Nanoindentation: An advanced procedure to investigate osteochondral engineered tissues

Marco Boi, Gregorio Marchiori, Matteo Berni, Alessandro Gambardella, Francesca Salamanna, Andrea Visani, Michele Bianchi, Milena Fini, Giuseppe Filardo

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Osteochondral scaffolds are emerging as a promising alternative for articular cartilage regeneration, although with still controversial results. In particular, the restoration of the osteochondral interface remains an open challenge. The current available investigative procedures are not optimal to quantify the properties of this region, neither to evaluate the quality of the regenerated tissue with respect to the physiological one. This study investigates an advanced procedure able to quantitatively evaluate the mechanical gradient between stiff and compliant tissues, such as in the osteochondral region where the interface between hyaline and calcified cartilage (tidemark) plays an integral role in transferring articular loads from the compliant articular surface to the stiffer underlying bone. A series of nanoindentation line scans was performed along the tidemark - starting from hyaline and expanding across calcified cartilage - on histological sections derived from sheep osteochondral tissue regenerated by a three-layered biomimetic scaffold, as well as to the adjacent healthy tissue for comparative purposes. After an accurate assessment of the indentation parameters, a sigmoid curve-fit function was applied on the reduced modulus profiles to extract gap, width and regularity of the mechanical transition. The designed procedure succeeded in quantitatively assessing the transition between compliant and stiff regions, limiting experimental issues that generally affect the reliability of the indentation mechanical data, such as apex-blunt indenter tip effect, surface roughness, and influence of the substrate. Among the evaluated parameters, the mechanical gap highlighted the main difference between native and regenerated tissues. Thanks to the information retrievable through this procedure, this load transmission area can be further investigated, providing data to tailor osteochondral engineered tissues in the future.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)79-87
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Volume96
Early online dateApr 23 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2019

Fingerprint

Nanoindentation
Tissue
Cartilage
Indentation
Biomimetics
Scaffolds (biology)
Scaffolds
Restoration
Bone
Surface roughness
Substrates

Keywords

  • Cartilage-bone interface
  • Indentation
  • Mechanical gradient
  • Nanomechanical
  • Osteochondral
  • Tidemark

Cite this

Nanoindentation: An advanced procedure to investigate osteochondral engineered tissues. / Boi, Marco; Marchiori, Gregorio; Berni, Matteo; Gambardella, Alessandro; Salamanna, Francesca; Visani, Andrea; Bianchi, Michele; Fini, Milena; Filardo, Giuseppe.

In: Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, Vol. 96, 08.2019, p. 79-87.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Boi, Marco ; Marchiori, Gregorio ; Berni, Matteo ; Gambardella, Alessandro ; Salamanna, Francesca ; Visani, Andrea ; Bianchi, Michele ; Fini, Milena ; Filardo, Giuseppe. / Nanoindentation: An advanced procedure to investigate osteochondral engineered tissues. In: Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials. 2019 ; Vol. 96. pp. 79-87.
@article{2d5c05470f364f21b91483bf4e57f7c5,
title = "Nanoindentation: An advanced procedure to investigate osteochondral engineered tissues",
abstract = "Osteochondral scaffolds are emerging as a promising alternative for articular cartilage regeneration, although with still controversial results. In particular, the restoration of the osteochondral interface remains an open challenge. The current available investigative procedures are not optimal to quantify the properties of this region, neither to evaluate the quality of the regenerated tissue with respect to the physiological one. This study investigates an advanced procedure able to quantitatively evaluate the mechanical gradient between stiff and compliant tissues, such as in the osteochondral region where the interface between hyaline and calcified cartilage (tidemark) plays an integral role in transferring articular loads from the compliant articular surface to the stiffer underlying bone. A series of nanoindentation line scans was performed along the tidemark - starting from hyaline and expanding across calcified cartilage - on histological sections derived from sheep osteochondral tissue regenerated by a three-layered biomimetic scaffold, as well as to the adjacent healthy tissue for comparative purposes. After an accurate assessment of the indentation parameters, a sigmoid curve-fit function was applied on the reduced modulus profiles to extract gap, width and regularity of the mechanical transition. The designed procedure succeeded in quantitatively assessing the transition between compliant and stiff regions, limiting experimental issues that generally affect the reliability of the indentation mechanical data, such as apex-blunt indenter tip effect, surface roughness, and influence of the substrate. Among the evaluated parameters, the mechanical gap highlighted the main difference between native and regenerated tissues. Thanks to the information retrievable through this procedure, this load transmission area can be further investigated, providing data to tailor osteochondral engineered tissues in the future.",
keywords = "Cartilage-bone interface, Indentation, Mechanical gradient, Nanomechanical, Osteochondral, Tidemark",
author = "Marco Boi and Gregorio Marchiori and Matteo Berni and Alessandro Gambardella and Francesca Salamanna and Andrea Visani and Michele Bianchi and Milena Fini and Giuseppe Filardo",
note = "Copyright {\circledC} 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1016/j.jmbbm.2019.04.042",
language = "English",
volume = "96",
pages = "79--87",
journal = "Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials",
issn = "1751-6161",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nanoindentation: An advanced procedure to investigate osteochondral engineered tissues

