Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder blame game: A study on the positioning of professionals, teachers and parents

Alessandra Frigerio, Lorenzo Montali, Michelle Fine

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder is currently the most debated childhood psychiatric diagnosis. Given the circulation of competing perspectives about the 'real' causes of children's behaviour and the 'best' way to treat them, we aim to analyse the interactions of the central social actors' discourses about attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children within the Italian context. Adopting a multi-method approach, we focus on the polyphonic chorus of voices surrounding the child, studying the discourses of mental health professionals, teachers and parents. These actors are representative of three contexts that are deeply engaged with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: medical institutions, schools and families. Our theoretical and methodological approach integrates positioning theory, the Bakhtinian notion of dialogical thinking and discourse analysis to study stakeholders' reflexive and interactive positioning in terms of the attribution of rights, duties, responsibilities and power issues. The results show that mutual blame is a constitutive element of relational dynamics among the key adults surrounding attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children. We argue that these conflicting relationships are not merely related to the debate regarding the validity of the attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder diagnosis. Rather, the mutual blame centres on questions of compliance, recognition of authority and morality. Through the blame game, adults negotiate their own and others' subjectivity in ways that simultaneously (re)produce power relationships and resistance efforts.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)584-604
Number of pages21
JournalHealth (United Kingdom)
Volume17
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2013

Fingerprint

ADHD
Attention Deficit Disorder with Hyperactivity
parents
Parents
teacher
discourse
Child Behavior
social actor
Interpersonal Relations
Medical Schools
Mental Disorders
discourse analysis
health professionals
morality
attribution
Compliance
subjectivity
Mental Health
mental health
childhood

Keywords

  • attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder
  • blame
  • discourse analysis
  • morality
  • positioning

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health(social science)

Cite this

Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder blame game : A study on the positioning of professionals, teachers and parents. / Frigerio, Alessandra; Montali, Lorenzo; Fine, Michelle.

In: Health (United Kingdom), Vol. 17, No. 6, 11.2013, p. 584-604.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a906a013291049b6a449baa01c685229,
title = "Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder blame game: A study on the positioning of professionals, teachers and parents",
abstract = "Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder is currently the most debated childhood psychiatric diagnosis. Given the circulation of competing perspectives about the 'real' causes of children's behaviour and the 'best' way to treat them, we aim to analyse the interactions of the central social actors' discourses about attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children within the Italian context. Adopting a multi-method approach, we focus on the polyphonic chorus of voices surrounding the child, studying the discourses of mental health professionals, teachers and parents. These actors are representative of three contexts that are deeply engaged with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: medical institutions, schools and families. Our theoretical and methodological approach integrates positioning theory, the Bakhtinian notion of dialogical thinking and discourse analysis to study stakeholders' reflexive and interactive positioning in terms of the attribution of rights, duties, responsibilities and power issues. The results show that mutual blame is a constitutive element of relational dynamics among the key adults surrounding attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children. We argue that these conflicting relationships are not merely related to the debate regarding the validity of the attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder diagnosis. Rather, the mutual blame centres on questions of compliance, recognition of authority and morality. Through the blame game, adults negotiate their own and others' subjectivity in ways that simultaneously (re)produce power relationships and resistance efforts.",
keywords = "attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder, blame, discourse analysis, morality, positioning",
author = "Alessandra Frigerio and Lorenzo Montali and Michelle Fine",
year = "2013",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1177/1363459312472083",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "584--604",
journal = "Health",
issn = "1363-4593",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder blame game

T2 - A study on the positioning of professionals, teachers and parents

AU - Frigerio, Alessandra

AU - Montali, Lorenzo

AU - Fine, Michelle

PY - 2013/11

Y1 - 2013/11

N2 - Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder is currently the most debated childhood psychiatric diagnosis. Given the circulation of competing perspectives about the 'real' causes of children's behaviour and the 'best' way to treat them, we aim to analyse the interactions of the central social actors' discourses about attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children within the Italian context. Adopting a multi-method approach, we focus on the polyphonic chorus of voices surrounding the child, studying the discourses of mental health professionals, teachers and parents. These actors are representative of three contexts that are deeply engaged with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: medical institutions, schools and families. Our theoretical and methodological approach integrates positioning theory, the Bakhtinian notion of dialogical thinking and discourse analysis to study stakeholders' reflexive and interactive positioning in terms of the attribution of rights, duties, responsibilities and power issues. The results show that mutual blame is a constitutive element of relational dynamics among the key adults surrounding attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children. We argue that these conflicting relationships are not merely related to the debate regarding the validity of the attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder diagnosis. Rather, the mutual blame centres on questions of compliance, recognition of authority and morality. Through the blame game, adults negotiate their own and others' subjectivity in ways that simultaneously (re)produce power relationships and resistance efforts.

AB - Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder is currently the most debated childhood psychiatric diagnosis. Given the circulation of competing perspectives about the 'real' causes of children's behaviour and the 'best' way to treat them, we aim to analyse the interactions of the central social actors' discourses about attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children within the Italian context. Adopting a multi-method approach, we focus on the polyphonic chorus of voices surrounding the child, studying the discourses of mental health professionals, teachers and parents. These actors are representative of three contexts that are deeply engaged with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: medical institutions, schools and families. Our theoretical and methodological approach integrates positioning theory, the Bakhtinian notion of dialogical thinking and discourse analysis to study stakeholders' reflexive and interactive positioning in terms of the attribution of rights, duties, responsibilities and power issues. The results show that mutual blame is a constitutive element of relational dynamics among the key adults surrounding attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder children. We argue that these conflicting relationships are not merely related to the debate regarding the validity of the attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder diagnosis. Rather, the mutual blame centres on questions of compliance, recognition of authority and morality. Through the blame game, adults negotiate their own and others' subjectivity in ways that simultaneously (re)produce power relationships and resistance efforts.

KW - attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder

KW - blame

KW - discourse analysis

KW - morality

KW - positioning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84886378120&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84886378120&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1363459312472083

DO - 10.1177/1363459312472083

M3 - Article

C2 - 23413098

AN - SCOPUS:84886378120

VL - 17

SP - 584

EP - 604

JO - Health

JF - Health

SN - 1363-4593

IS - 6

ER -