Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans

Yassine Bouchareb; Kris Thielemans; Terence Spinks; Ornella Rimoldi; Paolo G. Camici

doi:10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753

Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans

Yassine Bouchareb, Kris Thielemans, Terence Spinks, Ornella Rimoldi, Paolo G. Camici

IRCCS Ospedale San Raffaele

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Conference contribution

Abstract

We investigated the quantitative accuracy of iterative and analytic reconstruction methods to determine myocardial blood flow (MBF) in PET studies in pigs using O-15 labeled water. Dynamic scans were acquired on the EXACT3D PET scanner on large white pigs after H₂ ¹⁵O injection (resting and dipyridamole-induced stress). Radioactive microspheres were injected during the H₂ ¹⁵O scans to provide a "gold standard" of MBF values. Data were reconstructed with 3DRP, FORE + attenuation-weighted OSEM, FORE-FBP and 3D-OSEM. Factor images were generated by cluster analysis and linear dimension reduction (myocardium and left and right cavities) and resliced to short axis images; 16 ROIs were defined in the left myocardium and 2 ROIs in the left and right cavities. ROIs were projected onto the dynamic images to extract time-activity-curves (TACs), which were then fitted to a single compartment model to estimate regional and global absolute MBF. Microsphere measurements were obtained in a similar way and 64 pairs of measurements were made. FORE-OSEM and 3D-RP overestimated the CFR values by 10% and 17%, respectively and 3D-OSEM and FORE-FBP underestimate CFR values by 3% and 17%, respectively. Regression analysis for 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM gave intercepts close to zero and slopes close to unity. Bland and Altman plots of differences between all reconstructions and Microsphere provided a mean difference and limits of agreements in favour of 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM (mean difference closer to zero and smaller SD). For absolute quantification of MBF using O-15 water, 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM proved to be at least as accurate as 3DRP and FORE-FBP compared with the Microsphere technique.

Original language	English
Title of host publication	IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record
Pages	2120-2123
Number of pages	4
Volume	4
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753
Publication status	Published - 2005
Event	Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2005 IEEE - , Puerto Rico Duration: Oct 23 2005 → Oct 29 2005

Other

Other	Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2005 IEEE
Country/Territory	Puerto Rico
Period	10/23/05 → 10/29/05

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering

Access to Document

10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753

Cite this

Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans. / Bouchareb, Yassine; Thielemans, Kris; Spinks, Terence; Rimoldi, Ornella; Camici, Paolo G.

IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record. Vol. 4 2005. p. 2120-2123 1596753.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Conference contribution

Bouchareb, Y, Thielemans, K, Spinks, T, Rimoldi, O & Camici, PG 2005, Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans. in IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record. vol. 4, 1596753, pp. 2120-2123, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2005 IEEE, Puerto Rico, 10/23/05. https://doi.org/10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753

@inproceedings{fd6769ab0a9349a6ac7892f80d9d8b5a,

title = "Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans",

abstract = "We investigated the quantitative accuracy of iterative and analytic reconstruction methods to determine myocardial blood flow (MBF) in PET studies in pigs using O-15 labeled water. Dynamic scans were acquired on the EXACT3D PET scanner on large white pigs after H2 15O injection (resting and dipyridamole-induced stress). Radioactive microspheres were injected during the H2 15O scans to provide a {"}gold standard{"} of MBF values. Data were reconstructed with 3DRP, FORE + attenuation-weighted OSEM, FORE-FBP and 3D-OSEM. Factor images were generated by cluster analysis and linear dimension reduction (myocardium and left and right cavities) and resliced to short axis images; 16 ROIs were defined in the left myocardium and 2 ROIs in the left and right cavities. ROIs were projected onto the dynamic images to extract time-activity-curves (TACs), which were then fitted to a single compartment model to estimate regional and global absolute MBF. Microsphere measurements were obtained in a similar way and 64 pairs of measurements were made. FORE-OSEM and 3D-RP overestimated the CFR values by 10% and 17%, respectively and 3D-OSEM and FORE-FBP underestimate CFR values by 3% and 17%, respectively. Regression analysis for 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM gave intercepts close to zero and slopes close to unity. Bland and Altman plots of differences between all reconstructions and Microsphere provided a mean difference and limits of agreements in favour of 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM (mean difference closer to zero and smaller SD). For absolute quantification of MBF using O-15 water, 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM proved to be at least as accurate as 3DRP and FORE-FBP compared with the Microsphere technique.",

author = "Yassine Bouchareb and Kris Thielemans and Terence Spinks and Ornella Rimoldi and Camici, {Paolo G.}",

year = "2005",

doi = "10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753",

language = "English",

isbn = "0780392213",

volume = "4",

pages = "2120--2123",

booktitle = "IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record",

note = "Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2005 IEEE ; Conference date: 23-10-2005 Through 29-10-2005",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans

