Malingering and retrograde amnesia: The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic

Stefano Zago, Giuseppe Sartori, Guglielmo Scarlato

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Assessment of feigned cognitive disorders is an important field of neuropsychology because of its applications to forensic settings. Strategies for detecting malingering in amnesia are available for anterograde amnesia. Less attention has been given to malingering in retrograde amnesia. The case of the 'Smemorato di Collegno' (The Collegno Amnesic) is probably the most famous case of malingered retrograde amnesia ever known in Italy. In 1926, a man who appeared to have lost all his autobiographical memories and identity spent nearly a year in the Collegno asylum of Turin without a name. He was later initially identified as Giulio Canella, Director of the 'Scuola Normale di Verona' who had disappeared during the war in 1916. He was suspected of later identified as being Mario Bruneri, a petty crook from Turin who played the part of an amnesic whose retrograde memory gradually returned. A lengthy investigation was required before this conclusion was reached. Several clinicians and renowned academics evaluated the case, but only Alfredo Coppola, diagnosed "malingered retrograde amnesia" using a method that was extremely innovative for the times. The aim of the present paper is to review the original cognitive evaluation and the strategies used for malingering detection in the "Collegno case". The outcome of the case is then discussed in the light of present-day forensic neuropsychology and the level of advancement of mental examination achieved in the 1920s in Europe is highlighted.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)519-532
Number of pages14
JournalCortex
Volume40
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2004

Fingerprint

Retrograde Amnesia
Malingering
Neuropsychology
Anterograde Amnesia
Amnesia
Episodic Memory
Italy
Names

Keywords

  • Collegno's amnesic
  • Malingering amnesia
  • Retrograde amnesia

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cognitive Neuroscience
  • Experimental and Cognitive Psychology
  • Neuropsychology and Physiological Psychology
  • Neuroscience(all)

Cite this

Malingering and retrograde amnesia : The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic. / Zago, Stefano; Sartori, Giuseppe; Scarlato, Guglielmo.

In: Cortex, Vol. 40, No. 3, 2004, p. 519-532.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Zago, S, Sartori, G & Scarlato, G 2004, 'Malingering and retrograde amnesia: The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic', Cortex, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 519-532.
Zago, Stefano ; Sartori, Giuseppe ; Scarlato, Guglielmo. / Malingering and retrograde amnesia : The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic. In: Cortex. 2004 ; Vol. 40, No. 3. pp. 519-532.
@article{8c4cf7383a004c17bc8a4972179ed2ea,
title = "Malingering and retrograde amnesia: The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic",
abstract = "Assessment of feigned cognitive disorders is an important field of neuropsychology because of its applications to forensic settings. Strategies for detecting malingering in amnesia are available for anterograde amnesia. Less attention has been given to malingering in retrograde amnesia. The case of the 'Smemorato di Collegno' (The Collegno Amnesic) is probably the most famous case of malingered retrograde amnesia ever known in Italy. In 1926, a man who appeared to have lost all his autobiographical memories and identity spent nearly a year in the Collegno asylum of Turin without a name. He was later initially identified as Giulio Canella, Director of the 'Scuola Normale di Verona' who had disappeared during the war in 1916. He was suspected of later identified as being Mario Bruneri, a petty crook from Turin who played the part of an amnesic whose retrograde memory gradually returned. A lengthy investigation was required before this conclusion was reached. Several clinicians and renowned academics evaluated the case, but only Alfredo Coppola, diagnosed {"}malingered retrograde amnesia{"} using a method that was extremely innovative for the times. The aim of the present paper is to review the original cognitive evaluation and the strategies used for malingering detection in the {"}Collegno case{"}. The outcome of the case is then discussed in the light of present-day forensic neuropsychology and the level of advancement of mental examination achieved in the 1920s in Europe is highlighted.",
keywords = "Collegno's amnesic, Malingering amnesia, Retrograde amnesia",
author = "Stefano Zago and Giuseppe Sartori and Guglielmo Scarlato",
year = "2004",
language = "English",
volume = "40",
pages = "519--532",
journal = "Cortex",
issn = "0010-9452",
publisher = "Masson SpA",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Malingering and retrograde amnesia

T2 - The historic case of The Collegno Amnesic

AU - Zago, Stefano

AU - Sartori, Giuseppe

AU - Scarlato, Guglielmo

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - Assessment of feigned cognitive disorders is an important field of neuropsychology because of its applications to forensic settings. Strategies for detecting malingering in amnesia are available for anterograde amnesia. Less attention has been given to malingering in retrograde amnesia. The case of the 'Smemorato di Collegno' (The Collegno Amnesic) is probably the most famous case of malingered retrograde amnesia ever known in Italy. In 1926, a man who appeared to have lost all his autobiographical memories and identity spent nearly a year in the Collegno asylum of Turin without a name. He was later initially identified as Giulio Canella, Director of the 'Scuola Normale di Verona' who had disappeared during the war in 1916. He was suspected of later identified as being Mario Bruneri, a petty crook from Turin who played the part of an amnesic whose retrograde memory gradually returned. A lengthy investigation was required before this conclusion was reached. Several clinicians and renowned academics evaluated the case, but only Alfredo Coppola, diagnosed "malingered retrograde amnesia" using a method that was extremely innovative for the times. The aim of the present paper is to review the original cognitive evaluation and the strategies used for malingering detection in the "Collegno case". The outcome of the case is then discussed in the light of present-day forensic neuropsychology and the level of advancement of mental examination achieved in the 1920s in Europe is highlighted.

AB - Assessment of feigned cognitive disorders is an important field of neuropsychology because of its applications to forensic settings. Strategies for detecting malingering in amnesia are available for anterograde amnesia. Less attention has been given to malingering in retrograde amnesia. The case of the 'Smemorato di Collegno' (The Collegno Amnesic) is probably the most famous case of malingered retrograde amnesia ever known in Italy. In 1926, a man who appeared to have lost all his autobiographical memories and identity spent nearly a year in the Collegno asylum of Turin without a name. He was later initially identified as Giulio Canella, Director of the 'Scuola Normale di Verona' who had disappeared during the war in 1916. He was suspected of later identified as being Mario Bruneri, a petty crook from Turin who played the part of an amnesic whose retrograde memory gradually returned. A lengthy investigation was required before this conclusion was reached. Several clinicians and renowned academics evaluated the case, but only Alfredo Coppola, diagnosed "malingered retrograde amnesia" using a method that was extremely innovative for the times. The aim of the present paper is to review the original cognitive evaluation and the strategies used for malingering detection in the "Collegno case". The outcome of the case is then discussed in the light of present-day forensic neuropsychology and the level of advancement of mental examination achieved in the 1920s in Europe is highlighted.

KW - Collegno's amnesic

KW - Malingering amnesia

KW - Retrograde amnesia

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=3142699287&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=3142699287&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 15259331

AN - SCOPUS:3142699287

VL - 40

SP - 519

EP - 532

JO - Cortex

JF - Cortex

SN - 0010-9452

IS - 3

ER -