False positive results in cytotoxicity testing due to unexpectedly volatile compounds

G. Ciapetti, D. Granchi, E. Verri, L. Savarino, S. Stea, F. Savioli, A. Gori, A. Pizzoferrato

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We investigated the cytotoxicity of different dental materials according to the study protocol adopted by our lab for the screening of new materials. Experimental parameters used in such testing are addressed mainly in documents EN 30993 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 5: Tests for cytotoxicity: in vitro methods' and 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 12: Sample preparation and reference materials.' Cells were cultured in microplates and challenged with aqueous extracts of the materials. The assay methods were neutral red- and propidium iodide-uptake assays, both indicative of cell viability and able to provide quantitative data. The observation of contrasting results for one material using the above-mentioned methods raised some concern about the assay system used. With further experimentation, it appeared that a sustained release of volatile substances still present in one extract exerted a toxic effect in neighboring cultures. It is concluded that in the microenvironment of a microplate the distribution of samples cannot be disregarded, as it may be responsible for toxicity cross-contamination. Moreover, the use of more than one single method has to be recommended in cytotoxicity testing, in order to avoid false positive results due to experimental artifacts.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)286-291
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Biomedical Materials Research
Volume39
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1998

Fingerprint

Cytotoxicity
Assays
Testing
Dental materials
Neutral Red
Dental Materials
Equipment and Supplies
Propidium
Poisons
Artifacts
Toxicity
Cultured Cells
Cell Survival
Screening
Contamination
Cells
Observation

Keywords

  • Biomaterials
  • Cytotoxicity
  • Microplate
  • Standards

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biomedical Engineering
  • Biomaterials

Cite this

False positive results in cytotoxicity testing due to unexpectedly volatile compounds. / Ciapetti, G.; Granchi, D.; Verri, E.; Savarino, L.; Stea, S.; Savioli, F.; Gori, A.; Pizzoferrato, A.

In: Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, Vol. 39, No. 2, 1998, p. 286-291.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Ciapetti, G. ; Granchi, D. ; Verri, E. ; Savarino, L. ; Stea, S. ; Savioli, F. ; Gori, A. ; Pizzoferrato, A. / False positive results in cytotoxicity testing due to unexpectedly volatile compounds. In: Journal of Biomedical Materials Research. 1998 ; Vol. 39, No. 2. pp. 286-291.
@article{36f74295a71243c69d642007a1ef07c0,
title = "False positive results in cytotoxicity testing due to unexpectedly volatile compounds",
abstract = "We investigated the cytotoxicity of different dental materials according to the study protocol adopted by our lab for the screening of new materials. Experimental parameters used in such testing are addressed mainly in documents EN 30993 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 5: Tests for cytotoxicity: in vitro methods' and 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 12: Sample preparation and reference materials.' Cells were cultured in microplates and challenged with aqueous extracts of the materials. The assay methods were neutral red- and propidium iodide-uptake assays, both indicative of cell viability and able to provide quantitative data. The observation of contrasting results for one material using the above-mentioned methods raised some concern about the assay system used. With further experimentation, it appeared that a sustained release of volatile substances still present in one extract exerted a toxic effect in neighboring cultures. It is concluded that in the microenvironment of a microplate the distribution of samples cannot be disregarded, as it may be responsible for toxicity cross-contamination. Moreover, the use of more than one single method has to be recommended in cytotoxicity testing, in order to avoid false positive results due to experimental artifacts.",
keywords = "Biomaterials, Cytotoxicity, Microplate, Standards",
author = "G. Ciapetti and D. Granchi and E. Verri and L. Savarino and S. Stea and F. Savioli and A. Gori and A. Pizzoferrato",
year = "1998",
doi = "10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(199802)39:2<286::AID-JBM16>3.0.CO;2-B",
language = "English",
volume = "39",
pages = "286--291",
journal = "Journal of Biomedical Materials Research - Part A",
issn = "1549-3296",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - False positive results in cytotoxicity testing due to unexpectedly volatile compounds

AU - Ciapetti, G.

AU - Granchi, D.

AU - Verri, E.

AU - Savarino, L.

AU - Stea, S.

AU - Savioli, F.

AU - Gori, A.

AU - Pizzoferrato, A.

PY - 1998

Y1 - 1998

N2 - We investigated the cytotoxicity of different dental materials according to the study protocol adopted by our lab for the screening of new materials. Experimental parameters used in such testing are addressed mainly in documents EN 30993 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 5: Tests for cytotoxicity: in vitro methods' and 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 12: Sample preparation and reference materials.' Cells were cultured in microplates and challenged with aqueous extracts of the materials. The assay methods were neutral red- and propidium iodide-uptake assays, both indicative of cell viability and able to provide quantitative data. The observation of contrasting results for one material using the above-mentioned methods raised some concern about the assay system used. With further experimentation, it appeared that a sustained release of volatile substances still present in one extract exerted a toxic effect in neighboring cultures. It is concluded that in the microenvironment of a microplate the distribution of samples cannot be disregarded, as it may be responsible for toxicity cross-contamination. Moreover, the use of more than one single method has to be recommended in cytotoxicity testing, in order to avoid false positive results due to experimental artifacts.

AB - We investigated the cytotoxicity of different dental materials according to the study protocol adopted by our lab for the screening of new materials. Experimental parameters used in such testing are addressed mainly in documents EN 30993 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 5: Tests for cytotoxicity: in vitro methods' and 'Biological evaluation of medical devices, Part 12: Sample preparation and reference materials.' Cells were cultured in microplates and challenged with aqueous extracts of the materials. The assay methods were neutral red- and propidium iodide-uptake assays, both indicative of cell viability and able to provide quantitative data. The observation of contrasting results for one material using the above-mentioned methods raised some concern about the assay system used. With further experimentation, it appeared that a sustained release of volatile substances still present in one extract exerted a toxic effect in neighboring cultures. It is concluded that in the microenvironment of a microplate the distribution of samples cannot be disregarded, as it may be responsible for toxicity cross-contamination. Moreover, the use of more than one single method has to be recommended in cytotoxicity testing, in order to avoid false positive results due to experimental artifacts.

KW - Biomaterials

KW - Cytotoxicity

KW - Microplate

KW - Standards

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031597111&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031597111&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(199802)39:2<286::AID-JBM16>3.0.CO;2-B

DO - 10.1002/(SICI)1097-4636(199802)39:2<286::AID-JBM16>3.0.CO;2-B

M3 - Article

C2 - 9457559

AN - SCOPUS:0031597111

VL - 39

SP - 286

EP - 291

JO - Journal of Biomedical Materials Research - Part A

JF - Journal of Biomedical Materials Research - Part A

SN - 1549-3296

IS - 2

ER -