Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology: a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial

Sibylle Gündisch, Julia Slotta-Huspenina, Paolo Verderio, Chiara Maura Ciniselli, Sara Pizzamiglio, Christina Schott, Enken Drecoll, Christian Viertler, Kurt Zatloukal, Marcel Kap, Peter Riegman, Irene Esposito, Katja Specht, Gregor Babaryka, Martin Asslaber, Koppany Bodó, Michael den Bakker, Jan den Hollander, Falko Fend, Jens NeumannSimone Reu, Aurel Perren, Rupert Langer, Alessandro Lugli, Ingrid Becker, Thomas Richter, Gian Kayser, Annette M. May, Fatima Carneiro, José Manuel Lopes, Leslie Sobin, Heinz Höfler, Karl Friedrich Becker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The aim of our study was to evaluate the quality of histo- and cytomorphological features of PAXgene-fixed specimens and their suitability for histomorphological classification in comparison to standard formalin fixation. Fifteen colon cancer tissues were collected, divided into two mirrored samples and either formalin fixed (FFPE) or PAXgene fixed (PFPE) before paraffin embedding. HE- and PAS-stained sections were scanned and evaluated in a blinded, randomised ring trial by 20 pathologists from Europe and the USA using virtual microscopy. The pathologists evaluated histological grading, histological subtype, presence of adenoma, presence of lymphovascular invasion, quality of histomorphology and quality of nuclear features. Statistical analysis revealed that the reproducibility with regard to grading between both fixation methods was rather satisfactory (weighted kappa statistic (kw) = 0.73 (95 % confidence interval (CI), 0.41–0.94)), with a higher agreement between the reference evaluation and the PFPE samples (kw = 0.86 (95 % CI, 0.67–1.00)). Independent from preservation method, inter-observer reproducibility was not completely satisfactory (kw = 0.60). Histomorphological quality parameters were scored equal or better for PFPE than for FFPE samples. For example, overall quality and nuclear features, especially the detection of mitosis, were judged significantly better for PFPE cases. By contrast, significant retraction artefacts were observed more frequently in PFPE samples. In conclusion, our findings suggest that the PAXgene Tissue System leads to excellent preservation of histomorphology and nuclear features of colon cancer tissue and allows routine morphological diagnosis.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)509-519
Number of pages11
JournalVirchows Archiv
Volume465
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Tissue Fixation
Colonic Neoplasms
Formaldehyde
Paraffin Embedding
Confidence Intervals
Mitosis
Adenoma
Artifacts
Microscopy
Pathologists

Keywords

  • Colon cancer
  • Formalin free
  • Histomorphology
  • Molecular diagnostic
  • Reproducibility
  • Tissue preservation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pathology and Forensic Medicine
  • Cell Biology
  • Molecular Biology
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology : a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial. / Gündisch, Sibylle; Slotta-Huspenina, Julia; Verderio, Paolo; Ciniselli, Chiara Maura; Pizzamiglio, Sara; Schott, Christina; Drecoll, Enken; Viertler, Christian; Zatloukal, Kurt; Kap, Marcel; Riegman, Peter; Esposito, Irene; Specht, Katja; Babaryka, Gregor; Asslaber, Martin; Bodó, Koppany; den Bakker, Michael; den Hollander, Jan; Fend, Falko; Neumann, Jens; Reu, Simone; Perren, Aurel; Langer, Rupert; Lugli, Alessandro; Becker, Ingrid; Richter, Thomas; Kayser, Gian; May, Annette M.; Carneiro, Fatima; Lopes, José Manuel; Sobin, Leslie; Höfler, Heinz; Becker, Karl Friedrich.

