Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework

Massimo Confortini, A. Bondi, M. P. Cariaggi, F. Carozzi, P. Dalla Palma, B. Ghiringhello, D. Minucci, G. Montanari, F. Parisio, S. Prandi, M. L. Schiboni, G. Ronco

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Within a multicentre controlled trial framework, an external quality control (EQC) was scheduled to evaluate the interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based cytology. In particular, this EQC intended to evaluate the reproducibility of the ASCUS diagnosis. A selected set of 30 slides (4 within normal limit cases, 16 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance; 4 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions and 6 high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions) circulated among the 13 laboratories involved in the trial. Kappa values were obtained from the comparison between individual laboratory diagnoses and majority diagnoses with target diagnoses. Specific kappa values resulted moderate to high for HSIL and low to moderate for LSIL and WNL. Meanwhile, the specific kappa for ASCUS was below 0.4 in 12 of 13 participating laboratories. The lack of reproducibility for ASCUS was not a result of the introduction of this new technology but rather to the low repro ducibility of the ASCUS category itself stemming from intrinsic uncertainties in the reporting criteria.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)541-544
Number of pages4
JournalDiagnostic Cytopathology
Volume35
Issue number9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2007

Fingerprint

Cell Biology
Randomized Controlled Trials
Quality Control
Clinical Laboratory Techniques
Multicenter Studies
Uncertainty
Atypical Squamous Cells of the Cervix
Technology
Squamous Intraepithelial Lesions of the Cervix

Keywords

  • ASCUS reproducibility
  • External quality control
  • LBC
  • Pap smear

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anatomy

Cite this

Confortini, M., Bondi, A., Cariaggi, M. P., Carozzi, F., Dalla Palma, P., Ghiringhello, B., ... Ronco, G. (2007). Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework. Diagnostic Cytopathology, 35(9), 541-544. https://doi.org/10.1002/dc.20681

Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework. / Confortini, Massimo; Bondi, A.; Cariaggi, M. P.; Carozzi, F.; Dalla Palma, P.; Ghiringhello, B.; Minucci, D.; Montanari, G.; Parisio, F.; Prandi, S.; Schiboni, M. L.; Ronco, G.

In: Diagnostic Cytopathology, Vol. 35, No. 9, 09.2007, p. 541-544.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Confortini, M, Bondi, A, Cariaggi, MP, Carozzi, F, Dalla Palma, P, Ghiringhello, B, Minucci, D, Montanari, G, Parisio, F, Prandi, S, Schiboni, ML & Ronco, G 2007, 'Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework', Diagnostic Cytopathology, vol. 35, no. 9, pp. 541-544. https://doi.org/10.1002/dc.20681
Confortini, Massimo ; Bondi, A. ; Cariaggi, M. P. ; Carozzi, F. ; Dalla Palma, P. ; Ghiringhello, B. ; Minucci, D. ; Montanari, G. ; Parisio, F. ; Prandi, S. ; Schiboni, M. L. ; Ronco, G. / Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework. In: Diagnostic Cytopathology. 2007 ; Vol. 35, No. 9. pp. 541-544.
@article{19692a6f853643c9bf0fa7933669655c,
title = "Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework",
abstract = "Within a multicentre controlled trial framework, an external quality control (EQC) was scheduled to evaluate the interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based cytology. In particular, this EQC intended to evaluate the reproducibility of the ASCUS diagnosis. A selected set of 30 slides (4 within normal limit cases, 16 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance; 4 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions and 6 high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions) circulated among the 13 laboratories involved in the trial. Kappa values were obtained from the comparison between individual laboratory diagnoses and majority diagnoses with target diagnoses. Specific kappa values resulted moderate to high for HSIL and low to moderate for LSIL and WNL. Meanwhile, the specific kappa for ASCUS was below 0.4 in 12 of 13 participating laboratories. The lack of reproducibility for ASCUS was not a result of the introduction of this new technology but rather to the low repro ducibility of the ASCUS category itself stemming from intrinsic uncertainties in the reporting criteria.",
keywords = "ASCUS reproducibility, External quality control, LBC, Pap smear",
author = "Massimo Confortini and A. Bondi and Cariaggi, {M. P.} and F. Carozzi and {Dalla Palma}, P. and B. Ghiringhello and D. Minucci and G. Montanari and F. Parisio and S. Prandi and Schiboni, {M. L.} and G. Ronco",
year = "2007",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1002/dc.20681",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "541--544",
journal = "Diagnostic Cytopathology",
issn = "8755-1039",
publisher = "Wiley-Liss Inc.",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based equivocal cervical cytology within a randomized controlled trial framework

AU - Confortini, Massimo

AU - Bondi, A.

AU - Cariaggi, M. P.

AU - Carozzi, F.

AU - Dalla Palma, P.

AU - Ghiringhello, B.

AU - Minucci, D.

AU - Montanari, G.

AU - Parisio, F.

AU - Prandi, S.

AU - Schiboni, M. L.

AU - Ronco, G.

PY - 2007/9

Y1 - 2007/9

N2 - Within a multicentre controlled trial framework, an external quality control (EQC) was scheduled to evaluate the interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based cytology. In particular, this EQC intended to evaluate the reproducibility of the ASCUS diagnosis. A selected set of 30 slides (4 within normal limit cases, 16 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance; 4 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions and 6 high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions) circulated among the 13 laboratories involved in the trial. Kappa values were obtained from the comparison between individual laboratory diagnoses and majority diagnoses with target diagnoses. Specific kappa values resulted moderate to high for HSIL and low to moderate for LSIL and WNL. Meanwhile, the specific kappa for ASCUS was below 0.4 in 12 of 13 participating laboratories. The lack of reproducibility for ASCUS was not a result of the introduction of this new technology but rather to the low repro ducibility of the ASCUS category itself stemming from intrinsic uncertainties in the reporting criteria.

AB - Within a multicentre controlled trial framework, an external quality control (EQC) was scheduled to evaluate the interlaboratory reproducibility of liquid-based cytology. In particular, this EQC intended to evaluate the reproducibility of the ASCUS diagnosis. A selected set of 30 slides (4 within normal limit cases, 16 atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance; 4 low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions and 6 high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions) circulated among the 13 laboratories involved in the trial. Kappa values were obtained from the comparison between individual laboratory diagnoses and majority diagnoses with target diagnoses. Specific kappa values resulted moderate to high for HSIL and low to moderate for LSIL and WNL. Meanwhile, the specific kappa for ASCUS was below 0.4 in 12 of 13 participating laboratories. The lack of reproducibility for ASCUS was not a result of the introduction of this new technology but rather to the low repro ducibility of the ASCUS category itself stemming from intrinsic uncertainties in the reporting criteria.

KW - ASCUS reproducibility

KW - External quality control

KW - LBC

KW - Pap smear

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34548710367&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34548710367&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/dc.20681

DO - 10.1002/dc.20681

M3 - Article

C2 - 17703457

AN - SCOPUS:34548710367

VL - 35

SP - 541

EP - 544

JO - Diagnostic Cytopathology

JF - Diagnostic Cytopathology

SN - 8755-1039

IS - 9

ER -