Interobserver reliability of ICSD-R minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias

Luca Vignatelli, Francesca Bisulli, Anna Zaniboni, Ilaria Naldi, Jean Elias Fares, Federica Provini, Roberto Vetrugno, Giuseppe Plazzi, Paolo Tinuper, Pasquale Montagna

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

31 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of the minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias provided in the International Classification of Sleep Disorders Revised (ICSD-R). Methods: Fifty consecutive subjects underwent a structured interview by three doctors based on the ICSD-R minimal criteria for the diagnosis of 13 parasomnias at any time in life. IR was calculated by Kappa statistics and interpreted according to conventional categories. Results: In the group of Arousal Disorders, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.74) for confusional arousals, "slight" (kappa 0.36) for sleepwalking, "fair" (kappa -0.02) for sleep terrors. In the group of Wake-Sleep Transition Disorders, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect", but "moderate" for sleep starts (kappa 0.41). In the group of Parasomnias usually associated with REM Sleep, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.69) for sleep paralysis, "moderate" (kappa 0.46) for RBD, "fair" (kappa 0.25) for nightmares. In the group of Other Parasomnias, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect" (kappa between 0.73 and 0.93). Conclusions: When the clinical diagnosis of parasomnias is based on the ICSD-R: 1) the majority of Arousal Disorders and REM sleep parasomnias showed only a "fair" to "moderate" IR; 2) all of the other parasomnias showed a "substantial" to "almost perfect" IR. Nosological entities with unsatisfactory IR share complex motor phenomenology associated with a mental state difficult for the patient to define. The source of disagreement probably lies in the difficulty in interpreting patients' reports. For these parasomnias IR must be verified and possibly improved with training.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)712-717
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Neurology
Volume252
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2005

Fingerprint

Parasomnias
Sleep-Wake Transition Disorders
Arousal
REM Sleep Parasomnias
Sleep Arousal Disorders
Night Terrors
Sleep Paralysis
Somnambulism
REM Sleep
Sleep Wake Disorders
Interviews

Keywords

  • Diagnosis
  • ICSD-R
  • Kappa statistics
  • Parasomnias
  • Reliability of results

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology
  • Neurology

Cite this

Interobserver reliability of ICSD-R minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias. / Vignatelli, Luca; Bisulli, Francesca; Zaniboni, Anna; Naldi, Ilaria; Fares, Jean Elias; Provini, Federica; Vetrugno, Roberto; Plazzi, Giuseppe; Tinuper, Paolo; Montagna, Pasquale.

In: Journal of Neurology, Vol. 252, No. 6, 06.2005, p. 712-717.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Vignatelli, Luca ; Bisulli, Francesca ; Zaniboni, Anna ; Naldi, Ilaria ; Fares, Jean Elias ; Provini, Federica ; Vetrugno, Roberto ; Plazzi, Giuseppe ; Tinuper, Paolo ; Montagna, Pasquale. / Interobserver reliability of ICSD-R minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias. In: Journal of Neurology. 2005 ; Vol. 252, No. 6. pp. 712-717.
@article{a33ab548b91c42f09e79b5b25feab22d,
title = "Interobserver reliability of ICSD-R minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias",
abstract = "Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of the minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias provided in the International Classification of Sleep Disorders Revised (ICSD-R). Methods: Fifty consecutive subjects underwent a structured interview by three doctors based on the ICSD-R minimal criteria for the diagnosis of 13 parasomnias at any time in life. IR was calculated by Kappa statistics and interpreted according to conventional categories. Results: In the group of Arousal Disorders, IR was {"}substantial{"} (kappa 0.74) for confusional arousals, {"}slight{"} (kappa 0.36) for sleepwalking, {"}fair{"} (kappa -0.02) for sleep terrors. In the group of Wake-Sleep Transition Disorders, IR was {"}substantial{"} to {"}almost perfect{"}, but {"}moderate{"} for sleep starts (kappa 0.41). In the group of Parasomnias usually associated with REM Sleep, IR was {"}substantial{"} (kappa 0.69) for sleep paralysis, {"}moderate{"} (kappa 0.46) for RBD, {"}fair{"} (kappa 0.25) for nightmares. In the group of Other Parasomnias, IR was {"}substantial{"} to {"}almost perfect{"} (kappa between 0.73 and 0.93). Conclusions: When the clinical diagnosis of parasomnias is based on the ICSD-R: 1) the majority of Arousal Disorders and REM sleep parasomnias showed only a {"}fair{"} to {"}moderate{"} IR; 2) all of the other parasomnias showed a {"}substantial{"} to {"}almost perfect{"} IR. Nosological entities with unsatisfactory IR share complex motor phenomenology associated with a mental state difficult for the patient to define. The source of disagreement probably lies in the difficulty in interpreting patients' reports. For these parasomnias IR must be verified and possibly improved with training.",
keywords = "Diagnosis, ICSD-R, Kappa statistics, Parasomnias, Reliability of results",
author = "Luca Vignatelli and Francesca Bisulli and Anna Zaniboni and Ilaria Naldi and Fares, {Jean Elias} and Federica Provini and Roberto Vetrugno and Giuseppe Plazzi and Paolo Tinuper and Pasquale Montagna",
year = "2005",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1007/s00415-005-0723-1",
language = "English",
volume = "252",
pages = "712--717",
journal = "Journal of Neurology",
issn = "0340-5354",
publisher = "Dr. Dietrich Steinkopff Verlag GmbH and Co. KG",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Interobserver reliability of ICSD-R minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias

