International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life

Franzisca Domeisen Benedetti, Christoph Ostgathe, Jean Clark, Massimo Costantini, Maria Laura Daud, Barbara Grossenbacher-Gschwend, Richard Latten, Olav Lindqvist, Andreja Peternelj, Stefanie Schuler, Kali Tal, Agnes Van Der Heide, Steffen Eychmüller

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Providing the highest quality care for dying patients should be a core clinical proficiency and an integral part of comprehensive management, as fundamental as diagnosis and treatment. The aim of this study was to provide expert consensus on phenomena for identification and prediction of the last hours or days of a patient's life. This study is part of the OPCARE9 project, funded by the European Commission's Seventh Framework Programme. Method: The phenomena associated with approaching death were generated using Delphi technique. The Delphi process was set up in three cycles to collate a set of useful and relevant phenomena that identify and predict the last hours and days of life. Each cycle included: (1) development of the questionnaire, (2) distribution of the Delphi questionnaire and (3) review and synthesis of findings. Results: The first Delphi cycle of 252 participants (health care professionals, volunteers, public) generated 194 different phenomena, perceptions and observations. In the second cycle, these phenomena were checked for their specific ability to diagnose the last hours/days of life. Fifty-eight phenomena achieved more than 80 % expert consensus and were grouped into nine categories. In the third cycle, these 58 phenomena were ranked by a group of palliative care experts (78 professionals, including physicians, nurses, psycho-social-spiritual support; response rate 72 %, see Table 1) in terms of clinical relevance to the prediction that a person will die within the next few hours/days. Twenty-one phenomena were determined to have "high relevance" by more than 50 % of the experts. Based on these findings, the changes in the following categories (each consisting of up to three phenomena) were considered highly relevant to clinicians in identifying and predicting a patient's last hours/days of life: "breathing", "general deterioration", "consciousness/cognition", "skin", "intake of fluid, food, others", "emotional state" and "non-observations/expressed opinions/other". Conclusion: Experts from different professional backgrounds identified a set of categories describing a structure within which clinical phenomena can be clinically assessed, in order to more accurately predict whether someone will die within the next days or hours. However, these phenomena need further specification for clinical use.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1509-1517
Number of pages9
JournalSupportive Care in Cancer
Volume21
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2013

Fingerprint

Palliative Care
Consensus
Delphi Technique
Aptitude
Quality of Health Care
Consciousness
Cognition
Volunteers
Respiration
Eating
Nurses
Delivery of Health Care
Physicians
Skin
Surveys and Questionnaires
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Delphi technique
  • Last hours/days of life
  • Phenomena

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Oncology

Cite this

Domeisen Benedetti, F., Ostgathe, C., Clark, J., Costantini, M., Daud, M. L., Grossenbacher-Gschwend, B., ... Eychmüller, S. (2013). International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life. Supportive Care in Cancer, 21(6), 1509-1517. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00520-012-1677-3

International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life. / Domeisen Benedetti, Franzisca; Ostgathe, Christoph; Clark, Jean; Costantini, Massimo; Daud, Maria Laura; Grossenbacher-Gschwend, Barbara; Latten, Richard; Lindqvist, Olav; Peternelj, Andreja; Schuler, Stefanie; Tal, Kali; Van Der Heide, Agnes; Eychmüller, Steffen.

