Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy: A multicentric study

Lucia Clara Orlandini, Sara Lappi, Paola Mangili, Francesco Ziglio, Lanfranco Stea, Francesca Giglioli, Elisa Calamia, Maria Pia Mascia, Barbara Longobardi, Federica Cattani

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

A multicentric study involving eight Italian brachytherapy centers was performed to analyse to what extent the variations in the reconstructed seed distribution can affect the dosimetric parameters commonly used in post plan evaluations of permanent prostate brachytherapy. The geometrical seeds distributions were reconstructed by eight reviewers on CT and MR images of six implanted patients. Independently on the imaging modality, the geometric reconstruction of the seeds distribution showed little effect on quality dosimetric parameters D9D and V100 of the prostate implant. On the contrary a strong effect upon organs at risk (OARS) related parameters was found. The spread of the D1 and V150 values for the urethra calls into question the significance and the specificity of these parameters. Our preliminary results show the difficulty of collecting dosimetric data that could be correlated with biochemical relapse-free survival (RFS) or prostate specific antigen (PSA) and, particularly, with side effects. Nevertheless, in our opinion, prostate and OAR contouring remains the largest source of uncertainty in post plan evaluation.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)105-109
Number of pages5
JournalPhysica Medica
Volume20
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2004

Fingerprint

Observer Variation
Brachytherapy
seeds
Prostate
Seeds
Organs at Risk
Urethra
Prostate-Specific Antigen
Uncertainty
evaluation
antigens
organs
Recurrence
Survival

Keywords

  • Dosimetric parameters
  • I-125
  • Permanent prostate brachytherapy
  • Post-plan dosimetry

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Physics and Astronomy(all)

Cite this

Orlandini, L. C., Lappi, S., Mangili, P., Ziglio, F., Stea, L., Giglioli, F., ... Cattani, F. (2004). Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy: A multicentric study. Physica Medica, 20(3), 105-109.

Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy : A multicentric study. / Orlandini, Lucia Clara; Lappi, Sara; Mangili, Paola; Ziglio, Francesco; Stea, Lanfranco; Giglioli, Francesca; Calamia, Elisa; Mascia, Maria Pia; Longobardi, Barbara; Cattani, Federica.

In: Physica Medica, Vol. 20, No. 3, 07.2004, p. 105-109.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Orlandini, LC, Lappi, S, Mangili, P, Ziglio, F, Stea, L, Giglioli, F, Calamia, E, Mascia, MP, Longobardi, B & Cattani, F 2004, 'Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy: A multicentric study', Physica Medica, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 105-109.
Orlandini LC, Lappi S, Mangili P, Ziglio F, Stea L, Giglioli F et al. Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy: A multicentric study. Physica Medica. 2004 Jul;20(3):105-109.
Orlandini, Lucia Clara ; Lappi, Sara ; Mangili, Paola ; Ziglio, Francesco ; Stea, Lanfranco ; Giglioli, Francesca ; Calamia, Elisa ; Mascia, Maria Pia ; Longobardi, Barbara ; Cattani, Federica. / Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy : A multicentric study. In: Physica Medica. 2004 ; Vol. 20, No. 3. pp. 105-109.
@article{febf3a3536cc4d00b73c8d84198a77cc,
title = "Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy: A multicentric study",
abstract = "A multicentric study involving eight Italian brachytherapy centers was performed to analyse to what extent the variations in the reconstructed seed distribution can affect the dosimetric parameters commonly used in post plan evaluations of permanent prostate brachytherapy. The geometrical seeds distributions were reconstructed by eight reviewers on CT and MR images of six implanted patients. Independently on the imaging modality, the geometric reconstruction of the seeds distribution showed little effect on quality dosimetric parameters D9D and V100 of the prostate implant. On the contrary a strong effect upon organs at risk (OARS) related parameters was found. The spread of the D1 and V150 values for the urethra calls into question the significance and the specificity of these parameters. Our preliminary results show the difficulty of collecting dosimetric data that could be correlated with biochemical relapse-free survival (RFS) or prostate specific antigen (PSA) and, particularly, with side effects. Nevertheless, in our opinion, prostate and OAR contouring remains the largest source of uncertainty in post plan evaluation.",
keywords = "Dosimetric parameters, I-125, Permanent prostate brachytherapy, Post-plan dosimetry",
author = "Orlandini, {Lucia Clara} and Sara Lappi and Paola Mangili and Francesco Ziglio and Lanfranco Stea and Francesca Giglioli and Elisa Calamia and Mascia, {Maria Pia} and Barbara Longobardi and Federica Cattani",
year = "2004",
month = "7",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "105--109",
journal = "Physica Medica",
issn = "1120-1797",
publisher = "Associazione Italiana di Fisica Medica",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Inter-observer variability in post-plan seed localization after permanent prostate brachytherapy

T2 - A multicentric study

AU - Orlandini, Lucia Clara

AU - Lappi, Sara

AU - Mangili, Paola

AU - Ziglio, Francesco

AU - Stea, Lanfranco

AU - Giglioli, Francesca

AU - Calamia, Elisa

AU - Mascia, Maria Pia

AU - Longobardi, Barbara

AU - Cattani, Federica

PY - 2004/7

Y1 - 2004/7

N2 - A multicentric study involving eight Italian brachytherapy centers was performed to analyse to what extent the variations in the reconstructed seed distribution can affect the dosimetric parameters commonly used in post plan evaluations of permanent prostate brachytherapy. The geometrical seeds distributions were reconstructed by eight reviewers on CT and MR images of six implanted patients. Independently on the imaging modality, the geometric reconstruction of the seeds distribution showed little effect on quality dosimetric parameters D9D and V100 of the prostate implant. On the contrary a strong effect upon organs at risk (OARS) related parameters was found. The spread of the D1 and V150 values for the urethra calls into question the significance and the specificity of these parameters. Our preliminary results show the difficulty of collecting dosimetric data that could be correlated with biochemical relapse-free survival (RFS) or prostate specific antigen (PSA) and, particularly, with side effects. Nevertheless, in our opinion, prostate and OAR contouring remains the largest source of uncertainty in post plan evaluation.

AB - A multicentric study involving eight Italian brachytherapy centers was performed to analyse to what extent the variations in the reconstructed seed distribution can affect the dosimetric parameters commonly used in post plan evaluations of permanent prostate brachytherapy. The geometrical seeds distributions were reconstructed by eight reviewers on CT and MR images of six implanted patients. Independently on the imaging modality, the geometric reconstruction of the seeds distribution showed little effect on quality dosimetric parameters D9D and V100 of the prostate implant. On the contrary a strong effect upon organs at risk (OARS) related parameters was found. The spread of the D1 and V150 values for the urethra calls into question the significance and the specificity of these parameters. Our preliminary results show the difficulty of collecting dosimetric data that could be correlated with biochemical relapse-free survival (RFS) or prostate specific antigen (PSA) and, particularly, with side effects. Nevertheless, in our opinion, prostate and OAR contouring remains the largest source of uncertainty in post plan evaluation.

KW - Dosimetric parameters

KW - I-125

KW - Permanent prostate brachytherapy

KW - Post-plan dosimetry

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=13444301608&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=13444301608&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:13444301608

VL - 20

SP - 105

EP - 109

JO - Physica Medica

JF - Physica Medica

SN - 1120-1797

IS - 3

ER -