Nutritional intake of young Italian high-level soccer players: Under-reporting is the essential outcome

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

It is recognized that much of the dietary data on adolescents and athletes is prone to reporting error, mostly through underreporting. Nevertheless, in the majority of studies assessing the nutritional intake of young soccer players under-reporting has not been taken into consideration. The purpose of this study was to assess the dietary intake of a sample of young male Italian high-level soccer players on two time points to evaluate the degree of under-reporting. Seventy-five male high level soccer players (age range: 15-17 years) completed 4-day food records on two separate occasions (T0; T1, 3 months after T0). Underreporting was assessed by the ratio of reported estimated energy intake (EEI) to estimated energy expenditure (EEE). Forty-three subjects, whose food records were judged accurate enough both at T0 and T1, were included in the data analysis (inclusion rate 57.3%). No significant weight changes were documented between T0 and T1 and in the two weeks preceding both T0 and T1. Reported mean daily energy intake was significantly lower than mean estimated daily energy expenditure both at T0 and T1 (p <0.001). The average EEI/EEE ratio was 0.75 + 0.2 both at T0 and T1. It was ≤ 80% in 27 subjects (62.8%) at T0 and in 23 (53.4%) at T1; it reached 50% in 4 subjects both at T0 and T1. The degree of under-reporting of the young soccer players was in line with the available data on this age group. This study emphasizes that under-reporting is a critical issue in the evaluation of young athletes dietary intake, which should be considered in the interpretation of data, particularly when energy inadequacies are reported. Further studies with uniformed methods are needed, in order to reduce the degree of under-reporting, obtain reliable data on the dietary intake of young soccer players and evaluate the efficacy of targeted nutrition education programs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)538-542
Number of pages5
JournalJournal of Sports Science and Medicine
Volume6
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2007

Fingerprint

Soccer
Energy Intake
Energy Metabolism
Athletes
Food
Age Groups
Education
Weights and Measures

Keywords

  • Adolescent athletes
  • Dietary records
  • Energy intake
  • Reporting bias

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
  • Physical Therapy, Sports Therapy and Rehabilitation

Cite this

@article{f16047e74655428cacb81ef3d37a1de5,
title = "Nutritional intake of young Italian high-level soccer players: Under-reporting is the essential outcome",
abstract = "It is recognized that much of the dietary data on adolescents and athletes is prone to reporting error, mostly through underreporting. Nevertheless, in the majority of studies assessing the nutritional intake of young soccer players under-reporting has not been taken into consideration. The purpose of this study was to assess the dietary intake of a sample of young male Italian high-level soccer players on two time points to evaluate the degree of under-reporting. Seventy-five male high level soccer players (age range: 15-17 years) completed 4-day food records on two separate occasions (T0; T1, 3 months after T0). Underreporting was assessed by the ratio of reported estimated energy intake (EEI) to estimated energy expenditure (EEE). Forty-three subjects, whose food records were judged accurate enough both at T0 and T1, were included in the data analysis (inclusion rate 57.3{\%}). No significant weight changes were documented between T0 and T1 and in the two weeks preceding both T0 and T1. Reported mean daily energy intake was significantly lower than mean estimated daily energy expenditure both at T0 and T1 (p <0.001). The average EEI/EEE ratio was 0.75 + 0.2 both at T0 and T1. It was ≤ 80{\%} in 27 subjects (62.8{\%}) at T0 and in 23 (53.4{\%}) at T1; it reached 50{\%} in 4 subjects both at T0 and T1. The degree of under-reporting of the young soccer players was in line with the available data on this age group. This study emphasizes that under-reporting is a critical issue in the evaluation of young athletes dietary intake, which should be considered in the interpretation of data, particularly when energy inadequacies are reported. Further studies with uniformed methods are needed, in order to reduce the degree of under-reporting, obtain reliable data on the dietary intake of young soccer players and evaluate the efficacy of targeted nutrition education programs.",
keywords = "Adolescent athletes, Dietary records, Energy intake, Reporting bias",
author = "Riccardo Caccialanza and Barbara Cameletti and Gianfranco Cavallaro",
year = "2007",
month = "12",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
pages = "538--542",
journal = "Journal of Sports Science and Medicine",
issn = "1303-2968",
publisher = "Department of Sports Medicine, Medical Faculty of Uludag University",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Nutritional intake of young Italian high-level soccer players