In: Virchows Archiv, Vol. 465, No. 5, 2014, p. 509-519.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gündisch, S, Slotta-Huspenina, J, Verderio, P, Ciniselli, CM, Pizzamiglio, S, Schott, C, Drecoll, E, Viertler, C, Zatloukal, K, Kap, M, Riegman, P, Esposito, I, Specht, K, Babaryka, G, Asslaber, M, Bodó, K, den Bakker, M, den Hollander, J, Fend, F, Neumann, J, Reu, S, Perren, A, Langer, R, Lugli, A, Becker, I, Richter, T, Kayser, G, May, AM, Carneiro, F, Lopes, JM, Sobin, L, Höfler, H & Becker, KF 2014, 'Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology: a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial', Virchows Archiv, vol. 465, no. 5, pp. 509-519. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00428-014-1624-4
Gündisch, Sibylle ; Slotta-Huspenina, Julia ; Verderio, Paolo ; Ciniselli, Chiara Maura ; Pizzamiglio, Sara ; Schott, Christina ; Drecoll, Enken ; Viertler, Christian ; Zatloukal, Kurt ; Kap, Marcel ; Riegman, Peter ; Esposito, Irene ; Specht, Katja ; Babaryka, Gregor ; Asslaber, Martin ; Bodó, Koppany ; den Bakker, Michael ; den Hollander, Jan ; Fend, Falko ; Neumann, Jens ; Reu, Simone ; Perren, Aurel ; Langer, Rupert ; Lugli, Alessandro ; Becker, Ingrid ; Richter, Thomas ; Kayser, Gian ; May, Annette M. ; Carneiro, Fatima ; Lopes, José Manuel ; Sobin, Leslie ; Höfler, Heinz ; Becker, Karl Friedrich. / Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology : a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial. In: Virchows Archiv. 2014 ; Vol. 465, No. 5. pp. 509-519.
@article{d87386cc6b23479a954cebc2a0c9bccc,
title = "Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology: a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial",
abstract = "The aim of our study was to evaluate the quality of histo- and cytomorphological features of PAXgene-fixed specimens and their suitability for histomorphological classification in comparison to standard formalin fixation. Fifteen colon cancer tissues were collected, divided into two mirrored samples and either formalin fixed (FFPE) or PAXgene fixed (PFPE) before paraffin embedding. HE- and PAS-stained sections were scanned and evaluated in a blinded, randomised ring trial by 20 pathologists from Europe and the USA using virtual microscopy. The pathologists evaluated histological grading, histological subtype, presence of adenoma, presence of lymphovascular invasion, quality of histomorphology and quality of nuclear features. Statistical analysis revealed that the reproducibility with regard to grading between both fixation methods was rather satisfactory (weighted kappa statistic (kw) = 0.73 (95 {\%} confidence interval (CI), 0.41–0.94)), with a higher agreement between the reference evaluation and the PFPE samples (kw = 0.86 (95 {\%} CI, 0.67–1.00)). Independent from preservation method, inter-observer reproducibility was not completely satisfactory (kw = 0.60). Histomorphological quality parameters were scored equal or better for PFPE than for FFPE samples. For example, overall quality and nuclear features, especially the detection of mitosis, were judged significantly better for PFPE cases. By contrast, significant retraction artefacts were observed more frequently in PFPE samples. In conclusion, our findings suggest that the PAXgene Tissue System leads to excellent preservation of histomorphology and nuclear features of colon cancer tissue and allows routine morphological diagnosis.",
keywords = "Colon cancer, Formalin free, Histomorphology, Molecular diagnostic, Reproducibility, Tissue preservation",
author = "Sibylle G{\"u}ndisch and Julia Slotta-Huspenina and Paolo Verderio and Ciniselli, {Chiara Maura} and Sara Pizzamiglio and Christina Schott and Enken Drecoll and Christian Viertler and Kurt Zatloukal and Marcel Kap and Peter Riegman and Irene Esposito and Katja Specht and Gregor Babaryka and Martin Asslaber and Koppany Bod{\'o} and {den Bakker}, Michael and {den Hollander}, Jan and Falko Fend and Jens Neumann and Simone Reu and Aurel Perren and Rupert Langer and Alessandro Lugli and Ingrid Becker and Thomas Richter and Gian Kayser and May, {Annette M.} and Fatima Carneiro and Lopes, {Jos{\'e} Manuel} and Leslie Sobin and Heinz H{\"o}fler and Becker, {Karl Friedrich}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1007/s00428-014-1624-4",
language = "English",
volume = "465",
pages = "509--519",
journal = "Virchows Archiv - A Pathological Anatomy and Histopathology",
issn = "0945-6317",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of colon cancer histomorphology

T2 - a comparison between formalin and PAXgene tissue fixation by an international ring trial

AU - Gündisch, Sibylle

AU - Slotta-Huspenina, Julia

AU - Verderio, Paolo

AU - Ciniselli, Chiara Maura

AU - Pizzamiglio, Sara

AU - Schott, Christina

AU - Drecoll, Enken

AU - Viertler, Christian

AU - Zatloukal, Kurt

AU - Kap, Marcel

AU - Riegman, Peter

AU - Esposito, Irene

AU - Specht, Katja

AU - Babaryka, Gregor

AU - Asslaber, Martin

AU - Bodó, Koppany

AU - den Bakker, Michael

AU - den Hollander, Jan

AU - Fend, Falko

AU - Neumann, Jens

AU - Reu, Simone

AU - Perren, Aurel

AU - Langer, Rupert

AU - Lugli, Alessandro

AU - Becker, Ingrid

AU - Richter, Thomas

AU - Kayser, Gian

AU - May, Annette M.

