Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies

Ursula Hohl, Pietro Tiraboschi, Lawrence A. Hansen, Leon J. Thal, Jody Corey-Bloom

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

96 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Diagnostic criteria for dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) are still evolving. No data exist on prospective differentiation of DLB and Alzheimer disease (AD). Objective: To examine the clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB and analyze factors contributing to false-positive DLB diagnoses. Methods: A prospective series of 10 patients with clinically diagnosed DLB who came to autopsy was compared with 32 autopsy-confirmed cases of DLB (27 Lewy body variant, 5 diffuse Lewy body disease) and 20 autopsy-confirmed cases of AD (matched on age, sex, education, and initial Mini-Mental State Examination score) with regard to distinguishing and/or confounding clinical features. Results: The clinical diagnostic accuracy for DLB was 50%, with 5 of the 10 patients clinically presumed to have DLB confirmed at autopsy. Of the 5 misdiagnosed cases, 4 had AD and 1 had progressive supranuclear palsy. The misdiagnosed DLB cases who had pure AD had fewer hallucinations (25%) than those with Lewy body variant (63%) or diffuse Lewy body disease (100%) (P = .048); however, an equal amount of spontaneous (in the absence of neuroleptics) extrapyramidal signs was found. There were no differences among groups with regard to daily fluctuations in cognition or falls. Compared with the AD control group, the misdiagnosed DLB cases with pure AD showed significantly more spontaneous extrapyramidal signs (P ≤ .02). Conclusions: The clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB was poor. Early spontaneous extrapyramidal signs in AD were associated with false-positive clinical diagnoses of DLB. The distinction between DLB and AD may be improved by greater emphasis on hallucinations.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)347-351
Number of pages5
JournalArchives of Neurology
Volume57
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2000

Fingerprint

Lewy Body Disease
Alzheimer Disease
Autopsy
Diagnostic Errors
Lewy Bodies
Hallucinations
Dementia
Diagnostic Accuracy
Progressive Supranuclear Palsy
Sex Education
Alzheimer's Disease

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Hohl, U., Tiraboschi, P., Hansen, L. A., Thal, L. J., & Corey-Bloom, J. (2000). Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies. Archives of Neurology, 57(3), 347-351.

Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies. / Hohl, Ursula; Tiraboschi, Pietro; Hansen, Lawrence A.; Thal, Leon J.; Corey-Bloom, Jody.

In: Archives of Neurology, Vol. 57, No. 3, 03.2000, p. 347-351.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hohl, U, Tiraboschi, P, Hansen, LA, Thal, LJ & Corey-Bloom, J 2000, 'Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies', Archives of Neurology, vol. 57, no. 3, pp. 347-351.
Hohl U, Tiraboschi P, Hansen LA, Thal LJ, Corey-Bloom J. Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies. Archives of Neurology. 2000 Mar;57(3):347-351.
Hohl, Ursula ; Tiraboschi, Pietro ; Hansen, Lawrence A. ; Thal, Leon J. ; Corey-Bloom, Jody. / Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies. In: Archives of Neurology. 2000 ; Vol. 57, No. 3. pp. 347-351.
@article{7aaaa3481953414cb3ddf5831d002ce3,
title = "Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies",
abstract = "Background: Diagnostic criteria for dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) are still evolving. No data exist on prospective differentiation of DLB and Alzheimer disease (AD). Objective: To examine the clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB and analyze factors contributing to false-positive DLB diagnoses. Methods: A prospective series of 10 patients with clinically diagnosed DLB who came to autopsy was compared with 32 autopsy-confirmed cases of DLB (27 Lewy body variant, 5 diffuse Lewy body disease) and 20 autopsy-confirmed cases of AD (matched on age, sex, education, and initial Mini-Mental State Examination score) with regard to distinguishing and/or confounding clinical features. Results: The clinical diagnostic accuracy for DLB was 50{\%}, with 5 of the 10 patients clinically presumed to have DLB confirmed at autopsy. Of the 5 misdiagnosed cases, 4 had AD and 1 had progressive supranuclear palsy. The misdiagnosed DLB cases who had pure AD had fewer hallucinations (25{\%}) than those with Lewy body variant (63{\%}) or diffuse Lewy body disease (100{\%}) (P = .048); however, an equal amount of spontaneous (in the absence of neuroleptics) extrapyramidal signs was found. There were no differences among groups with regard to daily fluctuations in cognition or falls. Compared with the AD control group, the misdiagnosed DLB cases with pure AD showed significantly more spontaneous extrapyramidal signs (P ≤ .02). Conclusions: The clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB was poor. Early spontaneous extrapyramidal signs in AD were associated with false-positive clinical diagnoses of DLB. The distinction between DLB and AD may be improved by greater emphasis on hallucinations.",
author = "Ursula Hohl and Pietro Tiraboschi and Hansen, {Lawrence A.} and Thal, {Leon J.} and Jody Corey-Bloom",
year = "2000",
month = "3",
language = "English",
volume = "57",
pages = "347--351",
journal = "Archives of Neurology",
issn = "0003-9942",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Diagnostic accuracy of dementia with Lewy bodies