T2 - Under-reporting is the essential outcome

AU - Caccialanza, Riccardo

AU - Cameletti, Barbara

AU - Cavallaro, Gianfranco

PY - 2007/12

Y1 - 2007/12

N2 - It is recognized that much of the dietary data on adolescents and athletes is prone to reporting error, mostly through underreporting. Nevertheless, in the majority of studies assessing the nutritional intake of young soccer players under-reporting has not been taken into consideration. The purpose of this study was to assess the dietary intake of a sample of young male Italian high-level soccer players on two time points to evaluate the degree of under-reporting. Seventy-five male high level soccer players (age range: 15-17 years) completed 4-day food records on two separate occasions (T0; T1, 3 months after T0). Underreporting was assessed by the ratio of reported estimated energy intake (EEI) to estimated energy expenditure (EEE). Forty-three subjects, whose food records were judged accurate enough both at T0 and T1, were included in the data analysis (inclusion rate 57.3%). No significant weight changes were documented between T0 and T1 and in the two weeks preceding both T0 and T1. Reported mean daily energy intake was significantly lower than mean estimated daily energy expenditure both at T0 and T1 (p <0.001). The average EEI/EEE ratio was 0.75 + 0.2 both at T0 and T1. It was ≤ 80% in 27 subjects (62.8%) at T0 and in 23 (53.4%) at T1; it reached 50% in 4 subjects both at T0 and T1. The degree of under-reporting of the young soccer players was in line with the available data on this age group. This study emphasizes that under-reporting is a critical issue in the evaluation of young athletes dietary intake, which should be considered in the interpretation of data, particularly when energy inadequacies are reported. Further studies with uniformed methods are needed, in order to reduce the degree of under-reporting, obtain reliable data on the dietary intake of young soccer players and evaluate the efficacy of targeted nutrition education programs.

AB - It is recognized that much of the dietary data on adolescents and athletes is prone to reporting error, mostly through underreporting. Nevertheless, in the majority of studies assessing the nutritional intake of young soccer players under-reporting has not been taken into consideration. The purpose of this study was to assess the dietary intake of a sample of young male Italian high-level soccer players on two time points to evaluate the degree of under-reporting. Seventy-five male high level soccer players (age range: 15-17 years) completed 4-day food records on two separate occasions (T0; T1, 3 months after T0). Underreporting was assessed by the ratio of reported estimated energy intake (EEI) to estimated energy expenditure (EEE). Forty-three subjects, whose food records were judged accurate enough both at T0 and T1, were included in the data analysis (inclusion rate 57.3%). No significant weight changes were documented between T0 and T1 and in the two weeks preceding both T0 and T1. Reported mean daily energy intake was significantly lower than mean estimated daily energy expenditure both at T0 and T1 (p <0.001). The average EEI/EEE ratio was 0.75 + 0.2 both at T0 and T1. It was ≤ 80% in 27 subjects (62.8%) at T0 and in 23 (53.4%) at T1; it reached 50% in 4 subjects both at T0 and T1. The degree of under-reporting of the young soccer players was in line with the available data on this age group. This study emphasizes that under-reporting is a critical issue in the evaluation of young athletes dietary intake, which should be considered in the interpretation of data, particularly when energy inadequacies are reported. Further studies with uniformed methods are needed, in order to reduce the degree of under-reporting, obtain reliable data on the dietary intake of young soccer players and evaluate the efficacy of targeted nutrition education programs.

KW - Adolescent athletes

KW - Dietary records

KW - Energy intake

KW - Reporting bias

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=36849038362&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=36849038362&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:36849038362

VL - 6

SP - 538

EP - 542

JO - Journal of Sports Science and Medicine

JF - Journal of Sports Science and Medicine

SN - 1303-2968

IS - 4

ER -