Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification: MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey

Hélène C F Côté, Mariana Gerschenson, Ulrich A. Walker, Oscar Miro, Gloria Garrabou, Emma Hammond, Joan Villarroya, Marta Giralt, Francesc Villarroya, Paola Cinque, Elena Garcia-Arumi, Antonio L. Andreu, Marcello Pinti, Andrea Cossarizza

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Mitochondrial DNA quantification by qPCR is used in the context of many diseases and toxicity studies but comparison of results between laboratories is challenging. Through two multigroup distributions of DNA samples from human cell lines, the MITONAUTS group anonymously compared mtDNA/nDNA quantification across nine laboratories involved in HIV research worldwide. Eight of the nine sites showed significant correlation between them (mean raw data R2=0.664; log10-transformed data R2=0.844). Although mtDNA/nDNA values were well correlated between sites, the inter-site variability on the absolute measurements remained high with a mean (range) coefficient of variation of 71 (37-212) %. Some variability appeared cell line-specific, probably due to chromosomal alterations or pseudogenes affecting the quantification of certain genes, while within cell line variability was likely due to differences in calibration of the standard curves. The use of two mtDNA and two single copy nDNA genes with highly specific primers to quantify each genome would help address copy number variants. Our results indicate that sample shipment must be done frozen and that absolute mtDNA/nDNA ratio values cannot readily be compared between laboratories, especially if assessing cultured cell mtDNA content. However, within laboratory and relative mtDNA/nDNA comparisons between laboratories should be reliable.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)520-527
Number of pages8
JournalMitochondrion
Volume11
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2011

Fingerprint

Mitochondrial DNA
Cell Line
Pseudogenes
Surveys and Questionnaires
Calibration
Genes
Cultured Cells
HIV
Genome
DNA
Research

Keywords

  • Inter-laboratory variability
  • MtDNA content by qPCR

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cell Biology
  • Molecular Biology
  • Molecular Medicine

Cite this

Côté, H. C. F., Gerschenson, M., Walker, U. A., Miro, O., Garrabou, G., Hammond, E., ... Cossarizza, A. (2011). Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification: MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey. Mitochondrion, 11(3), 520-527. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mito.2011.01.011

Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification : MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey. / Côté, Hélène C F; Gerschenson, Mariana; Walker, Ulrich A.; Miro, Oscar; Garrabou, Gloria; Hammond, Emma; Villarroya, Joan; Giralt, Marta; Villarroya, Francesc; Cinque, Paola; Garcia-Arumi, Elena; Andreu, Antonio L.; Pinti, Marcello; Cossarizza, Andrea.

In: Mitochondrion, Vol. 11, No. 3, 05.2011, p. 520-527.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Côté, HCF, Gerschenson, M, Walker, UA, Miro, O, Garrabou, G, Hammond, E, Villarroya, J, Giralt, M, Villarroya, F, Cinque, P, Garcia-Arumi, E, Andreu, AL, Pinti, M & Cossarizza, A 2011, 'Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification: MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey', Mitochondrion, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 520-527. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mito.2011.01.011
Côté, Hélène C F ; Gerschenson, Mariana ; Walker, Ulrich A. ; Miro, Oscar ; Garrabou, Gloria ; Hammond, Emma ; Villarroya, Joan ; Giralt, Marta ; Villarroya, Francesc ; Cinque, Paola ; Garcia-Arumi, Elena ; Andreu, Antonio L. ; Pinti, Marcello ; Cossarizza, Andrea. / Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification : MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey. In: Mitochondrion. 2011 ; Vol. 11, No. 3. pp. 520-527.
@article{429e236ea2574c13bd5510b77b687a9c,
title = "Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification: MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey",
abstract = "Mitochondrial DNA quantification by qPCR is used in the context of many diseases and toxicity studies but comparison of results between laboratories is challenging. Through two multigroup distributions of DNA samples from human cell lines, the MITONAUTS group anonymously compared mtDNA/nDNA quantification across nine laboratories involved in HIV research worldwide. Eight of the nine sites showed significant correlation between them (mean raw data R2=0.664; log10-transformed data R2=0.844). Although mtDNA/nDNA values were well correlated between sites, the inter-site variability on the absolute measurements remained high with a mean (range) coefficient of variation of 71 (37-212) {\%}. Some variability appeared cell line-specific, probably due to chromosomal alterations or pseudogenes affecting the quantification of certain genes, while within cell line variability was likely due to differences in calibration of the standard curves. The use of two mtDNA and two single copy nDNA genes with highly specific primers to quantify each genome would help address copy number variants. Our results indicate that sample shipment must be done frozen and that absolute mtDNA/nDNA ratio values cannot readily be compared between laboratories, especially if assessing cultured cell mtDNA content. However, within laboratory and relative mtDNA/nDNA comparisons between laboratories should be reliable.",
keywords = "Inter-laboratory variability, MtDNA content by qPCR",
author = "C{\^o}t{\'e}, {H{\'e}l{\`e}ne C F} and Mariana Gerschenson and Walker, {Ulrich A.} and Oscar Miro and Gloria Garrabou and Emma Hammond and Joan Villarroya and Marta Giralt and Francesc Villarroya and Paola Cinque and Elena Garcia-Arumi and Andreu, {Antonio L.} and Marcello Pinti and Andrea Cossarizza",
year = "2011",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.mito.2011.01.011",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "520--527",
journal = "Mitochondrion",
issn = "1567-7249",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quality assessment of human mitochondrial DNA quantification

