Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014

Gert Van der Auwera, Aldert Bart, Carmen Chicharro, Sofia Cortes, Leigh Davidsson, Trentina Di Muccio, Jean-Claude Dujardin, Ingrid Felger, Maria Grazia Paglia, Felix Grimm, Gundel Harms, Charles L Jaffe, Monika Manser, Christophe Ravel, Florence Robert-Gangneux, Jeroen Roelfsema, Seray Töz, Jaco J Verweij, Peter L. Chiodini

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Leishmaniasis is endemic in southern Europe, and in other European countries cases are diagnosed in travellers who have visited affected areas both within the continent and beyond. Prompt and accurate diagnosis poses a challenge in clinical practice in Europe. Different methods exist for identification of the infecting Leishmania species. Sixteen clinical laboratories in 10 European countries, plus Israel and Turkey, conducted a study to assess their genotyping performance. DNA from 21 promastigote cultures of 13 species was analysed blindly by the routinely used typing method. Five different molecular targets were used, which were analysed with PCR-based methods. Different levels of identification were achieved, and either the Leishmania subgenus, species complex, or actual species were reported. The overall error rate of strains placed in the wrong complex or species was 8.5%. Various reasons for incorrect typing were identified. The study shows there is considerable room for improvement and standardisation of Leishmania typing. The use of well validated standard operating procedures is recommended, covering testing, interpretation, and reporting guidelines. Application of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of the rDNA array should be restricted to Old World samples, while the heat-shock protein 70 gene and the mini-exon can be applied globally.

Original languageEnglish
JournalEurosurveillance
Volume21
Issue number49
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 8 2016

Fingerprint

Leishmania
HSP70 Heat-Shock Proteins
Leishmaniasis
Israel
Turkey
Ribosomal DNA
Exons
Guidelines
Polymerase Chain Reaction
DNA
Genes

Keywords

  • Journal Article

Cite this

Van der Auwera, G., Bart, A., Chicharro, C., Cortes, S., Davidsson, L., Di Muccio, T., ... Chiodini, P. L. (2016). Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014. Eurosurveillance, 21(49). https://doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.49.30418

Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014. / Van der Auwera, Gert; Bart, Aldert; Chicharro, Carmen; Cortes, Sofia; Davidsson, Leigh; Di Muccio, Trentina; Dujardin, Jean-Claude; Felger, Ingrid; Paglia, Maria Grazia; Grimm, Felix; Harms, Gundel; Jaffe, Charles L; Manser, Monika; Ravel, Christophe; Robert-Gangneux, Florence; Roelfsema, Jeroen; Töz, Seray; Verweij, Jaco J; Chiodini, Peter L.

In: Eurosurveillance, Vol. 21, No. 49, 08.12.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Van der Auwera, G, Bart, A, Chicharro, C, Cortes, S, Davidsson, L, Di Muccio, T, Dujardin, J-C, Felger, I, Paglia, MG, Grimm, F, Harms, G, Jaffe, CL, Manser, M, Ravel, C, Robert-Gangneux, F, Roelfsema, J, Töz, S, Verweij, JJ & Chiodini, PL 2016, 'Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014', Eurosurveillance, vol. 21, no. 49. https://doi.org/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.49.30418
Van der Auwera, Gert ; Bart, Aldert ; Chicharro, Carmen ; Cortes, Sofia ; Davidsson, Leigh ; Di Muccio, Trentina ; Dujardin, Jean-Claude ; Felger, Ingrid ; Paglia, Maria Grazia ; Grimm, Felix ; Harms, Gundel ; Jaffe, Charles L ; Manser, Monika ; Ravel, Christophe ; Robert-Gangneux, Florence ; Roelfsema, Jeroen ; Töz, Seray ; Verweij, Jaco J ; Chiodini, Peter L. / Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014. In: Eurosurveillance. 2016 ; Vol. 21, No. 49.
@article{2167a35fc9cf44db8f2f06897233745d,
title = "Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014",
abstract = "Leishmaniasis is endemic in southern Europe, and in other European countries cases are diagnosed in travellers who have visited affected areas both within the continent and beyond. Prompt and accurate diagnosis poses a challenge in clinical practice in Europe. Different methods exist for identification of the infecting Leishmania species. Sixteen clinical laboratories in 10 European countries, plus Israel and Turkey, conducted a study to assess their genotyping performance. DNA from 21 promastigote cultures of 13 species was analysed blindly by the routinely used typing method. Five different molecular targets were used, which were analysed with PCR-based methods. Different levels of identification were achieved, and either the Leishmania subgenus, species complex, or actual species were reported. The overall error rate of strains placed in the wrong complex or species was 8.5{\%}. Various reasons for incorrect typing were identified. The study shows there is considerable room for improvement and standardisation of Leishmania typing. The use of well validated standard operating procedures is recommended, covering testing, interpretation, and reporting guidelines. Application of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of the rDNA array should be restricted to Old World samples, while the heat-shock protein 70 gene and the mini-exon can be applied globally.",
keywords = "Journal Article",
author = "{Van der Auwera}, Gert and Aldert Bart and Carmen Chicharro and Sofia Cortes and Leigh Davidsson and {Di Muccio}, Trentina and Jean-Claude Dujardin and Ingrid Felger and Paglia, {Maria Grazia} and Felix Grimm and Gundel Harms and Jaffe, {Charles L} and Monika Manser and Christophe Ravel and Florence Robert-Gangneux and Jeroen Roelfsema and Seray T{\"o}z and Verweij, {Jaco J} and Chiodini, {Peter L.}",
note = "This article is copyright of The Authors, 2016.",
year = "2016",
month = "12",
day = "8",
doi = "10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.49.30418",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
journal = "Eurosurveillance",
issn = "1560-7917",
publisher = "European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC)",
number = "49",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of Leishmania typing results obtained from 16 European clinical laboratories in 2014

