Palliative care training addressed to hospital healthcare professionals by palliative care specialists: A mixed-method evaluation

Giovanna Artioli, Gabriele Bedini, Elisabetta Bertocchi, Luca Ghirotto, Silvio Cavuto, Massimo Costantini, Silvia Tanzi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Despite the great advances in the concept of palliative care (PC) and its benefits, its application seems to be delayed, leaving unfulfilled the many needs of patients and family members. One way to overcome this difficulty could be to develop a new training programme by palliative care specialists to improve PC primary skills in healthcare professionals. The aim of this study was to evaluate the training's impact on trainees within a hospital setting using Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models. Methods: We adopted a mixed-method evaluation with concurrent triangulation. The evaluation followed the first three steps of Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models and included a pre-and post-training evaluation through self-administered questionnaires and focus groups. We used the McNemar statistical test. Results: The results highlighted the significant amount of knowledge acquired by the hospital professionals after training, in terms of increasing their knowledge of palliative care and in terms of the change in meaning that they attributed to phenomena related to chronicity and incurability, which they encounter daily in their professional practice. In both quantitative and qualitative research, the results, in synthesis, highlight: (i) the development of a new concept of palliative care, centred on the response to the holistic needs of people; (ii) that palliative care can also be extended to non-oncological patients in advanced illness stages (our training was directed to Geriatrics and Nephrology/Dialysis professionals); (iii) the empowerment and the increase in self-esteem that healthcare professionals gained, from learning about the logistical and structural organization of palliative care, to activate and implement PC; (iv) the need to share personal aspects of their professional life (this result emerges only in qualitative research); (v) the appreciation of cooperation and the joining of multiple competences towards a synergistic approach and enhanced outcomes. Conclusion: It is necessary to further develop rigorous research on training evaluation, at the most complex orders of the Kirkpatrick and Moore models, to measure primary PC skills in health care professionals. This will develop the effectiveness of the integration of I-and II-level palliative care competencies in hospitals and improve outcomes of patients' and families' quality of life.

Original languageEnglish
Article number88
JournalBMC Palliative Care
Volume18
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 26 2019

Keywords

  • Educational models
  • Health care professionals
  • Hospital
  • Palliative care
  • Palliative care specialists
  • Training evaluation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Palliative care training addressed to hospital healthcare professionals by palliative care specialists : A mixed-method evaluation. / Artioli, Giovanna; Bedini, Gabriele; Bertocchi, Elisabetta; Ghirotto, Luca; Cavuto, Silvio; Costantini, Massimo; Tanzi, Silvia.

In: BMC Palliative Care, Vol. 18, No. 1, 88, 26.10.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{bcc3392723aa4f69812ac5b5071d5a54,
title = "Palliative care training addressed to hospital healthcare professionals by palliative care specialists: A mixed-method evaluation",
abstract = "Background: Despite the great advances in the concept of palliative care (PC) and its benefits, its application seems to be delayed, leaving unfulfilled the many needs of patients and family members. One way to overcome this difficulty could be to develop a new training programme by palliative care specialists to improve PC primary skills in healthcare professionals. The aim of this study was to evaluate the training's impact on trainees within a hospital setting using Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models. Methods: We adopted a mixed-method evaluation with concurrent triangulation. The evaluation followed the first three steps of Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models and included a pre-and post-training evaluation through self-administered questionnaires and focus groups. We used the McNemar statistical test. Results: The results highlighted the significant amount of knowledge acquired by the hospital professionals after training, in terms of increasing their knowledge of palliative care and in terms of the change in meaning that they attributed to phenomena related to chronicity and incurability, which they encounter daily in their professional practice. In both quantitative and qualitative research, the results, in synthesis, highlight: (i) the development of a new concept of palliative care, centred on the response to the holistic needs of people; (ii) that palliative care can also be extended to non-oncological patients in advanced illness stages (our training was directed to Geriatrics and Nephrology/Dialysis professionals); (iii) the empowerment and the increase in self-esteem that healthcare professionals gained, from learning about the logistical and structural organization of palliative care, to activate and implement PC; (iv) the need to share personal aspects of their professional life (this result emerges only in qualitative research); (v) the appreciation of cooperation and the joining of multiple competences towards a synergistic approach and enhanced outcomes. Conclusion: It is necessary to further develop rigorous research on training evaluation, at the most complex orders of the Kirkpatrick and Moore models, to measure primary PC skills in health care professionals. This will develop the effectiveness of the integration of I-and II-level palliative care competencies in hospitals and improve outcomes of patients' and families' quality of life.",
keywords = "Educational models, Health care professionals, Hospital, Palliative care, Palliative care specialists, Training evaluation",
author = "Giovanna Artioli and Gabriele Bedini and Elisabetta Bertocchi and Luca Ghirotto and Silvio Cavuto and Massimo Costantini and Silvia Tanzi",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "26",
doi = "10.1186/s12904-019-0476-8",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
journal = "BMC Palliative Care",
issn = "1472-684X",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Palliative care training addressed to hospital healthcare professionals by palliative care specialists

