Isotopic and nonisotopic assays for measuring somatotropin compared: Re-evaluation of cutoff value in provocative tests

Giuseppe Banfi, Marcello Marinelli, Erminia Casari, Michelangelo Murone, Pierangelo Bonini

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Measurement of human growth hormone (hGH; somatotropin) concentrations in serum after provocative tests is crucial for diagnosing deficiencies in production of this hormone. Serum hGH can be measured by various immunoassays, isotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies: a cutoff value of 10 μg/L after provocative testing is usually used to distinguish normal from hGH-deficient children. Previous studies demonstrated discrepancies in hGH measurement by different radioisotopic immunoassays. Here we evaluated the responses of six different commercial assays, radioisotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies in a series of 16 provocative tests (stimulation with clonidine) in short children. A wide range of discrepant values was obtained with the different kits. A cutoff of 10 μg/L produced discordance of diagnosis among assays for two children, whereas complete agreement was reached for a cutoff value of 7 μg/L. Parallelism tests performed with hGH international standard, pure recombinant hGH, and a serum with high hGH content suggest that heterogeneity of the antibodies used by the manufacturers, even among monoclonal antibodies, is the main source of discordant results. Cutoff values and reference values must be established separately for each method proposed for routine use.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)273-276
Number of pages4
JournalClinical Chemistry
Volume37
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 1991

Fingerprint

Growth Hormone
Assays
Immunoassay
Antibodies
Serum
Human Growth Hormone
Clonidine
Reference Values
Monoclonal Antibodies
Hormones
Testing

Keywords

  • Analytical error
  • Clonidine stimulation
  • Intermethod comparison
  • Monoclonal antibodies

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Biochemistry

Cite this

Isotopic and nonisotopic assays for measuring somatotropin compared : Re-evaluation of cutoff value in provocative tests. / Banfi, Giuseppe; Marinelli, Marcello; Casari, Erminia; Murone, Michelangelo; Bonini, Pierangelo.

In: Clinical Chemistry, Vol. 37, No. 2, 1991, p. 273-276.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2e1a7fb223f04681a1abf10380393b57,
title = "Isotopic and nonisotopic assays for measuring somatotropin compared: Re-evaluation of cutoff value in provocative tests",
abstract = "Measurement of human growth hormone (hGH; somatotropin) concentrations in serum after provocative tests is crucial for diagnosing deficiencies in production of this hormone. Serum hGH can be measured by various immunoassays, isotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies: a cutoff value of 10 μg/L after provocative testing is usually used to distinguish normal from hGH-deficient children. Previous studies demonstrated discrepancies in hGH measurement by different radioisotopic immunoassays. Here we evaluated the responses of six different commercial assays, radioisotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies in a series of 16 provocative tests (stimulation with clonidine) in short children. A wide range of discrepant values was obtained with the different kits. A cutoff of 10 μg/L produced discordance of diagnosis among assays for two children, whereas complete agreement was reached for a cutoff value of 7 μg/L. Parallelism tests performed with hGH international standard, pure recombinant hGH, and a serum with high hGH content suggest that heterogeneity of the antibodies used by the manufacturers, even among monoclonal antibodies, is the main source of discordant results. Cutoff values and reference values must be established separately for each method proposed for routine use.",
keywords = "Analytical error, Clonidine stimulation, Intermethod comparison, Monoclonal antibodies",
author = "Giuseppe Banfi and Marcello Marinelli and Erminia Casari and Michelangelo Murone and Pierangelo Bonini",
year = "1991",
language = "English",
volume = "37",
pages = "273--276",
journal = "Clinical Chemistry",
issn = "0009-9147",
publisher = "American Association for Clinical Chemistry Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Isotopic and nonisotopic assays for measuring somatotropin compared

T2 - Re-evaluation of cutoff value in provocative tests

AU - Banfi, Giuseppe

AU - Marinelli, Marcello

AU - Casari, Erminia

AU - Murone, Michelangelo

AU - Bonini, Pierangelo

PY - 1991

Y1 - 1991

N2 - Measurement of human growth hormone (hGH; somatotropin) concentrations in serum after provocative tests is crucial for diagnosing deficiencies in production of this hormone. Serum hGH can be measured by various immunoassays, isotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies: a cutoff value of 10 μg/L after provocative testing is usually used to distinguish normal from hGH-deficient children. Previous studies demonstrated discrepancies in hGH measurement by different radioisotopic immunoassays. Here we evaluated the responses of six different commercial assays, radioisotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies in a series of 16 provocative tests (stimulation with clonidine) in short children. A wide range of discrepant values was obtained with the different kits. A cutoff of 10 μg/L produced discordance of diagnosis among assays for two children, whereas complete agreement was reached for a cutoff value of 7 μg/L. Parallelism tests performed with hGH international standard, pure recombinant hGH, and a serum with high hGH content suggest that heterogeneity of the antibodies used by the manufacturers, even among monoclonal antibodies, is the main source of discordant results. Cutoff values and reference values must be established separately for each method proposed for routine use.

AB - Measurement of human growth hormone (hGH; somatotropin) concentrations in serum after provocative tests is crucial for diagnosing deficiencies in production of this hormone. Serum hGH can be measured by various immunoassays, isotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies: a cutoff value of 10 μg/L after provocative testing is usually used to distinguish normal from hGH-deficient children. Previous studies demonstrated discrepancies in hGH measurement by different radioisotopic immunoassays. Here we evaluated the responses of six different commercial assays, radioisotopic and nonisotopic, with monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies in a series of 16 provocative tests (stimulation with clonidine) in short children. A wide range of discrepant values was obtained with the different kits. A cutoff of 10 μg/L produced discordance of diagnosis among assays for two children, whereas complete agreement was reached for a cutoff value of 7 μg/L. Parallelism tests performed with hGH international standard, pure recombinant hGH, and a serum with high hGH content suggest that heterogeneity of the antibodies used by the manufacturers, even among monoclonal antibodies, is the main source of discordant results. Cutoff values and reference values must be established separately for each method proposed for routine use.

KW - Analytical error

KW - Clonidine stimulation

KW - Intermethod comparison

KW - Monoclonal antibodies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0025754249&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0025754249&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 1993338

AN - SCOPUS:0025754249

VL - 37

SP - 273

EP - 276

JO - Clinical Chemistry

JF - Clinical Chemistry

SN - 0009-9147

IS - 2

ER -