in a population of young women with unexplained infertility to those with age-related infertility is not justified. It is noteworthy that, if AssistedReproductiveTechnologies are unable to overcome age-related infertility, the older women erroneously labeled with unexplained infertility may receive inappropriate therapies. These may expose women to unjustified risks and waste financial resources. Unfortunately, the available literature about older women is scanty and does not provide valid evidence. Randomized controlled trials aimed at identifying the most suitable clinical management of older women with a normal infertility work-up are pressingly needed.
KW - Age
KW - ART
KW - Economic
KW - IVF
KW - Risk
KW - Unexplained infertility
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84977107018&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84977107018&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1093/humrep/dew066
DO - 10.1093/humrep/dew066
M3 - Review article
AN - SCOPUS:84977107018
VL - 31
SP - 1390
EP - 1396
JO - Human Reproduction
JF - Human Reproduction
SN - 0268-1161
IS - 7
ER -