Dealing with individual variability

When telling what is real depends on telling who is acting

Elena Daprati, Selina Wriessnegger, Francesco Lacquaniti

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

You are queuing at the bus stop, and notice that someone suddenly turns her walk into a run: typically, you assume that she wants to catch the bus and may want to tell the driver to wait. Faced with a sudden speed change, rather than considering it bizarre or unnatural, observers attach a meaning to it, and act consequently. In a social context, speed of a movement often bears as much significance as its form, and can be adapted to vehicle precise meanings. This pragmatic rule facilitates decoding of non-verbal messages from other individuals, but may not necessarily apply when observing one's own movements, for which intentions should be informative enough. Hence, the range of motion speeds labeled as 'natural' could be broader for other people's actions compared to one's own. We explored this possibility through a task in which human observers decided whether speed of a gesture had been artificially modified. A virtual hand was presented, which - unbeknownst to participants - moved according to the kinematics of either the observer, or another individual. Although a self/other distinction was never required, participants applied different criteria when dealing with self compared to other people's gestures, suggesting that the brain implicitly extracts identity information before any overt judgment is produced. Interestingly, observers were reluctant to labeling movements of another individual as artificial, in keeping with the hypothesis that large variations in movements' speed can vehicle social messages, and therefore are not regarded a priori as unnatural.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)6-9
Number of pages4
JournalNeuroscience Letters
Volume498
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 1 2011

Fingerprint

Gestures
Motor Vehicles
Ego
Articular Range of Motion
Biomechanical Phenomena
Hand
Brain

Keywords

  • Action observation
  • Biological motion
  • Extra-striate body area
  • Hand gestures
  • Self
  • Social interactions

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Dealing with individual variability : When telling what is real depends on telling who is acting. / Daprati, Elena; Wriessnegger, Selina; Lacquaniti, Francesco.

In: Neuroscience Letters, Vol. 498, No. 1, 01.07.2011, p. 6-9.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{8516839a6d8745dbb483f4c574dbe102,
title = "Dealing with individual variability: When telling what is real depends on telling who is acting",
abstract = "You are queuing at the bus stop, and notice that someone suddenly turns her walk into a run: typically, you assume that she wants to catch the bus and may want to tell the driver to wait. Faced with a sudden speed change, rather than considering it bizarre or unnatural, observers attach a meaning to it, and act consequently. In a social context, speed of a movement often bears as much significance as its form, and can be adapted to vehicle precise meanings. This pragmatic rule facilitates decoding of non-verbal messages from other individuals, but may not necessarily apply when observing one's own movements, for which intentions should be informative enough. Hence, the range of motion speeds labeled as 'natural' could be broader for other people's actions compared to one's own. We explored this possibility through a task in which human observers decided whether speed of a gesture had been artificially modified. A virtual hand was presented, which - unbeknownst to participants - moved according to the kinematics of either the observer, or another individual. Although a self/other distinction was never required, participants applied different criteria when dealing with self compared to other people's gestures, suggesting that the brain implicitly extracts identity information before any overt judgment is produced. Interestingly, observers were reluctant to labeling movements of another individual as artificial, in keeping with the hypothesis that large variations in movements' speed can vehicle social messages, and therefore are not regarded a priori as unnatural.",
keywords = "Action observation, Biological motion, Extra-striate body area, Hand gestures, Self, Social interactions",
author = "Elena Daprati and Selina Wriessnegger and Francesco Lacquaniti",
year = "2011",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.neulet.2011.04.032",
language = "English",
volume = "498",
pages = "6--9",
journal = "Neuroscience Letters",
issn = "0304-3940",
publisher = "Elsevier Ireland Ltd",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Dealing with individual variability

T2 - When telling what is real depends on telling who is acting

AU - Daprati, Elena

AU - Wriessnegger, Selina

AU - Lacquaniti, Francesco

PY - 2011/7/1

Y1 - 2011/7/1

N2 - You are queuing at the bus stop, and notice that someone suddenly turns her walk into a run: typically, you assume that she wants to catch the bus and may want to tell the driver to wait. Faced with a sudden speed change, rather than considering it bizarre or unnatural, observers attach a meaning to it, and act consequently. In a social context, speed of a movement often bears as much significance as its form, and can be adapted to vehicle precise meanings. This pragmatic rule facilitates decoding of non-verbal messages from other individuals, but may not necessarily apply when observing one's own movements, for which intentions should be informative enough. Hence, the range of motion speeds labeled as 'natural' could be broader for other people's actions compared to one's own. We explored this possibility through a task in which human observers decided whether speed of a gesture had been artificially modified. A virtual hand was presented, which - unbeknownst to participants - moved according to the kinematics of either the observer, or another individual. Although a self/other distinction was never required, participants applied different criteria when dealing with self compared to other people's gestures, suggesting that the brain implicitly extracts identity information before any overt judgment is produced. Interestingly, observers were reluctant to labeling movements of another individual as artificial, in keeping with the hypothesis that large variations in movements' speed can vehicle social messages, and therefore are not regarded a priori as unnatural.

AB - You are queuing at the bus stop, and notice that someone suddenly turns her walk into a run: typically, you assume that she wants to catch the bus and may want to tell the driver to wait. Faced with a sudden speed change, rather than considering it bizarre or unnatural, observers attach a meaning to it, and act consequently. In a social context, speed of a movement often bears as much significance as its form, and can be adapted to vehicle precise meanings. This pragmatic rule facilitates decoding of non-verbal messages from other individuals, but may not necessarily apply when observing one's own movements, for which intentions should be informative enough. Hence, the range of motion speeds labeled as 'natural' could be broader for other people's actions compared to one's own. We explored this possibility through a task in which human observers decided whether speed of a gesture had been artificially modified. A virtual hand was presented, which - unbeknownst to participants - moved according to the kinematics of either the observer, or another individual. Although a self/other distinction was never required, participants applied different criteria when dealing with self compared to other people's gestures, suggesting that the brain implicitly extracts identity information before any overt judgment is produced. Interestingly, observers were reluctant to labeling movements of another individual as artificial, in keeping with the hypothesis that large variations in movements' speed can vehicle social messages, and therefore are not regarded a priori as unnatural.

KW - Action observation

KW - Biological motion

KW - Extra-striate body area

KW - Hand gestures

KW - Self

KW - Social interactions

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79958097138&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79958097138&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.neulet.2011.04.032

DO - 10.1016/j.neulet.2011.04.032

M3 - Article

VL - 498

SP - 6

EP - 9

JO - Neuroscience Letters

JF - Neuroscience Letters

SN - 0304-3940

IS - 1

ER -