In: Supportive Care in Cancer, Vol. 21, No. 6, 06.2013, p. 1509-1517.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Domeisen Benedetti, F, Ostgathe, C, Clark, J, Costantini, M, Daud, ML, Grossenbacher-Gschwend, B, Latten, R, Lindqvist, O, Peternelj, A, Schuler, S, Tal, K, Van Der Heide, A & Eychmüller, S 2013, 'International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life', Supportive Care in Cancer, vol. 21, no. 6, pp. 1509-1517. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00520-012-1677-3
Domeisen Benedetti, Franzisca ; Ostgathe, Christoph ; Clark, Jean ; Costantini, Massimo ; Daud, Maria Laura ; Grossenbacher-Gschwend, Barbara ; Latten, Richard ; Lindqvist, Olav ; Peternelj, Andreja ; Schuler, Stefanie ; Tal, Kali ; Van Der Heide, Agnes ; Eychmüller, Steffen. / International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life. In: Supportive Care in Cancer. 2013 ; Vol. 21, No. 6. pp. 1509-1517.
@article{567463228d944ff58bfd49b506b616de,
title = "International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life",
abstract = "Background: Providing the highest quality care for dying patients should be a core clinical proficiency and an integral part of comprehensive management, as fundamental as diagnosis and treatment. The aim of this study was to provide expert consensus on phenomena for identification and prediction of the last hours or days of a patient's life. This study is part of the OPCARE9 project, funded by the European Commission's Seventh Framework Programme. Method: The phenomena associated with approaching death were generated using Delphi technique. The Delphi process was set up in three cycles to collate a set of useful and relevant phenomena that identify and predict the last hours and days of life. Each cycle included: (1) development of the questionnaire, (2) distribution of the Delphi questionnaire and (3) review and synthesis of findings. Results: The first Delphi cycle of 252 participants (health care professionals, volunteers, public) generated 194 different phenomena, perceptions and observations. In the second cycle, these phenomena were checked for their specific ability to diagnose the last hours/days of life. Fifty-eight phenomena achieved more than 80 {\%} expert consensus and were grouped into nine categories. In the third cycle, these 58 phenomena were ranked by a group of palliative care experts (78 professionals, including physicians, nurses, psycho-social-spiritual support; response rate 72 {\%}, see Table 1) in terms of clinical relevance to the prediction that a person will die within the next few hours/days. Twenty-one phenomena were determined to have {"}high relevance{"} by more than 50 {\%} of the experts. Based on these findings, the changes in the following categories (each consisting of up to three phenomena) were considered highly relevant to clinicians in identifying and predicting a patient's last hours/days of life: {"}breathing{"}, {"}general deterioration{"}, {"}consciousness/cognition{"}, {"}skin{"}, {"}intake of fluid, food, others{"}, {"}emotional state{"} and {"}non-observations/expressed opinions/other{"}. Conclusion: Experts from different professional backgrounds identified a set of categories describing a structure within which clinical phenomena can be clinically assessed, in order to more accurately predict whether someone will die within the next days or hours. However, these phenomena need further specification for clinical use.",
keywords = "Delphi technique, Last hours/days of life, Phenomena",
author = "{Domeisen Benedetti}, Franzisca and Christoph Ostgathe and Jean Clark and Massimo Costantini and Daud, {Maria Laura} and Barbara Grossenbacher-Gschwend and Richard Latten and Olav Lindqvist and Andreja Peternelj and Stefanie Schuler and Kali Tal and {Van Der Heide}, Agnes and Steffen Eychm{\"u}ller",
year = "2013",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1007/s00520-012-1677-3",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "1509--1517",
journal = "Supportive Care in Cancer",
issn = "0941-4355",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - International palliative care experts' view on phenomena indicating the last hours and days of life

