Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina

Federica Sevini, Daniele Yang Yao, Laura Lomartire, Annalaura Barbieri, Dario Vianello, Gianmarco Ferri, Edgardo Moretti, Maria Cristina Dasso, Paolo Garagnani, Davide Pettener, Claudio Franceschi, Donata Luiselli, Zelda Alice Franceschi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Sub-population structure and intricate kinship dynamics might introduce biases in molecular anthropology studies and could invalidate the efforts to understand diseases in highly admixed populations. In order to clarify the previously observed distribution pattern and morbidity of Chagas disease in Gran Chaco, Argentina, we studied two populations (Wichí and Criollos) recruited following an innovative bio-cultural model considering their complex cultural interactions. By reconstructing the genetic background and the structure of these two culturally different populations, the pattern of admixture, the correspondence between genealogical and genetic relationships, this integrated perspective had the power to validate data and to link the gap usually relying on a singular discipline. Although Wichí and Criollos share the same area, these sympatric populations are differentiated from the genetic point of view as revealed by Non Recombinant Y Chromosome genotyping resulting in significantly high Fst values and in a lower genetic variability in the Wichí population. Surprisingly, the Amerindian and the European components emerged with comparable amounts (20%) among Criollos and Wichí respectively. The detailed analysis of mitochondrial DNA showed that the two populations have as much as 87% of private haplotypes. Moreover, from the maternal perspective, despite a common Amerindian origin, an Andean and an Amazonian component emerged in Criollos and in Wichí respectively. Our approach allowed us to highlight that quite frequently there is a discrepancy between self-reported and genetic kinship. Indeed, if self-reported identity and kinship are usually utilized in population genetics as a reliable proxy for genetic identity and parental relationship, in our model populations appear to be the result not only and not simply of the genetic background but also of complex cultural determinants. This integrated approach paves the way to a rigorous reconstruction of demographic and cultural history as well as of bioancestry and propensity to diseases of Wichí and Criollos.

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere64054
JournalPLoS One
Volume8
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 22 2013

Fingerprint

Argentina
sympatry
kinship
Population
Chromosomes
Mitochondrial DNA
Population Genetics
genetic background
anthropology
Chagas disease
Y chromosome
Anthropology
Chagas Disease
Genetic Structures
Y Chromosome
Proxy
genotyping
genetic relationships
Pedigree
morbidity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Agricultural and Biological Sciences(all)
  • Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology(all)
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Sevini, F., Yao, D. Y., Lomartire, L., Barbieri, A., Vianello, D., Ferri, G., ... Franceschi, Z. A. (2013). Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina. PLoS One, 8(5), [e64054]. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0064054

Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina. / Sevini, Federica; Yao, Daniele Yang; Lomartire, Laura; Barbieri, Annalaura; Vianello, Dario; Ferri, Gianmarco; Moretti, Edgardo; Dasso, Maria Cristina; Garagnani, Paolo; Pettener, Davide; Franceschi, Claudio; Luiselli, Donata; Franceschi, Zelda Alice.

In: PLoS One, Vol. 8, No. 5, e64054, 22.05.2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Sevini, F, Yao, DY, Lomartire, L, Barbieri, A, Vianello, D, Ferri, G, Moretti, E, Dasso, MC, Garagnani, P, Pettener, D, Franceschi, C, Luiselli, D & Franceschi, ZA 2013, 'Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina', PLoS One, vol. 8, no. 5, e64054. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0064054
Sevini F, Yao DY, Lomartire L, Barbieri A, Vianello D, Ferri G et al. Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina. PLoS One. 2013 May 22;8(5). e64054. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0064054
Sevini, Federica ; Yao, Daniele Yang ; Lomartire, Laura ; Barbieri, Annalaura ; Vianello, Dario ; Ferri, Gianmarco ; Moretti, Edgardo ; Dasso, Maria Cristina ; Garagnani, Paolo ; Pettener, Davide ; Franceschi, Claudio ; Luiselli, Donata ; Franceschi, Zelda Alice. / Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina. In: PLoS One. 2013 ; Vol. 8, No. 5.
@article{3058af86e0784738bd723d52be62baa7,
title = "Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina",
abstract = "Sub-population structure and intricate kinship dynamics might introduce biases in molecular anthropology studies and could invalidate the efforts to understand diseases in highly admixed populations. In order to clarify the previously observed distribution pattern and morbidity of Chagas disease in Gran Chaco, Argentina, we studied two populations (Wich{\'i} and Criollos) recruited following an innovative bio-cultural model considering their complex cultural interactions. By reconstructing the genetic background and the structure of these two culturally different populations, the pattern of admixture, the correspondence between genealogical and genetic relationships, this integrated perspective had the power to validate data and to link the gap usually relying on a singular discipline. Although Wich{\'i} and Criollos share the same area, these sympatric populations are differentiated from the genetic point of view as revealed by Non Recombinant Y Chromosome genotyping resulting in significantly high Fst values and in a lower genetic variability in the Wich{\'i} population. Surprisingly, the Amerindian and the European components emerged with comparable amounts (20{\%}) among Criollos and Wich{\'i} respectively. The detailed analysis of mitochondrial DNA showed that the two populations have as much as 87{\%} of private haplotypes. Moreover, from the maternal perspective, despite a common Amerindian origin, an Andean and an Amazonian component emerged in Criollos and in Wich{\'i} respectively. Our approach allowed us to highlight that quite frequently there is a discrepancy between self-reported and genetic kinship. Indeed, if self-reported identity and kinship are usually utilized in population genetics as a reliable proxy for genetic identity and parental relationship, in our model populations appear to be the result not only and not simply of the genetic background but also of complex cultural determinants. This integrated approach paves the way to a rigorous reconstruction of demographic and cultural history as well as of bioancestry and propensity to diseases of Wich{\'i} and Criollos.",
author = "Federica Sevini and Yao, {Daniele Yang} and Laura Lomartire and Annalaura Barbieri and Dario Vianello and Gianmarco Ferri and Edgardo Moretti and Dasso, {Maria Cristina} and Paolo Garagnani and Davide Pettener and Claudio Franceschi and Donata Luiselli and Franceschi, {Zelda Alice}",
year = "2013",
month = "5",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1371/journal.pone.0064054",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
journal = "PLoS One",
issn = "1932-6203",
publisher = "Public Library of Science",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Analysis of Population Substructure in Two Sympatric Populations of Gran Chaco, Argentina

