Original article: The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer

R. Grilli, A. Alexanian, G. Apolone, R. Fossati, S. Marsoni, A. Nicolucci, V. Torri, P. Zola, M. Compagnucci, E. Di Mambro, G. Grazzini, L. Mesi, D. Palmieri, G. Tonini, A. Liberati

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Summary: Over the past ten years the Italian National Research Council (C.N.R.) has carried out an educational program based on the preparation and dissemination of guidelines to facilitate delivery in community hospitals of the most up-to-date care to patients with overian cancer. In 1988 an assessment was begun to determine (a) whether the guidelines reached the target physician population; (b) whether they were accepted by those they reached, and (c) whether treatment patterns thereafter conformed to the guidelines. Overall results of this evaluation provide no evidence of clinically relevant effects of the program. The guidelines were not widely disseminated: only 44% of responders were aware of them. Moreover, analysis of practice patterns showed serious deficiencies in diagnostic procedure and surgical staging (information on grading and residual tumour was available only in 30% and 45% of cases, respectively, and only 10% of the patients had random biopsies as part of their surgical staging). The only observation supporting some effect of this educational intervention in terms of knowledge modification was of certain therapeutic preferences among those aware of the guidelines. This finding, however, is highly susceptible to confounding by other factors (e.g. physicians' greater expertise, spillover effect of the program) not entirely avoidable in an observational study. We conclude that any assessment of procedures based on dissemination of information must include a careful analysis of the method of dissemination. The availability of clinically applicable information must also be realistically appraised before the guidelines approach can be accepted as the most effective.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)112-118
Number of pages7
JournalAnnals of Oncology
Volume1
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 1990

Fingerprint

Ovarian Cancer
Oncology
Biopsy
General Hospitals
Ovarian Neoplasms
Tumors
Cancer
Availability
Guidelines
Neoplasms
Therapeutics
Physicians
Observational Study
Information Dissemination
Confounding
Health Services Needs and Demand
Community Hospital
Residual Neoplasm
Grading
Expertise

Keywords

  • Decision-making
  • Health care research
  • Ovarianneoplasm
  • Quality of care

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty
  • Applied Mathematics
  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Neuropsychology and Physiological Psychology
  • Hematology
  • Oncology
  • Cancer Research

Cite this

Grilli, R., Alexanian, A., Apolone, G., Fossati, R., Marsoni, S., Nicolucci, A., ... Liberati, A. (1990). Original article: The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer. Annals of Oncology, 1(2), 112-118.

Original article : The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer. / Grilli, R.; Alexanian, A.; Apolone, G.; Fossati, R.; Marsoni, S.; Nicolucci, A.; Torri, V.; Zola, P.; Compagnucci, M.; Di Mambro, E.; Grazzini, G.; Mesi, L.; Palmieri, D.; Tonini, G.; Liberati, A.

In: Annals of Oncology, Vol. 1, No. 2, 1990, p. 112-118.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Grilli, R, Alexanian, A, Apolone, G, Fossati, R, Marsoni, S, Nicolucci, A, Torri, V, Zola, P, Compagnucci, M, Di Mambro, E, Grazzini, G, Mesi, L, Palmieri, D, Tonini, G & Liberati, A 1990, 'Original article: The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer', Annals of Oncology, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 112-118.
Grilli, R. ; Alexanian, A. ; Apolone, G. ; Fossati, R. ; Marsoni, S. ; Nicolucci, A. ; Torri, V. ; Zola, P. ; Compagnucci, M. ; Di Mambro, E. ; Grazzini, G. ; Mesi, L. ; Palmieri, D. ; Tonini, G. ; Liberati, A. / Original article : The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer. In: Annals of Oncology. 1990 ; Vol. 1, No. 2. pp. 112-118.
@article{a12dc0897705493e80f726f380b4b8cc,
title = "Original article: The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer",
abstract = "Summary: Over the past ten years the Italian National Research Council (C.N.R.) has carried out an educational program based on the preparation and dissemination of guidelines to facilitate delivery in community hospitals of the most up-to-date care to patients with overian cancer. In 1988 an assessment was begun to determine (a) whether the guidelines reached the target physician population; (b) whether they were accepted by those they reached, and (c) whether treatment patterns thereafter conformed to the guidelines. Overall results of this evaluation provide no evidence of clinically relevant effects of the program. The guidelines were not widely disseminated: only 44{\%} of responders were aware of them. Moreover, analysis of practice patterns showed serious deficiencies in diagnostic procedure and surgical staging (information on grading and residual tumour was available only in 30{\%} and 45{\%} of cases, respectively, and only 10{\%} of the patients had random biopsies as part of their surgical staging). The only observation supporting some effect of this educational intervention in terms of knowledge modification was of certain therapeutic preferences among those aware of the guidelines. This finding, however, is highly susceptible to confounding by other factors (e.g. physicians' greater expertise, spillover effect of the program) not entirely avoidable in an observational study. We conclude that any assessment of procedures based on dissemination of information must include a careful analysis of the method of dissemination. The availability of clinically applicable information must also be realistically appraised before the guidelines approach can be accepted as the most effective.",
keywords = "Decision-making, Health care research, Ovarianneoplasm, Quality of care",
author = "R. Grilli and A. Alexanian and G. Apolone and R. Fossati and S. Marsoni and A. Nicolucci and V. Torri and P. Zola and M. Compagnucci and {Di Mambro}, E. and G. Grazzini and L. Mesi and D. Palmieri and G. Tonini and A. Liberati",
year = "1990",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "112--118",
journal = "Annals of Oncology",
issn = "0923-7534",
publisher = "NLM (Medline)",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Original article