T2 - A mixed-method evaluation

AU - Artioli, Giovanna

AU - Bedini, Gabriele

AU - Bertocchi, Elisabetta

AU - Ghirotto, Luca

AU - Cavuto, Silvio

AU - Costantini, Massimo

AU - Tanzi, Silvia

PY - 2019/10/26

Y1 - 2019/10/26

N2 - Background: Despite the great advances in the concept of palliative care (PC) and its benefits, its application seems to be delayed, leaving unfulfilled the many needs of patients and family members. One way to overcome this difficulty could be to develop a new training programme by palliative care specialists to improve PC primary skills in healthcare professionals. The aim of this study was to evaluate the training's impact on trainees within a hospital setting using Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models. Methods: We adopted a mixed-method evaluation with concurrent triangulation. The evaluation followed the first three steps of Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models and included a pre-and post-training evaluation through self-administered questionnaires and focus groups. We used the McNemar statistical test. Results: The results highlighted the significant amount of knowledge acquired by the hospital professionals after training, in terms of increasing their knowledge of palliative care and in terms of the change in meaning that they attributed to phenomena related to chronicity and incurability, which they encounter daily in their professional practice. In both quantitative and qualitative research, the results, in synthesis, highlight: (i) the development of a new concept of palliative care, centred on the response to the holistic needs of people; (ii) that palliative care can also be extended to non-oncological patients in advanced illness stages (our training was directed to Geriatrics and Nephrology/Dialysis professionals); (iii) the empowerment and the increase in self-esteem that healthcare professionals gained, from learning about the logistical and structural organization of palliative care, to activate and implement PC; (iv) the need to share personal aspects of their professional life (this result emerges only in qualitative research); (v) the appreciation of cooperation and the joining of multiple competences towards a synergistic approach and enhanced outcomes. Conclusion: It is necessary to further develop rigorous research on training evaluation, at the most complex orders of the Kirkpatrick and Moore models, to measure primary PC skills in health care professionals. This will develop the effectiveness of the integration of I-and II-level palliative care competencies in hospitals and improve outcomes of patients' and families' quality of life.

AB - Background: Despite the great advances in the concept of palliative care (PC) and its benefits, its application seems to be delayed, leaving unfulfilled the many needs of patients and family members. One way to overcome this difficulty could be to develop a new training programme by palliative care specialists to improve PC primary skills in healthcare professionals. The aim of this study was to evaluate the training's impact on trainees within a hospital setting using Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models. Methods: We adopted a mixed-method evaluation with concurrent triangulation. The evaluation followed the first three steps of Kirkpatrick's and Moore's models and included a pre-and post-training evaluation through self-administered questionnaires and focus groups. We used the McNemar statistical test. Results: The results highlighted the significant amount of knowledge acquired by the hospital professionals after training, in terms of increasing their knowledge of palliative care and in terms of the change in meaning that they attributed to phenomena related to chronicity and incurability, which they encounter daily in their professional practice. In both quantitative and qualitative research, the results, in synthesis, highlight: (i) the development of a new concept of palliative care, centred on the response to the holistic needs of people; (ii) that palliative care can also be extended to non-oncological patients in advanced illness stages (our training was directed to Geriatrics and Nephrology/Dialysis professionals); (iii) the empowerment and the increase in self-esteem that healthcare professionals gained, from learning about the logistical and structural organization of palliative care, to activate and implement PC; (iv) the need to share personal aspects of their professional life (this result emerges only in qualitative research); (v) the appreciation of cooperation and the joining of multiple competences towards a synergistic approach and enhanced outcomes. Conclusion: It is necessary to further develop rigorous research on training evaluation, at the most complex orders of the Kirkpatrick and Moore models, to measure primary PC skills in health care professionals. This will develop the effectiveness of the integration of I-and II-level palliative care competencies in hospitals and improve outcomes of patients' and families' quality of life.

KW - Educational models

KW - Health care professionals

KW - Hospital

KW - Palliative care

KW - Palliative care specialists

KW - Training evaluation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85074168995&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85074168995&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/s12904-019-0476-8

DO - 10.1186/s12904-019-0476-8

M3 - Article

C2 - 31655585

AN - SCOPUS:85074168995

VL - 18

JO - BMC Palliative Care

JF - BMC Palliative Care

SN - 1472-684X

IS - 1

M1 - 88

ER -