T2 - MITONAUTS, an international multicentre survey

AU - Côté, Hélène C F

AU - Gerschenson, Mariana

AU - Walker, Ulrich A.

AU - Miro, Oscar

AU - Garrabou, Gloria

AU - Hammond, Emma

AU - Villarroya, Joan

AU - Giralt, Marta

AU - Villarroya, Francesc

AU - Cinque, Paola

AU - Garcia-Arumi, Elena

AU - Andreu, Antonio L.

AU - Pinti, Marcello

AU - Cossarizza, Andrea

PY - 2011/5

Y1 - 2011/5

N2 - Mitochondrial DNA quantification by qPCR is used in the context of many diseases and toxicity studies but comparison of results between laboratories is challenging. Through two multigroup distributions of DNA samples from human cell lines, the MITONAUTS group anonymously compared mtDNA/nDNA quantification across nine laboratories involved in HIV research worldwide. Eight of the nine sites showed significant correlation between them (mean raw data R2=0.664; log10-transformed data R2=0.844). Although mtDNA/nDNA values were well correlated between sites, the inter-site variability on the absolute measurements remained high with a mean (range) coefficient of variation of 71 (37-212) %. Some variability appeared cell line-specific, probably due to chromosomal alterations or pseudogenes affecting the quantification of certain genes, while within cell line variability was likely due to differences in calibration of the standard curves. The use of two mtDNA and two single copy nDNA genes with highly specific primers to quantify each genome would help address copy number variants. Our results indicate that sample shipment must be done frozen and that absolute mtDNA/nDNA ratio values cannot readily be compared between laboratories, especially if assessing cultured cell mtDNA content. However, within laboratory and relative mtDNA/nDNA comparisons between laboratories should be reliable.

AB - Mitochondrial DNA quantification by qPCR is used in the context of many diseases and toxicity studies but comparison of results between laboratories is challenging. Through two multigroup distributions of DNA samples from human cell lines, the MITONAUTS group anonymously compared mtDNA/nDNA quantification across nine laboratories involved in HIV research worldwide. Eight of the nine sites showed significant correlation between them (mean raw data R2=0.664; log10-transformed data R2=0.844). Although mtDNA/nDNA values were well correlated between sites, the inter-site variability on the absolute measurements remained high with a mean (range) coefficient of variation of 71 (37-212) %. Some variability appeared cell line-specific, probably due to chromosomal alterations or pseudogenes affecting the quantification of certain genes, while within cell line variability was likely due to differences in calibration of the standard curves. The use of two mtDNA and two single copy nDNA genes with highly specific primers to quantify each genome would help address copy number variants. Our results indicate that sample shipment must be done frozen and that absolute mtDNA/nDNA ratio values cannot readily be compared between laboratories, especially if assessing cultured cell mtDNA content. However, within laboratory and relative mtDNA/nDNA comparisons between laboratories should be reliable.

KW - Inter-laboratory variability

KW - MtDNA content by qPCR

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79953755706&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=79953755706&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.mito.2011.01.011

DO - 10.1016/j.mito.2011.01.011

M3 - Article

C2 - 21303702

AN - SCOPUS:79953755706

VL - 11

SP - 520

EP - 527

JO - Mitochondrion

JF - Mitochondrion

SN - 1567-7249

IS - 3

ER -