Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study)

Dominique Laude, Jean Luc Elghozi, Arlette Girard, Elisabeth Bellard, Malika Bouhaddi, Paolo Castiglioni, Catherine Cerutti, Andrei Cividjian, Marco Di Rienzo, Jacques Olivier Fortrat, Ben Janssen, John M. Karemaker, Georges Lefthériotis, Gianfranco Parati, Pontus B. Persson, Alberto Porta, Luc Quintin, Jacques Regnard, Heinz Rüdiger, Harald M. Stauss

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

283 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study compared spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) estimates obtained from an identical set of data by 11 European centers using different methods and procedures. Noninvasive blood pressure (BP) and ECG recordings were obtained in 21 subjects, including 2 subjects with established baroreflex failure. Twenty-one estimates of BRS were obtained by methods including the two main techniques of BRS estimates, i.e., the spectral analysis (11 procedures) and the sequence method (7 procedures) but also one trigonometric regressive spectral analysis method (TRS), one exogenous model with autoregressive input method (X-AR), and one Z method. With subjects in a supine position, BRS estimates obtained with calculations of α-coefficient or gain of the transfer function in both the low-frequency band or high-frequency band, TRS, and sequence methods gave strongly related results. Conversely, weighted gain, X-AR, and Z exhibited lower agreement with all the other techniques. In addition, the use of mean BP instead of systolic BP in the sequence method decreased the relationships with the other estimates. Some procedures were unable to provide results when BRS estimates were expected to be very low in data sets (in patients with established baroreflex failure). The failure to provide BRS values was due to setting of algorithmic parameters too strictly. The discrepancies between procedures show that the choice of parameters and data handling should be considered before BRS estimation. These data are available on the web site (http://www.cbi.polimi.it/glossary/eurobavar.html) to allow the comparison of new techniques with this set of results.

Original languageEnglish
JournalAmerican Journal of Physiology - Regulatory Integrative and Comparative Physiology
Volume286
Issue number1 55-1
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2004

Fingerprint

Baroreflex
Blood Pressure
Supine Position
Electrocardiography

Keywords

  • Autonomic nervous system
  • Baroreceptor reflex
  • Sequence technique
  • Spectral analysis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Physiology

Cite this

Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study). / Laude, Dominique; Elghozi, Jean Luc; Girard, Arlette; Bellard, Elisabeth; Bouhaddi, Malika; Castiglioni, Paolo; Cerutti, Catherine; Cividjian, Andrei; Di Rienzo, Marco; Fortrat, Jacques Olivier; Janssen, Ben; Karemaker, John M.; Lefthériotis, Georges; Parati, Gianfranco; Persson, Pontus B.; Porta, Alberto; Quintin, Luc; Regnard, Jacques; Rüdiger, Heinz; Stauss, Harald M.

In: American Journal of Physiology - Regulatory Integrative and Comparative Physiology, Vol. 286, No. 1 55-1, 01.2004.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Laude, D, Elghozi, JL, Girard, A, Bellard, E, Bouhaddi, M, Castiglioni, P, Cerutti, C, Cividjian, A, Di Rienzo, M, Fortrat, JO, Janssen, B, Karemaker, JM, Lefthériotis, G, Parati, G, Persson, PB, Porta, A, Quintin, L, Regnard, J, Rüdiger, H & Stauss, HM 2004, 'Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study)', American Journal of Physiology - Regulatory Integrative and Comparative Physiology, vol. 286, no. 1 55-1.
Laude, Dominique ; Elghozi, Jean Luc ; Girard, Arlette ; Bellard, Elisabeth ; Bouhaddi, Malika ; Castiglioni, Paolo ; Cerutti, Catherine ; Cividjian, Andrei ; Di Rienzo, Marco ; Fortrat, Jacques Olivier ; Janssen, Ben ; Karemaker, John M. ; Lefthériotis, Georges ; Parati, Gianfranco ; Persson, Pontus B. ; Porta, Alberto ; Quintin, Luc ; Regnard, Jacques ; Rüdiger, Heinz ; Stauss, Harald M. / Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study). In: American Journal of Physiology - Regulatory Integrative and Comparative Physiology. 2004 ; Vol. 286, No. 1 55-1.
@article{3bef0f8ee8e142318a45e2f6c6cc96ac,
title = "Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study)",
abstract = "This study compared spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) estimates obtained from an identical set of data by 11 European centers using different methods and procedures. Noninvasive blood pressure (BP) and ECG recordings were obtained in 21 subjects, including 2 subjects with established baroreflex failure. Twenty-one estimates of BRS were obtained by methods including the two main techniques of BRS estimates, i.e., the spectral analysis (11 procedures) and the sequence method (7 procedures) but also one trigonometric regressive spectral analysis method (TRS), one exogenous model with autoregressive input method (X-AR), and one Z method. With subjects in a supine position, BRS estimates obtained with calculations of α-coefficient or gain of the transfer function in both the low-frequency band or high-frequency band, TRS, and sequence methods gave strongly related results. Conversely, weighted gain, X-AR, and Z exhibited lower agreement with all the other techniques. In addition, the use of mean BP instead of systolic BP in the sequence method decreased the relationships with the other estimates. Some procedures were unable to provide results when BRS estimates were expected to be very low in data sets (in patients with established baroreflex failure). The failure to provide BRS values was due to setting of algorithmic parameters too strictly. The discrepancies between procedures show that the choice of parameters and data handling should be considered before BRS estimation. These data are available on the web site (http://www.cbi.polimi.it/glossary/eurobavar.html) to allow the comparison of new techniques with this set of results.",
keywords = "Autonomic nervous system, Baroreceptor reflex, Sequence technique, Spectral analysis",
author = "Dominique Laude and Elghozi, {Jean Luc} and Arlette Girard and Elisabeth Bellard and Malika Bouhaddi and Paolo Castiglioni and Catherine Cerutti and Andrei Cividjian and {Di Rienzo}, Marco and Fortrat, {Jacques Olivier} and Ben Janssen and Karemaker, {John M.} and Georges Lefth{\'e}riotis and Gianfranco Parati and Persson, {Pontus B.} and Alberto Porta and Luc Quintin and Jacques Regnard and Heinz R{\"u}diger and Stauss, {Harald M.}",
year = "2004",
month = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "286",
journal = "American Journal of Physiology",
issn = "0363-6119",
publisher = "American Physiological Society",
number = "1 55-1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of various techniques used to estimate spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (the EuroBaVar study)