AU - Bouchareb, Yassine

AU - Thielemans, Kris

AU - Spinks, Terence

AU - Rimoldi, Ornella

AU - Camici, Paolo G.

PY - 2005

Y1 - 2005

N2 - We investigated the quantitative accuracy of iterative and analytic reconstruction methods to determine myocardial blood flow (MBF) in PET studies in pigs using O-15 labeled water. Dynamic scans were acquired on the EXACT3D PET scanner on large white pigs after H2 15O injection (resting and dipyridamole-induced stress). Radioactive microspheres were injected during the H2 15O scans to provide a "gold standard" of MBF values. Data were reconstructed with 3DRP, FORE + attenuation-weighted OSEM, FORE-FBP and 3D-OSEM. Factor images were generated by cluster analysis and linear dimension reduction (myocardium and left and right cavities) and resliced to short axis images; 16 ROIs were defined in the left myocardium and 2 ROIs in the left and right cavities. ROIs were projected onto the dynamic images to extract time-activity-curves (TACs), which were then fitted to a single compartment model to estimate regional and global absolute MBF. Microsphere measurements were obtained in a similar way and 64 pairs of measurements were made. FORE-OSEM and 3D-RP overestimated the CFR values by 10% and 17%, respectively and 3D-OSEM and FORE-FBP underestimate CFR values by 3% and 17%, respectively. Regression analysis for 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM gave intercepts close to zero and slopes close to unity. Bland and Altman plots of differences between all reconstructions and Microsphere provided a mean difference and limits of agreements in favour of 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM (mean difference closer to zero and smaller SD). For absolute quantification of MBF using O-15 water, 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM proved to be at least as accurate as 3DRP and FORE-FBP compared with the Microsphere technique.

AB - We investigated the quantitative accuracy of iterative and analytic reconstruction methods to determine myocardial blood flow (MBF) in PET studies in pigs using O-15 labeled water. Dynamic scans were acquired on the EXACT3D PET scanner on large white pigs after H2 15O injection (resting and dipyridamole-induced stress). Radioactive microspheres were injected during the H2 15O scans to provide a "gold standard" of MBF values. Data were reconstructed with 3DRP, FORE + attenuation-weighted OSEM, FORE-FBP and 3D-OSEM. Factor images were generated by cluster analysis and linear dimension reduction (myocardium and left and right cavities) and resliced to short axis images; 16 ROIs were defined in the left myocardium and 2 ROIs in the left and right cavities. ROIs were projected onto the dynamic images to extract time-activity-curves (TACs), which were then fitted to a single compartment model to estimate regional and global absolute MBF. Microsphere measurements were obtained in a similar way and 64 pairs of measurements were made. FORE-OSEM and 3D-RP overestimated the CFR values by 10% and 17%, respectively and 3D-OSEM and FORE-FBP underestimate CFR values by 3% and 17%, respectively. Regression analysis for 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM gave intercepts close to zero and slopes close to unity. Bland and Altman plots of differences between all reconstructions and Microsphere provided a mean difference and limits of agreements in favour of 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM (mean difference closer to zero and smaller SD). For absolute quantification of MBF using O-15 water, 3D-OSEM and FORE-OSEM proved to be at least as accurate as 3DRP and FORE-FBP compared with the Microsphere technique.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33846647583&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33846647583&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753

DO - 10.1109/NSSMIC.2005.1596753

M3 - Conference contribution

AN - SCOPUS:33846647583

SN - 0780392213

SN - 9780780392212

VL - 4

SP - 2120

EP - 2123

BT - IEEE Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record

T2 - Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2005 IEEE

Y2 - 23 October 2005 through 29 October 2005

ER -

Comparison of analytic and iterative reconstruction methods for quantitative cardiac PET studies in 3D using Oxygen-15 water scans

Abstract

Other

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Access to Document

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this