AU - Vignatelli, Luca

AU - Bisulli, Francesca

AU - Zaniboni, Anna

AU - Naldi, Ilaria

AU - Fares, Jean Elias

AU - Provini, Federica

AU - Vetrugno, Roberto

AU - Plazzi, Giuseppe

AU - Tinuper, Paolo

AU - Montagna, Pasquale

PY - 2005/6

Y1 - 2005/6

N2 - Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of the minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias provided in the International Classification of Sleep Disorders Revised (ICSD-R). Methods: Fifty consecutive subjects underwent a structured interview by three doctors based on the ICSD-R minimal criteria for the diagnosis of 13 parasomnias at any time in life. IR was calculated by Kappa statistics and interpreted according to conventional categories. Results: In the group of Arousal Disorders, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.74) for confusional arousals, "slight" (kappa 0.36) for sleepwalking, "fair" (kappa -0.02) for sleep terrors. In the group of Wake-Sleep Transition Disorders, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect", but "moderate" for sleep starts (kappa 0.41). In the group of Parasomnias usually associated with REM Sleep, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.69) for sleep paralysis, "moderate" (kappa 0.46) for RBD, "fair" (kappa 0.25) for nightmares. In the group of Other Parasomnias, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect" (kappa between 0.73 and 0.93). Conclusions: When the clinical diagnosis of parasomnias is based on the ICSD-R: 1) the majority of Arousal Disorders and REM sleep parasomnias showed only a "fair" to "moderate" IR; 2) all of the other parasomnias showed a "substantial" to "almost perfect" IR. Nosological entities with unsatisfactory IR share complex motor phenomenology associated with a mental state difficult for the patient to define. The source of disagreement probably lies in the difficulty in interpreting patients' reports. For these parasomnias IR must be verified and possibly improved with training.

AB - Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of the minimal diagnostic criteria for the parasomnias provided in the International Classification of Sleep Disorders Revised (ICSD-R). Methods: Fifty consecutive subjects underwent a structured interview by three doctors based on the ICSD-R minimal criteria for the diagnosis of 13 parasomnias at any time in life. IR was calculated by Kappa statistics and interpreted according to conventional categories. Results: In the group of Arousal Disorders, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.74) for confusional arousals, "slight" (kappa 0.36) for sleepwalking, "fair" (kappa -0.02) for sleep terrors. In the group of Wake-Sleep Transition Disorders, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect", but "moderate" for sleep starts (kappa 0.41). In the group of Parasomnias usually associated with REM Sleep, IR was "substantial" (kappa 0.69) for sleep paralysis, "moderate" (kappa 0.46) for RBD, "fair" (kappa 0.25) for nightmares. In the group of Other Parasomnias, IR was "substantial" to "almost perfect" (kappa between 0.73 and 0.93). Conclusions: When the clinical diagnosis of parasomnias is based on the ICSD-R: 1) the majority of Arousal Disorders and REM sleep parasomnias showed only a "fair" to "moderate" IR; 2) all of the other parasomnias showed a "substantial" to "almost perfect" IR. Nosological entities with unsatisfactory IR share complex motor phenomenology associated with a mental state difficult for the patient to define. The source of disagreement probably lies in the difficulty in interpreting patients' reports. For these parasomnias IR must be verified and possibly improved with training.

KW - Diagnosis

KW - ICSD-R

KW - Kappa statistics

KW - Parasomnias

KW - Reliability of results

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=20844443824&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=20844443824&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00415-005-0723-1

DO - 10.1007/s00415-005-0723-1

M3 - Article

VL - 252

SP - 712

EP - 717

JO - Journal of Neurology

JF - Journal of Neurology

SN - 0340-5354

IS - 6

ER -