AU - Laude, Dominique

AU - Elghozi, Jean Luc

AU - Girard, Arlette

AU - Bellard, Elisabeth

AU - Bouhaddi, Malika

AU - Castiglioni, Paolo

AU - Cerutti, Catherine

AU - Cividjian, Andrei

AU - Di Rienzo, Marco

AU - Fortrat, Jacques Olivier

AU - Janssen, Ben

AU - Karemaker, John M.

AU - Lefthériotis, Georges

AU - Parati, Gianfranco

AU - Persson, Pontus B.

AU - Porta, Alberto

AU - Quintin, Luc

AU - Regnard, Jacques

AU - Rüdiger, Heinz

AU - Stauss, Harald M.

PY - 2004/1

Y1 - 2004/1

N2 - This study compared spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) estimates obtained from an identical set of data by 11 European centers using different methods and procedures. Noninvasive blood pressure (BP) and ECG recordings were obtained in 21 subjects, including 2 subjects with established baroreflex failure. Twenty-one estimates of BRS were obtained by methods including the two main techniques of BRS estimates, i.e., the spectral analysis (11 procedures) and the sequence method (7 procedures) but also one trigonometric regressive spectral analysis method (TRS), one exogenous model with autoregressive input method (X-AR), and one Z method. With subjects in a supine position, BRS estimates obtained with calculations of α-coefficient or gain of the transfer function in both the low-frequency band or high-frequency band, TRS, and sequence methods gave strongly related results. Conversely, weighted gain, X-AR, and Z exhibited lower agreement with all the other techniques. In addition, the use of mean BP instead of systolic BP in the sequence method decreased the relationships with the other estimates. Some procedures were unable to provide results when BRS estimates were expected to be very low in data sets (in patients with established baroreflex failure). The failure to provide BRS values was due to setting of algorithmic parameters too strictly. The discrepancies between procedures show that the choice of parameters and data handling should be considered before BRS estimation. These data are available on the web site (http://www.cbi.polimi.it/glossary/eurobavar.html) to allow the comparison of new techniques with this set of results.

AB - This study compared spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) estimates obtained from an identical set of data by 11 European centers using different methods and procedures. Noninvasive blood pressure (BP) and ECG recordings were obtained in 21 subjects, including 2 subjects with established baroreflex failure. Twenty-one estimates of BRS were obtained by methods including the two main techniques of BRS estimates, i.e., the spectral analysis (11 procedures) and the sequence method (7 procedures) but also one trigonometric regressive spectral analysis method (TRS), one exogenous model with autoregressive input method (X-AR), and one Z method. With subjects in a supine position, BRS estimates obtained with calculations of α-coefficient or gain of the transfer function in both the low-frequency band or high-frequency band, TRS, and sequence methods gave strongly related results. Conversely, weighted gain, X-AR, and Z exhibited lower agreement with all the other techniques. In addition, the use of mean BP instead of systolic BP in the sequence method decreased the relationships with the other estimates. Some procedures were unable to provide results when BRS estimates were expected to be very low in data sets (in patients with established baroreflex failure). The failure to provide BRS values was due to setting of algorithmic parameters too strictly. The discrepancies between procedures show that the choice of parameters and data handling should be considered before BRS estimation. These data are available on the web site (http://www.cbi.polimi.it/glossary/eurobavar.html) to allow the comparison of new techniques with this set of results.

KW - Autonomic nervous system

KW - Baroreceptor reflex

KW - Sequence technique

KW - Spectral analysis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=9144225480&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=9144225480&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 14500269

AN - SCOPUS:9144225480

VL - 286

JO - American Journal of Physiology

JF - American Journal of Physiology

SN - 0363-6119

IS - 1 55-1

ER -