AU - Carneiro, Fatima

AU - Lopes, José Manuel

AU - Sobin, Leslie

AU - Höfler, Heinz

AU - Becker, Karl Friedrich

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - The aim of our study was to evaluate the quality of histo- and cytomorphological features of PAXgene-fixed specimens and their suitability for histomorphological classification in comparison to standard formalin fixation. Fifteen colon cancer tissues were collected, divided into two mirrored samples and either formalin fixed (FFPE) or PAXgene fixed (PFPE) before paraffin embedding. HE- and PAS-stained sections were scanned and evaluated in a blinded, randomised ring trial by 20 pathologists from Europe and the USA using virtual microscopy. The pathologists evaluated histological grading, histological subtype, presence of adenoma, presence of lymphovascular invasion, quality of histomorphology and quality of nuclear features. Statistical analysis revealed that the reproducibility with regard to grading between both fixation methods was rather satisfactory (weighted kappa statistic (kw) = 0.73 (95 % confidence interval (CI), 0.41–0.94)), with a higher agreement between the reference evaluation and the PFPE samples (kw = 0.86 (95 % CI, 0.67–1.00)). Independent from preservation method, inter-observer reproducibility was not completely satisfactory (kw = 0.60). Histomorphological quality parameters were scored equal or better for PFPE than for FFPE samples. For example, overall quality and nuclear features, especially the detection of mitosis, were judged significantly better for PFPE cases. By contrast, significant retraction artefacts were observed more frequently in PFPE samples. In conclusion, our findings suggest that the PAXgene Tissue System leads to excellent preservation of histomorphology and nuclear features of colon cancer tissue and allows routine morphological diagnosis.

AB - The aim of our study was to evaluate the quality of histo- and cytomorphological features of PAXgene-fixed specimens and their suitability for histomorphological classification in comparison to standard formalin fixation. Fifteen colon cancer tissues were collected, divided into two mirrored samples and either formalin fixed (FFPE) or PAXgene fixed (PFPE) before paraffin embedding. HE- and PAS-stained sections were scanned and evaluated in a blinded, randomised ring trial by 20 pathologists from Europe and the USA using virtual microscopy. The pathologists evaluated histological grading, histological subtype, presence of adenoma, presence of lymphovascular invasion, quality of histomorphology and quality of nuclear features. Statistical analysis revealed that the reproducibility with regard to grading between both fixation methods was rather satisfactory (weighted kappa statistic (kw) = 0.73 (95 % confidence interval (CI), 0.41–0.94)), with a higher agreement between the reference evaluation and the PFPE samples (kw = 0.86 (95 % CI, 0.67–1.00)). Independent from preservation method, inter-observer reproducibility was not completely satisfactory (kw = 0.60). Histomorphological quality parameters were scored equal or better for PFPE than for FFPE samples. For example, overall quality and nuclear features, especially the detection of mitosis, were judged significantly better for PFPE cases. By contrast, significant retraction artefacts were observed more frequently in PFPE samples. In conclusion, our findings suggest that the PAXgene Tissue System leads to excellent preservation of histomorphology and nuclear features of colon cancer tissue and allows routine morphological diagnosis.

KW - Colon cancer

KW - Formalin free

KW - Histomorphology

KW - Molecular diagnostic

KW - Reproducibility

KW - Tissue preservation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84925284550&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84925284550&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00428-014-1624-4

DO - 10.1007/s00428-014-1624-4

M3 - Article

C2 - 25085759

AN - SCOPUS:84925284550

VL - 465

SP - 509

EP - 519

JO - Virchows Archiv - A Pathological Anatomy and Histopathology

JF - Virchows Archiv - A Pathological Anatomy and Histopathology

SN - 0945-6317

IS - 5

ER -