EEG rhythms lateralization patterns in children with unilateral hearing loss are different from the patterns of normal hearing controls during speech-in-noise listening

Giulia Cartocci, Alessandro Scorpecci, Gianluca Borghini, Anton Giulio Maglione, Bianca Maria Serena Inguscio, Sara Giannantonio, Andrea Giorgi, Paolo Malerba, Dario Rossi, Enrica Modica, Pietro Aricò, Gianluca Di Flumeri, Pasquale Marsella, Fabio Babiloni

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Unilateral hearing loss constitutes a field of growing interest in the scientific community. In fact, this kind of patients represent a unique and physiological way to investigate how neuroplasticity overcame unilateral deafferentation by implementing particular strategies that produce apparently next- to- normal hearing behavioural performances. This explains why such patients have been underinvestigated for a long time. Thanks to the availability of techniques able to study the cerebral activity underlying the mentioned behavioural outcomes, the aim of the present research was to elucidate whether different electroencephalographic (EEG)patterns occurred in unilateral hearing loss (UHL)children in comparison to normal hearing (NH)controls during speech-in-noise listening. Given the intrinsic lateralized nature of such patients, due to the unilateral side of hearing impairment, the experimental question was to assess whether this would reflect a different EEG pattern while performing a word in noise recognition task varying the direction of the noise source. Results showed a correlation between the period of deafness and the cortical activity asymmetry toward the hearing ear side in the frontal, parietal and occipital areas in all the experimental conditions. Concerning alpha and beta activity in the frontal and central areas highlighted that in the NH group, the lateralization was always left-sided during the Quiet condition, while it was right-sided in noise conditions; this evidence was not, however, detected also in the UHL group. In addition, focusing on the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)during noise conditions, while the activity was always left-lateralized in the NH group, it was ipsilateral to the direction of the background noise in the UHL group, and of a weaker extent than in NH controls. Furthermore, in noise conditions, only the UHL group showed a higher theta activity in the temporal areas ipsilateral to the side where the background noise was directed to. Finally, in the case of bilateral noise (background noise and word signal both coming from the same two sources), the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)was left-lateralized in the case of the NH group and lateralized towards the side of the better hearing ear in the case of the UHL group. Taken together, this evidence supports the establishment of a particular EEG pattern occurrence in UHL children taking place in the frontal (Broca area), temporal and parietal lobes, probably physiologically established in order to deal with different sound and noise source directions.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)31-42
Number of pages12
JournalHearing Research
Volume379
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 1 2019

Fingerprint

Unilateral Hearing Loss
Hearing
Noise
Ear
Central Hearing Loss
Parietal Lobe
Neuronal Plasticity
Temporal Lobe
Hearing Loss

Keywords

  • Alpha
  • Beta
  • Deafness
  • Gamma
  • Theta
  • Word in noise recognition

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Sensory Systems

Cite this

EEG rhythms lateralization patterns in children with unilateral hearing loss are different from the patterns of normal hearing controls during speech-in-noise listening. / Cartocci, Giulia; Scorpecci, Alessandro; Borghini, Gianluca; Maglione, Anton Giulio; Inguscio, Bianca Maria Serena; Giannantonio, Sara; Giorgi, Andrea; Malerba, Paolo; Rossi, Dario; Modica, Enrica; Aricò, Pietro; Di Flumeri, Gianluca; Marsella, Pasquale; Babiloni, Fabio.

In: Hearing Research, Vol. 379, 01.08.2019, p. 31-42.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9da36b1a04fc4c26a32fa289914968fb,
title = "EEG rhythms lateralization patterns in children with unilateral hearing loss are different from the patterns of normal hearing controls during speech-in-noise listening",
abstract = "Unilateral hearing loss constitutes a field of growing interest in the scientific community. In fact, this kind of patients represent a unique and physiological way to investigate how neuroplasticity overcame unilateral deafferentation by implementing particular strategies that produce apparently next- to- normal hearing behavioural performances. This explains why such patients have been underinvestigated for a long time. Thanks to the availability of techniques able to study the cerebral activity underlying the mentioned behavioural outcomes, the aim of the present research was to elucidate whether different electroencephalographic (EEG)patterns occurred in unilateral hearing loss (UHL)children in comparison to normal hearing (NH)controls during speech-in-noise listening. Given the intrinsic lateralized nature of such patients, due to the unilateral side of hearing impairment, the experimental question was to assess whether this would reflect a different EEG pattern while performing a word in noise recognition task varying the direction of the noise source. Results showed a correlation between the period of deafness and the cortical activity asymmetry toward the hearing ear side in the frontal, parietal and occipital areas in all the experimental conditions. Concerning alpha and beta activity in the frontal and central areas highlighted that in the NH group, the lateralization was always left-sided during the Quiet condition, while it was right-sided in noise conditions; this evidence was not, however, detected also in the UHL group. In addition, focusing on the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)during noise conditions, while the activity was always left-lateralized in the NH group, it was ipsilateral to the direction of the background noise in the UHL group, and of a weaker extent than in NH controls. Furthermore, in noise conditions, only the UHL group showed a higher theta activity in the temporal areas ipsilateral to the side where the background noise was directed to. Finally, in the case of bilateral noise (background noise and word signal both coming from the same two sources), the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)was left-lateralized in the case of the NH group and lateralized towards the side of the better hearing ear in the case of the UHL group. Taken together, this evidence supports the establishment of a particular EEG pattern occurrence in UHL children taking place in the frontal (Broca area), temporal and parietal lobes, probably physiologically established in order to deal with different sound and noise source directions.",
keywords = "Alpha, Beta, Deafness, Gamma, Theta, Word in noise recognition",
author = "Giulia Cartocci and Alessandro Scorpecci and Gianluca Borghini and Maglione, {Anton Giulio} and Inguscio, {Bianca Maria Serena} and Sara Giannantonio and Andrea Giorgi and Paolo Malerba and Dario Rossi and Enrica Modica and Pietro Aric{\`o} and {Di Flumeri}, Gianluca and Pasquale Marsella and Fabio Babiloni",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.011",
language = "English",
volume = "379",
pages = "31--42",
journal = "Hearing Research",
issn = "0378-5955",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - EEG rhythms lateralization patterns in children with unilateral hearing loss are different from the patterns of normal hearing controls during speech-in-noise listening