AU - Hohl, Ursula

AU - Tiraboschi, Pietro

AU - Hansen, Lawrence A.

AU - Thal, Leon J.

AU - Corey-Bloom, Jody

PY - 2000/3

Y1 - 2000/3

N2 - Background: Diagnostic criteria for dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) are still evolving. No data exist on prospective differentiation of DLB and Alzheimer disease (AD). Objective: To examine the clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB and analyze factors contributing to false-positive DLB diagnoses. Methods: A prospective series of 10 patients with clinically diagnosed DLB who came to autopsy was compared with 32 autopsy-confirmed cases of DLB (27 Lewy body variant, 5 diffuse Lewy body disease) and 20 autopsy-confirmed cases of AD (matched on age, sex, education, and initial Mini-Mental State Examination score) with regard to distinguishing and/or confounding clinical features. Results: The clinical diagnostic accuracy for DLB was 50%, with 5 of the 10 patients clinically presumed to have DLB confirmed at autopsy. Of the 5 misdiagnosed cases, 4 had AD and 1 had progressive supranuclear palsy. The misdiagnosed DLB cases who had pure AD had fewer hallucinations (25%) than those with Lewy body variant (63%) or diffuse Lewy body disease (100%) (P = .048); however, an equal amount of spontaneous (in the absence of neuroleptics) extrapyramidal signs was found. There were no differences among groups with regard to daily fluctuations in cognition or falls. Compared with the AD control group, the misdiagnosed DLB cases with pure AD showed significantly more spontaneous extrapyramidal signs (P ≤ .02). Conclusions: The clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB was poor. Early spontaneous extrapyramidal signs in AD were associated with false-positive clinical diagnoses of DLB. The distinction between DLB and AD may be improved by greater emphasis on hallucinations.

AB - Background: Diagnostic criteria for dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) are still evolving. No data exist on prospective differentiation of DLB and Alzheimer disease (AD). Objective: To examine the clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB and analyze factors contributing to false-positive DLB diagnoses. Methods: A prospective series of 10 patients with clinically diagnosed DLB who came to autopsy was compared with 32 autopsy-confirmed cases of DLB (27 Lewy body variant, 5 diffuse Lewy body disease) and 20 autopsy-confirmed cases of AD (matched on age, sex, education, and initial Mini-Mental State Examination score) with regard to distinguishing and/or confounding clinical features. Results: The clinical diagnostic accuracy for DLB was 50%, with 5 of the 10 patients clinically presumed to have DLB confirmed at autopsy. Of the 5 misdiagnosed cases, 4 had AD and 1 had progressive supranuclear palsy. The misdiagnosed DLB cases who had pure AD had fewer hallucinations (25%) than those with Lewy body variant (63%) or diffuse Lewy body disease (100%) (P = .048); however, an equal amount of spontaneous (in the absence of neuroleptics) extrapyramidal signs was found. There were no differences among groups with regard to daily fluctuations in cognition or falls. Compared with the AD control group, the misdiagnosed DLB cases with pure AD showed significantly more spontaneous extrapyramidal signs (P ≤ .02). Conclusions: The clinician's diagnostic accuracy for DLB was poor. Early spontaneous extrapyramidal signs in AD were associated with false-positive clinical diagnoses of DLB. The distinction between DLB and AD may be improved by greater emphasis on hallucinations.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034015590&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034015590&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 10714660

AN - SCOPUS:0034015590

VL - 57

SP - 347

EP - 351

JO - Archives of Neurology

JF - Archives of Neurology

SN - 0003-9942

IS - 3

ER -