Interobserver reliability of video recording in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures

Luca Vignatelli, Francesca Bisulli, Federica Provini, Ilaria Naldi, Francesca Pittau, Anna Zaniboni, Pasquale Montagna, Paolo Tinuper

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) show one or all of the following semeiological patterns: (1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behavior); (2) hyperkinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features); (3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizures (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features); (4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behavior). Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-recording diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists, and trainees in sleep medicine. Methods: Sixty-six patients with suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (three experts and three trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to the standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). Results: The observed raw agreement ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). A major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and nonepileptic arousals, without differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Conclusions: Among sleep experts and trainees, IR of diagnosis of NFLS, based on videotaped observation of sleep phenomena, is not satisfactory. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1506-1511
Number of pages6
JournalEpilepsia
Volume48
Issue number8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2007

Fingerprint

Video Recording
Frontal Lobe
Seizures
Sleep
Arousal
Somnambulism
Medicine
Narcolepsy
Observation

Keywords

  • Diagnosis
  • Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures
  • Parasomnias
  • Paroxysmal motor phenomena during sleep
  • Reliability of results
  • Video-recording

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology
  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Interobserver reliability of video recording in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures. / Vignatelli, Luca; Bisulli, Francesca; Provini, Federica; Naldi, Ilaria; Pittau, Francesca; Zaniboni, Anna; Montagna, Pasquale; Tinuper, Paolo.

In: Epilepsia, Vol. 48, No. 8, 08.2007, p. 1506-1511.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Vignatelli, Luca ; Bisulli, Francesca ; Provini, Federica ; Naldi, Ilaria ; Pittau, Francesca ; Zaniboni, Anna ; Montagna, Pasquale ; Tinuper, Paolo. / Interobserver reliability of video recording in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures. In: Epilepsia. 2007 ; Vol. 48, No. 8. pp. 1506-1511.
@article{328610d4b1034d01b31b6277062c871b,
title = "Interobserver reliability of video recording in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures",
abstract = "Background: Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) show one or all of the following semeiological patterns: (1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behavior); (2) hyperkinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features); (3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizures (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features); (4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behavior). Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-recording diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists, and trainees in sleep medicine. Methods: Sixty-six patients with suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (three experts and three trainees) independently classified each case as {"}NFLS ascertained{"} (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or {"}NFLS excluded{"}. IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to the standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). Results: The observed raw agreement ranged from 63{\%} to 79{\%} between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from {"}moderate{"} (kappa = 0.50) to {"}substantial{"} (kappa = 0.72). A major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and nonepileptic arousals, without differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Conclusions: Among sleep experts and trainees, IR of diagnosis of NFLS, based on videotaped observation of sleep phenomena, is not satisfactory. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.",
keywords = "Diagnosis, Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures, Parasomnias, Paroxysmal motor phenomena during sleep, Reliability of results, Video-recording",
author = "Luca Vignatelli and Francesca Bisulli and Federica Provini and Ilaria Naldi and Francesca Pittau and Anna Zaniboni and Pasquale Montagna and Paolo Tinuper",
year = "2007",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1111/j.1528-1167.2007.01121.x",
language = "English",
volume = "48",
pages = "1506--1511",
journal = "Epilepsia",
issn = "0013-9580",
publisher = "Blackwell Publishing Inc.",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Interobserver reliability of video recording in the diagnosis of nocturnal frontal lobe seizures

AU - Vignatelli, Luca

AU - Bisulli, Francesca

AU - Provini, Federica

AU - Naldi, Ilaria

AU - Pittau, Francesca

AU - Zaniboni, Anna

AU - Montagna, Pasquale

AU - Tinuper, Paolo

PY - 2007/8

Y1 - 2007/8

N2 - Background: Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) show one or all of the following semeiological patterns: (1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behavior); (2) hyperkinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features); (3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizures (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features); (4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behavior). Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-recording diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists, and trainees in sleep medicine. Methods: Sixty-six patients with suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (three experts and three trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to the standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). Results: The observed raw agreement ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). A major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and nonepileptic arousals, without differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Conclusions: Among sleep experts and trainees, IR of diagnosis of NFLS, based on videotaped observation of sleep phenomena, is not satisfactory. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

AB - Background: Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures (NFLS) show one or all of the following semeiological patterns: (1) paroxysmal arousals (PA: brief and sudden recurrent motor paroxysmal behavior); (2) hyperkinetic seizures (HS: motor attacks with complex dyskinetic features); (3) asymmetric bilateral tonic seizures (ATS: motor attacks with dystonic features); (4) epileptic nocturnal wanderings (ENW: stereotyped, prolonged ambulatory behavior). Objective: To estimate the interobserver reliability (IR) of video-recording diagnosis in patients with suspected NFLS among sleep medicine experts, epileptologists, and trainees in sleep medicine. Methods: Sixty-six patients with suspected NFLS were included. All underwent nocturnal video-polysomnographic recording. Six doctors (three experts and three trainees) independently classified each case as "NFLS ascertained" (according to the above specified subtypes: PA, HS, ATS, ENW) or "NFLS excluded". IR was calculated by means of Kappa statistics, and interpreted according to the standard classification (0.0-0.20 = slight agreement; 0.21-0.40 = fair; 0.41-0.60 = moderate; 0.61-0.80 = substantial; 0.81-1.00 = almost perfect). Results: The observed raw agreement ranged from 63% to 79% between each pair of raters; the IR ranged from "moderate" (kappa = 0.50) to "substantial" (kappa = 0.72). A major source of variance was the disagreement in distinguishing between PA and nonepileptic arousals, without differences in the level of agreement between experts and trainees. Conclusions: Among sleep experts and trainees, IR of diagnosis of NFLS, based on videotaped observation of sleep phenomena, is not satisfactory. Explicit video-polysomnographic criteria for the classification of paroxysmal sleep motor phenomena are needed.

KW - Diagnosis

KW - Nocturnal frontal lobe seizures

KW - Parasomnias

KW - Paroxysmal motor phenomena during sleep

KW - Reliability of results

KW - Video-recording

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34547841399&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34547841399&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2007.01121.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2007.01121.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 17484750

AN - SCOPUS:34547841399

VL - 48

SP - 1506

EP - 1511

JO - Epilepsia

JF - Epilepsia

SN - 0013-9580

IS - 8

ER -