Concordanza interosservatore nella diagnosi video-polisonnografica di epilessia frontale notturna

Translated title of the contribution: Difficulties in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures: A study on interobserver reliability of video recordings

I. Naldi, L. Vignatelli, F. Bisulli, F. Provini, A. Zaniboni, L. Licchetta, F. Pittau, P. Montagna, P. Tinuper

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy (NFLE) is mainly based on video-polysomnographic examination of nocturnal episodes. The clinical spectrum of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) includes one or all of the following semiological patterns: 1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behaviour), 2) hypercinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features) 3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizure (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features), 4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behaviour mimicking somnambulism). The aim of this study was to estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-polysomnographic diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists and trainees in sleep medicine. Sixty-six patients referred to our sleep centre for suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (3 experts and 3 trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). The observed raw agreement on the diagnosis of NFLS ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). The major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and non-epileptic arousal episodes. There were no differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Among sleep medicine/epileptologist experts and trainees, interobserver reliability of diagnosis of NFLS on the basis of videotaped observation of sleep motor phenomena is not satisfactory. One of the sources of variance is probably the interpretation of motor phenomena resembling simple arousals or PA. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

Original languageItalian
Pages (from-to)75-76
Number of pages2
JournalBollettino - Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia
Issue number133-134
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2006

Fingerprint

Video Recording
Frontal Lobe
Seizures
Sleep
Arousal
Somnambulism
Medicine
Frontal Lobe Epilepsy
Narcolepsy
Observation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Concordanza interosservatore nella diagnosi video-polisonnografica di epilessia frontale notturna. / Naldi, I.; Vignatelli, L.; Bisulli, F.; Provini, F.; Zaniboni, A.; Licchetta, L.; Pittau, F.; Montagna, P.; Tinuper, P.

In: Bollettino - Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia, No. 133-134, 07.2006, p. 75-76.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9acdc18e136f404a855845cd9af87623,
title = "Concordanza interosservatore nella diagnosi video-polisonnografica di epilessia frontale notturna",
abstract = "The diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy (NFLE) is mainly based on video-polysomnographic examination of nocturnal episodes. The clinical spectrum of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) includes one or all of the following semiological patterns: 1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behaviour), 2) hypercinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features) 3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizure (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features), 4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behaviour mimicking somnambulism). The aim of this study was to estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-polysomnographic diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists and trainees in sleep medicine. Sixty-six patients referred to our sleep centre for suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (3 experts and 3 trainees) independently classified each case as {"}NFLS ascertained{"} (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or {"}NFLS excluded{"}. IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). The observed raw agreement on the diagnosis of NFLS ranged from 63{\%} to 79{\%} between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from {"}moderate{"} (kappa = 0.50) to {"}substantial{"} (kappa = 0.72). The major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and non-epileptic arousal episodes. There were no differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Among sleep medicine/epileptologist experts and trainees, interobserver reliability of diagnosis of NFLS on the basis of videotaped observation of sleep motor phenomena is not satisfactory. One of the sources of variance is probably the interpretation of motor phenomena resembling simple arousals or PA. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.",
keywords = "Diagnosis, Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures, Parasomnias, Paroxysmal motor phenomena during sleep, Reliability of results, Video-recording",
author = "I. Naldi and L. Vignatelli and F. Bisulli and F. Provini and A. Zaniboni and L. Licchetta and F. Pittau and P. Montagna and P. Tinuper",
year = "2006",
month = "7",
language = "Italian",
pages = "75--76",
journal = "Bollettino - Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia",
issn = "0394-560X",
publisher = "Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia",
number = "133-134",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Concordanza interosservatore nella diagnosi video-polisonnografica di epilessia frontale notturna

AU - Naldi, I.

AU - Vignatelli, L.

AU - Bisulli, F.

AU - Provini, F.

AU - Zaniboni, A.

AU - Licchetta, L.

AU - Pittau, F.

AU - Montagna, P.

AU - Tinuper, P.

PY - 2006/7

Y1 - 2006/7

N2 - The diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy (NFLE) is mainly based on video-polysomnographic examination of nocturnal episodes. The clinical spectrum of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) includes one or all of the following semiological patterns: 1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behaviour), 2) hypercinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features) 3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizure (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features), 4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behaviour mimicking somnambulism). The aim of this study was to estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-polysomnographic diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists and trainees in sleep medicine. Sixty-six patients referred to our sleep centre for suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (3 experts and 3 trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). The observed raw agreement on the diagnosis of NFLS ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). The major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and non-epileptic arousal episodes. There were no differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Among sleep medicine/epileptologist experts and trainees, interobserver reliability of diagnosis of NFLS on the basis of videotaped observation of sleep motor phenomena is not satisfactory. One of the sources of variance is probably the interpretation of motor phenomena resembling simple arousals or PA. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

AB - The diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe epilepsy (NFLE) is mainly based on video-polysomnographic examination of nocturnal episodes. The clinical spectrum of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) includes one or all of the following semiological patterns: 1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behaviour), 2) hypercinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features) 3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizure (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features), 4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behaviour mimicking somnambulism). The aim of this study was to estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-polysomnographic diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists and trainees in sleep medicine. Sixty-six patients referred to our sleep centre for suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (3 experts and 3 trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). The observed raw agreement on the diagnosis of NFLS ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). The major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and non-epileptic arousal episodes. There were no differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Among sleep medicine/epileptologist experts and trainees, interobserver reliability of diagnosis of NFLS on the basis of videotaped observation of sleep motor phenomena is not satisfactory. One of the sources of variance is probably the interpretation of motor phenomena resembling simple arousals or PA. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

KW - Diagnosis

KW - Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures

KW - Parasomnias

KW - Paroxysmal motor phenomena during sleep

KW - Reliability of results

KW - Video-recording

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33847637264&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33847637264&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Articolo

SP - 75

EP - 76

JO - Bollettino - Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia

JF - Bollettino - Lega Italiana contro l'Epilessia

SN - 0394-560X

IS - 133-134

ER -