AU - Boi, Marco

AU - Marchiori, Gregorio

AU - Berni, Matteo

AU - Gambardella, Alessandro

AU - Salamanna, Francesca

AU - Visani, Andrea

AU - Bianchi, Michele

AU - Fini, Milena

AU - Filardo, Giuseppe

N1 - Copyright © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

PY - 2019/8

Y1 - 2019/8

N2 - Osteochondral scaffolds are emerging as a promising alternative for articular cartilage regeneration, although with still controversial results. In particular, the restoration of the osteochondral interface remains an open challenge. The current available investigative procedures are not optimal to quantify the properties of this region, neither to evaluate the quality of the regenerated tissue with respect to the physiological one. This study investigates an advanced procedure able to quantitatively evaluate the mechanical gradient between stiff and compliant tissues, such as in the osteochondral region where the interface between hyaline and calcified cartilage (tidemark) plays an integral role in transferring articular loads from the compliant articular surface to the stiffer underlying bone. A series of nanoindentation line scans was performed along the tidemark - starting from hyaline and expanding across calcified cartilage - on histological sections derived from sheep osteochondral tissue regenerated by a three-layered biomimetic scaffold, as well as to the adjacent healthy tissue for comparative purposes. After an accurate assessment of the indentation parameters, a sigmoid curve-fit function was applied on the reduced modulus profiles to extract gap, width and regularity of the mechanical transition. The designed procedure succeeded in quantitatively assessing the transition between compliant and stiff regions, limiting experimental issues that generally affect the reliability of the indentation mechanical data, such as apex-blunt indenter tip effect, surface roughness, and influence of the substrate. Among the evaluated parameters, the mechanical gap highlighted the main difference between native and regenerated tissues. Thanks to the information retrievable through this procedure, this load transmission area can be further investigated, providing data to tailor osteochondral engineered tissues in the future.

AB - Osteochondral scaffolds are emerging as a promising alternative for articular cartilage regeneration, although with still controversial results. In particular, the restoration of the osteochondral interface remains an open challenge. The current available investigative procedures are not optimal to quantify the properties of this region, neither to evaluate the quality of the regenerated tissue with respect to the physiological one. This study investigates an advanced procedure able to quantitatively evaluate the mechanical gradient between stiff and compliant tissues, such as in the osteochondral region where the interface between hyaline and calcified cartilage (tidemark) plays an integral role in transferring articular loads from the compliant articular surface to the stiffer underlying bone. A series of nanoindentation line scans was performed along the tidemark - starting from hyaline and expanding across calcified cartilage - on histological sections derived from sheep osteochondral tissue regenerated by a three-layered biomimetic scaffold, as well as to the adjacent healthy tissue for comparative purposes. After an accurate assessment of the indentation parameters, a sigmoid curve-fit function was applied on the reduced modulus profiles to extract gap, width and regularity of the mechanical transition. The designed procedure succeeded in quantitatively assessing the transition between compliant and stiff regions, limiting experimental issues that generally affect the reliability of the indentation mechanical data, such as apex-blunt indenter tip effect, surface roughness, and influence of the substrate. Among the evaluated parameters, the mechanical gap highlighted the main difference between native and regenerated tissues. Thanks to the information retrievable through this procedure, this load transmission area can be further investigated, providing data to tailor osteochondral engineered tissues in the future.

KW - Cartilage-bone interface

KW - Indentation

KW - Mechanical gradient

KW - Nanomechanical

KW - Osteochondral

KW - Tidemark

U2 - 10.1016/j.jmbbm.2019.04.042

DO - 10.1016/j.jmbbm.2019.04.042

M3 - Article

C2 - 31029997

VL - 96

SP - 79

EP - 87

JO - Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials

JF - Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials

SN - 1751-6161

ER -