AU - Sevini, Federica

AU - Yao, Daniele Yang

AU - Lomartire, Laura

AU - Barbieri, Annalaura

AU - Vianello, Dario

AU - Ferri, Gianmarco

AU - Moretti, Edgardo

AU - Dasso, Maria Cristina

AU - Garagnani, Paolo

AU - Pettener, Davide

AU - Franceschi, Claudio

AU - Luiselli, Donata

AU - Franceschi, Zelda Alice

PY - 2013/5/22

Y1 - 2013/5/22

N2 - Sub-population structure and intricate kinship dynamics might introduce biases in molecular anthropology studies and could invalidate the efforts to understand diseases in highly admixed populations. In order to clarify the previously observed distribution pattern and morbidity of Chagas disease in Gran Chaco, Argentina, we studied two populations (Wichí and Criollos) recruited following an innovative bio-cultural model considering their complex cultural interactions. By reconstructing the genetic background and the structure of these two culturally different populations, the pattern of admixture, the correspondence between genealogical and genetic relationships, this integrated perspective had the power to validate data and to link the gap usually relying on a singular discipline. Although Wichí and Criollos share the same area, these sympatric populations are differentiated from the genetic point of view as revealed by Non Recombinant Y Chromosome genotyping resulting in significantly high Fst values and in a lower genetic variability in the Wichí population. Surprisingly, the Amerindian and the European components emerged with comparable amounts (20%) among Criollos and Wichí respectively. The detailed analysis of mitochondrial DNA showed that the two populations have as much as 87% of private haplotypes. Moreover, from the maternal perspective, despite a common Amerindian origin, an Andean and an Amazonian component emerged in Criollos and in Wichí respectively. Our approach allowed us to highlight that quite frequently there is a discrepancy between self-reported and genetic kinship. Indeed, if self-reported identity and kinship are usually utilized in population genetics as a reliable proxy for genetic identity and parental relationship, in our model populations appear to be the result not only and not simply of the genetic background but also of complex cultural determinants. This integrated approach paves the way to a rigorous reconstruction of demographic and cultural history as well as of bioancestry and propensity to diseases of Wichí and Criollos.

AB - Sub-population structure and intricate kinship dynamics might introduce biases in molecular anthropology studies and could invalidate the efforts to understand diseases in highly admixed populations. In order to clarify the previously observed distribution pattern and morbidity of Chagas disease in Gran Chaco, Argentina, we studied two populations (Wichí and Criollos) recruited following an innovative bio-cultural model considering their complex cultural interactions. By reconstructing the genetic background and the structure of these two culturally different populations, the pattern of admixture, the correspondence between genealogical and genetic relationships, this integrated perspective had the power to validate data and to link the gap usually relying on a singular discipline. Although Wichí and Criollos share the same area, these sympatric populations are differentiated from the genetic point of view as revealed by Non Recombinant Y Chromosome genotyping resulting in significantly high Fst values and in a lower genetic variability in the Wichí population. Surprisingly, the Amerindian and the European components emerged with comparable amounts (20%) among Criollos and Wichí respectively. The detailed analysis of mitochondrial DNA showed that the two populations have as much as 87% of private haplotypes. Moreover, from the maternal perspective, despite a common Amerindian origin, an Andean and an Amazonian component emerged in Criollos and in Wichí respectively. Our approach allowed us to highlight that quite frequently there is a discrepancy between self-reported and genetic kinship. Indeed, if self-reported identity and kinship are usually utilized in population genetics as a reliable proxy for genetic identity and parental relationship, in our model populations appear to be the result not only and not simply of the genetic background but also of complex cultural determinants. This integrated approach paves the way to a rigorous reconstruction of demographic and cultural history as well as of bioancestry and propensity to diseases of Wichí and Criollos.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84878057439&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84878057439&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1371/journal.pone.0064054

DO - 10.1371/journal.pone.0064054

M3 - Article

C2 - 23717528

AN - SCOPUS:84878057439

VL - 8

JO - PLoS One

JF - PLoS One

SN - 1932-6203

IS - 5

M1 - e64054

ER -