AU - Van der Auwera, Gert

AU - Bart, Aldert

AU - Chicharro, Carmen

AU - Cortes, Sofia

AU - Davidsson, Leigh

AU - Di Muccio, Trentina

AU - Dujardin, Jean-Claude

AU - Felger, Ingrid

AU - Paglia, Maria Grazia

AU - Grimm, Felix

AU - Harms, Gundel

AU - Jaffe, Charles L

AU - Manser, Monika

AU - Ravel, Christophe

AU - Robert-Gangneux, Florence

AU - Roelfsema, Jeroen

AU - Töz, Seray

AU - Verweij, Jaco J

AU - Chiodini, Peter L.

N1 - This article is copyright of The Authors, 2016.

PY - 2016/12/8

Y1 - 2016/12/8

N2 - Leishmaniasis is endemic in southern Europe, and in other European countries cases are diagnosed in travellers who have visited affected areas both within the continent and beyond. Prompt and accurate diagnosis poses a challenge in clinical practice in Europe. Different methods exist for identification of the infecting Leishmania species. Sixteen clinical laboratories in 10 European countries, plus Israel and Turkey, conducted a study to assess their genotyping performance. DNA from 21 promastigote cultures of 13 species was analysed blindly by the routinely used typing method. Five different molecular targets were used, which were analysed with PCR-based methods. Different levels of identification were achieved, and either the Leishmania subgenus, species complex, or actual species were reported. The overall error rate of strains placed in the wrong complex or species was 8.5%. Various reasons for incorrect typing were identified. The study shows there is considerable room for improvement and standardisation of Leishmania typing. The use of well validated standard operating procedures is recommended, covering testing, interpretation, and reporting guidelines. Application of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of the rDNA array should be restricted to Old World samples, while the heat-shock protein 70 gene and the mini-exon can be applied globally.

AB - Leishmaniasis is endemic in southern Europe, and in other European countries cases are diagnosed in travellers who have visited affected areas both within the continent and beyond. Prompt and accurate diagnosis poses a challenge in clinical practice in Europe. Different methods exist for identification of the infecting Leishmania species. Sixteen clinical laboratories in 10 European countries, plus Israel and Turkey, conducted a study to assess their genotyping performance. DNA from 21 promastigote cultures of 13 species was analysed blindly by the routinely used typing method. Five different molecular targets were used, which were analysed with PCR-based methods. Different levels of identification were achieved, and either the Leishmania subgenus, species complex, or actual species were reported. The overall error rate of strains placed in the wrong complex or species was 8.5%. Various reasons for incorrect typing were identified. The study shows there is considerable room for improvement and standardisation of Leishmania typing. The use of well validated standard operating procedures is recommended, covering testing, interpretation, and reporting guidelines. Application of the internal transcribed spacer 1 of the rDNA array should be restricted to Old World samples, while the heat-shock protein 70 gene and the mini-exon can be applied globally.

KW - Journal Article

U2 - 10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.49.30418

DO - 10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2016.21.49.30418

M3 - Article

VL - 21

JO - Eurosurveillance

JF - Eurosurveillance

SN - 1560-7917

IS - 49

ER -