T2 - The impact of cancer treatment guidelines on actual practice in Italian general hospitals: The case of ovarian cancer

AU - Grilli, R.

AU - Alexanian, A.

AU - Apolone, G.

AU - Fossati, R.

AU - Marsoni, S.

AU - Nicolucci, A.

AU - Torri, V.

AU - Zola, P.

AU - Compagnucci, M.

AU - Di Mambro, E.

AU - Grazzini, G.

AU - Mesi, L.

AU - Palmieri, D.

AU - Tonini, G.

AU - Liberati, A.

PY - 1990

Y1 - 1990

N2 - Summary: Over the past ten years the Italian National Research Council (C.N.R.) has carried out an educational program based on the preparation and dissemination of guidelines to facilitate delivery in community hospitals of the most up-to-date care to patients with overian cancer. In 1988 an assessment was begun to determine (a) whether the guidelines reached the target physician population; (b) whether they were accepted by those they reached, and (c) whether treatment patterns thereafter conformed to the guidelines. Overall results of this evaluation provide no evidence of clinically relevant effects of the program. The guidelines were not widely disseminated: only 44% of responders were aware of them. Moreover, analysis of practice patterns showed serious deficiencies in diagnostic procedure and surgical staging (information on grading and residual tumour was available only in 30% and 45% of cases, respectively, and only 10% of the patients had random biopsies as part of their surgical staging). The only observation supporting some effect of this educational intervention in terms of knowledge modification was of certain therapeutic preferences among those aware of the guidelines. This finding, however, is highly susceptible to confounding by other factors (e.g. physicians' greater expertise, spillover effect of the program) not entirely avoidable in an observational study. We conclude that any assessment of procedures based on dissemination of information must include a careful analysis of the method of dissemination. The availability of clinically applicable information must also be realistically appraised before the guidelines approach can be accepted as the most effective.

AB - Summary: Over the past ten years the Italian National Research Council (C.N.R.) has carried out an educational program based on the preparation and dissemination of guidelines to facilitate delivery in community hospitals of the most up-to-date care to patients with overian cancer. In 1988 an assessment was begun to determine (a) whether the guidelines reached the target physician population; (b) whether they were accepted by those they reached, and (c) whether treatment patterns thereafter conformed to the guidelines. Overall results of this evaluation provide no evidence of clinically relevant effects of the program. The guidelines were not widely disseminated: only 44% of responders were aware of them. Moreover, analysis of practice patterns showed serious deficiencies in diagnostic procedure and surgical staging (information on grading and residual tumour was available only in 30% and 45% of cases, respectively, and only 10% of the patients had random biopsies as part of their surgical staging). The only observation supporting some effect of this educational intervention in terms of knowledge modification was of certain therapeutic preferences among those aware of the guidelines. This finding, however, is highly susceptible to confounding by other factors (e.g. physicians' greater expertise, spillover effect of the program) not entirely avoidable in an observational study. We conclude that any assessment of procedures based on dissemination of information must include a careful analysis of the method of dissemination. The availability of clinically applicable information must also be realistically appraised before the guidelines approach can be accepted as the most effective.

KW - Decision-making

KW - Health care research

KW - Ovarianneoplasm

KW - Quality of care

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0025276843&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0025276843&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 2078493

AN - SCOPUS:0025276843

VL - 1

SP - 112

EP - 118

JO - Annals of Oncology

JF - Annals of Oncology

SN - 0923-7534

IS - 2

ER -