AU - Domeisen Benedetti, Franzisca

AU - Ostgathe, Christoph

AU - Clark, Jean

AU - Costantini, Massimo

AU - Daud, Maria Laura

AU - Grossenbacher-Gschwend, Barbara

AU - Latten, Richard

AU - Lindqvist, Olav

AU - Peternelj, Andreja

AU - Schuler, Stefanie

AU - Tal, Kali

AU - Van Der Heide, Agnes

AU - Eychmüller, Steffen

PY - 2013/6

Y1 - 2013/6

N2 - Background: Providing the highest quality care for dying patients should be a core clinical proficiency and an integral part of comprehensive management, as fundamental as diagnosis and treatment. The aim of this study was to provide expert consensus on phenomena for identification and prediction of the last hours or days of a patient's life. This study is part of the OPCARE9 project, funded by the European Commission's Seventh Framework Programme. Method: The phenomena associated with approaching death were generated using Delphi technique. The Delphi process was set up in three cycles to collate a set of useful and relevant phenomena that identify and predict the last hours and days of life. Each cycle included: (1) development of the questionnaire, (2) distribution of the Delphi questionnaire and (3) review and synthesis of findings. Results: The first Delphi cycle of 252 participants (health care professionals, volunteers, public) generated 194 different phenomena, perceptions and observations. In the second cycle, these phenomena were checked for their specific ability to diagnose the last hours/days of life. Fifty-eight phenomena achieved more than 80 % expert consensus and were grouped into nine categories. In the third cycle, these 58 phenomena were ranked by a group of palliative care experts (78 professionals, including physicians, nurses, psycho-social-spiritual support; response rate 72 %, see Table 1) in terms of clinical relevance to the prediction that a person will die within the next few hours/days. Twenty-one phenomena were determined to have "high relevance" by more than 50 % of the experts. Based on these findings, the changes in the following categories (each consisting of up to three phenomena) were considered highly relevant to clinicians in identifying and predicting a patient's last hours/days of life: "breathing", "general deterioration", "consciousness/cognition", "skin", "intake of fluid, food, others", "emotional state" and "non-observations/expressed opinions/other". Conclusion: Experts from different professional backgrounds identified a set of categories describing a structure within which clinical phenomena can be clinically assessed, in order to more accurately predict whether someone will die within the next days or hours. However, these phenomena need further specification for clinical use.

AB - Background: Providing the highest quality care for dying patients should be a core clinical proficiency and an integral part of comprehensive management, as fundamental as diagnosis and treatment. The aim of this study was to provide expert consensus on phenomena for identification and prediction of the last hours or days of a patient's life. This study is part of the OPCARE9 project, funded by the European Commission's Seventh Framework Programme. Method: The phenomena associated with approaching death were generated using Delphi technique. The Delphi process was set up in three cycles to collate a set of useful and relevant phenomena that identify and predict the last hours and days of life. Each cycle included: (1) development of the questionnaire, (2) distribution of the Delphi questionnaire and (3) review and synthesis of findings. Results: The first Delphi cycle of 252 participants (health care professionals, volunteers, public) generated 194 different phenomena, perceptions and observations. In the second cycle, these phenomena were checked for their specific ability to diagnose the last hours/days of life. Fifty-eight phenomena achieved more than 80 % expert consensus and were grouped into nine categories. In the third cycle, these 58 phenomena were ranked by a group of palliative care experts (78 professionals, including physicians, nurses, psycho-social-spiritual support; response rate 72 %, see Table 1) in terms of clinical relevance to the prediction that a person will die within the next few hours/days. Twenty-one phenomena were determined to have "high relevance" by more than 50 % of the experts. Based on these findings, the changes in the following categories (each consisting of up to three phenomena) were considered highly relevant to clinicians in identifying and predicting a patient's last hours/days of life: "breathing", "general deterioration", "consciousness/cognition", "skin", "intake of fluid, food, others", "emotional state" and "non-observations/expressed opinions/other". Conclusion: Experts from different professional backgrounds identified a set of categories describing a structure within which clinical phenomena can be clinically assessed, in order to more accurately predict whether someone will die within the next days or hours. However, these phenomena need further specification for clinical use.

KW - Delphi technique

KW - Last hours/days of life

KW - Phenomena

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84879154155&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84879154155&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00520-012-1677-3

DO - 10.1007/s00520-012-1677-3

M3 - Article

C2 - 23242388

AN - SCOPUS:84879154155

VL - 21

SP - 1509

EP - 1517

JO - Supportive Care in Cancer

JF - Supportive Care in Cancer

SN - 0941-4355

IS - 6

ER -