Five years (2004-2009) of a restrictive law-regulating ART in Italy significantly reduced delivery rate: Analysis of 10 706 cycles

P. E. Levi Setti, E. Albani, M. Matteo, E. Morenghi, E. Zannoni, A. M. Baggiani, V. Arfuso, P. Patrizio

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review


Study Question Was the delivery rate of ART cycles negatively affected by the enactment of the Law 40/2004 by the Italian Parliament which imposed a long list of restrictions for ART procedures? Summary Answer This large and extensive comparative analysis of ART outcomes prior to and after the introduction of the Law 40 revealed a significant reduction in pregnancy and delivery rates per cycle, independent of age or other clinical variables, once the law went into effect. What is Known AlreadySeveral studies have been published on the effect of Law 40/2004 on ART outcomes, some authors demonstrating a negative impact of the Law in relation to specific etiologies of infertility, other authors showing opposite Conclusions . Study Design , Size, DurationRetrospective clinical study of 3808 patients treated prior to the enactment of the Law, September 1996-March 2004 (Group I) and 6898 treated during the Law, March 2004-May 2009 (Group II). Participants/Materials, Setting , Method SA total of 10 706 ART cycles were analysed, 3808 performed before and 6898 after the application of the Law. An intention-to-treat statistical analysis was performed to detect pregnancy and delivery rates (pregnancies ≥24 weeks) per started cycle. A P value of 38 years, duration of infertility, basal FSH level and number of retrieved oocytes, showed a 16% lower delivery rate (odds ratio: 0.84; confidence interval: 0.75-0.94). This statistical approach removed the risk that the observed effects were due to chance and confirmed unequivocally that the Law was an independent factor responsible for the reduced likelihood of a successful outcome. Limitations , Reasons for Caution This is a retrospective study. A prospective randomized study, with patients treated in the same time period and randomized to restrictions or not, would have minimized potential Limitations due to differences in years of treatments. Wider Implications of the FindingsOur findings based on the analysis of such a large number of cycles proved clearly and unequivocally that imposing restrictions on the practice of ART penalized patients. These data represent a relevant clinical contribution for countries still debating the enactment of restrictive Limitations of ART. Study Funding/Competing Interest This investigation has been supported by a finalized grant from Lombardy County, Italy (DGR 7255, 3 July 2008).

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)343-349
Number of pages7
JournalHuman Reproduction
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2013


  • assisted reproduction regulation
  • assisted reproduction technology
  • delivery rate
  • ethics and law

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Rehabilitation
  • Obstetrics and Gynaecology
  • Reproductive Medicine


Dive into the research topics of 'Five years (2004-2009) of a restrictive law-regulating ART in Italy significantly reduced delivery rate: Analysis of 10 706 cycles'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this