AU - Cartocci, Giulia

AU - Scorpecci, Alessandro

AU - Borghini, Gianluca

AU - Maglione, Anton Giulio

AU - Inguscio, Bianca Maria Serena

AU - Giannantonio, Sara

AU - Giorgi, Andrea

AU - Malerba, Paolo

AU - Rossi, Dario

AU - Modica, Enrica

AU - Aricò, Pietro

AU - Di Flumeri, Gianluca

AU - Marsella, Pasquale

AU - Babiloni, Fabio

PY - 2019/8/1

Y1 - 2019/8/1

N2 - Unilateral hearing loss constitutes a field of growing interest in the scientific community. In fact, this kind of patients represent a unique and physiological way to investigate how neuroplasticity overcame unilateral deafferentation by implementing particular strategies that produce apparently next- to- normal hearing behavioural performances. This explains why such patients have been underinvestigated for a long time. Thanks to the availability of techniques able to study the cerebral activity underlying the mentioned behavioural outcomes, the aim of the present research was to elucidate whether different electroencephalographic (EEG)patterns occurred in unilateral hearing loss (UHL)children in comparison to normal hearing (NH)controls during speech-in-noise listening. Given the intrinsic lateralized nature of such patients, due to the unilateral side of hearing impairment, the experimental question was to assess whether this would reflect a different EEG pattern while performing a word in noise recognition task varying the direction of the noise source. Results showed a correlation between the period of deafness and the cortical activity asymmetry toward the hearing ear side in the frontal, parietal and occipital areas in all the experimental conditions. Concerning alpha and beta activity in the frontal and central areas highlighted that in the NH group, the lateralization was always left-sided during the Quiet condition, while it was right-sided in noise conditions; this evidence was not, however, detected also in the UHL group. In addition, focusing on the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)during noise conditions, while the activity was always left-lateralized in the NH group, it was ipsilateral to the direction of the background noise in the UHL group, and of a weaker extent than in NH controls. Furthermore, in noise conditions, only the UHL group showed a higher theta activity in the temporal areas ipsilateral to the side where the background noise was directed to. Finally, in the case of bilateral noise (background noise and word signal both coming from the same two sources), the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)was left-lateralized in the case of the NH group and lateralized towards the side of the better hearing ear in the case of the UHL group. Taken together, this evidence supports the establishment of a particular EEG pattern occurrence in UHL children taking place in the frontal (Broca area), temporal and parietal lobes, probably physiologically established in order to deal with different sound and noise source directions.

AB - Unilateral hearing loss constitutes a field of growing interest in the scientific community. In fact, this kind of patients represent a unique and physiological way to investigate how neuroplasticity overcame unilateral deafferentation by implementing particular strategies that produce apparently next- to- normal hearing behavioural performances. This explains why such patients have been underinvestigated for a long time. Thanks to the availability of techniques able to study the cerebral activity underlying the mentioned behavioural outcomes, the aim of the present research was to elucidate whether different electroencephalographic (EEG)patterns occurred in unilateral hearing loss (UHL)children in comparison to normal hearing (NH)controls during speech-in-noise listening. Given the intrinsic lateralized nature of such patients, due to the unilateral side of hearing impairment, the experimental question was to assess whether this would reflect a different EEG pattern while performing a word in noise recognition task varying the direction of the noise source. Results showed a correlation between the period of deafness and the cortical activity asymmetry toward the hearing ear side in the frontal, parietal and occipital areas in all the experimental conditions. Concerning alpha and beta activity in the frontal and central areas highlighted that in the NH group, the lateralization was always left-sided during the Quiet condition, while it was right-sided in noise conditions; this evidence was not, however, detected also in the UHL group. In addition, focusing on the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)during noise conditions, while the activity was always left-lateralized in the NH group, it was ipsilateral to the direction of the background noise in the UHL group, and of a weaker extent than in NH controls. Furthermore, in noise conditions, only the UHL group showed a higher theta activity in the temporal areas ipsilateral to the side where the background noise was directed to. Finally, in the case of bilateral noise (background noise and word signal both coming from the same two sources), the theta and alpha activity in the frontal areas (Broca area)was left-lateralized in the case of the NH group and lateralized towards the side of the better hearing ear in the case of the UHL group. Taken together, this evidence supports the establishment of a particular EEG pattern occurrence in UHL children taking place in the frontal (Broca area), temporal and parietal lobes, probably physiologically established in order to deal with different sound and noise source directions.

KW - Alpha

KW - Beta

KW - Deafness

KW - Gamma

KW - Theta

KW - Word in noise recognition

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064625048&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85064625048&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.011

DO - 10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.011

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85064625048

VL - 379

SP - 31

EP - 42

JO - Hearing Research

JF - Hearing Research

SN - 0378-5955

ER -