Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy

Lauro Bucchi, Paolo Cristiani, Silvano Costa, Patrizia Schincaglia, Paola Garutti, Priscilla Sassoli De Bianchi, Carlo Naldoni, Oswaldo Olea, Mario Sideri

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Abstract. Background: Colposcopy, the key step in the management of women with abnormal Pap smear results, is a visual technique prone to observer variation, which implies the need for prolonged apprenticeship, continuous training, and quality assurance (QA) measures. Colposcopy QA programmes vary in level of responsibility of organizing subjects, geographic coverage, scope, model, and type of actions. The programmes addressing the clinical standards of colposcopy (quality of examination and appropriateness of clinical decisions) are more limited in space and less sustainable over time than those focused on the provision of the service (resources, accessibility, etc.). This article reports on the protocol of a QA programme targeting the clinical quality of colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening service in an administrative region of northern Italy. Methods/design. After a situation analysis of local colposcopy audit practices and previous QA initiatives, a permanent web-based QA programme was developed. The design places more emphasis on providing education and feedback to participants than on testing them. The technical core is a log-in web application accessible on the website of the regional Administration. The primary objectives are to provide (1) a practical opportunity for retraining of screening colposcopists, and (2) a platform for them to interact with colposcopists from other settings and regions through exchange and discussion of digital colposcopic images. The retraining function is based on repeated QA sessions in which the registered colposcopists log-in, classify a posted set of colpophotographs, and receive on line a set of personal feedback data. Each session ends with a plenary seminar featuring the presentation of overall results and an interactive review of the test set of colpophotographs. This is meant to be a forum for an open exchange of views that may lead to more knowledge and more diagnostic homogeneity. The protocol includes the criteria for selection of colpophotographs and the rationale for colposcopic gold standards. Discussion. This programme is an ongoing initiative open to further developments, in particular in the area of basic training. It uses the infrastructure of the internet to give a novel solution to technical problems affecting colposcopy QA in population-based screening services.

Original languageEnglish
Article number237
JournalBMC Health Services Research
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Colposcopy
Italy
Population
Papanicolaou Test
Observer Variation
Internet
Patient Selection
Education

Keywords

  • Cervical Cancer Screening
  • Colposcopy
  • Digital
  • Internet
  • Interobserver Agreement
  • Quality Assurance

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy. / Bucchi, Lauro; Cristiani, Paolo; Costa, Silvano; Schincaglia, Patrizia; Garutti, Paola; Sassoli De Bianchi, Priscilla; Naldoni, Carlo; Olea, Oswaldo; Sideri, Mario.

In: BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 13, No. 1, 237, 2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bucchi, Lauro ; Cristiani, Paolo ; Costa, Silvano ; Schincaglia, Patrizia ; Garutti, Paola ; Sassoli De Bianchi, Priscilla ; Naldoni, Carlo ; Olea, Oswaldo ; Sideri, Mario. / Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy. In: BMC Health Services Research. 2013 ; Vol. 13, No. 1.
@article{b4e89440c1de475aa1bebad6760aa084,
title = "Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy",
abstract = "Abstract. Background: Colposcopy, the key step in the management of women with abnormal Pap smear results, is a visual technique prone to observer variation, which implies the need for prolonged apprenticeship, continuous training, and quality assurance (QA) measures. Colposcopy QA programmes vary in level of responsibility of organizing subjects, geographic coverage, scope, model, and type of actions. The programmes addressing the clinical standards of colposcopy (quality of examination and appropriateness of clinical decisions) are more limited in space and less sustainable over time than those focused on the provision of the service (resources, accessibility, etc.). This article reports on the protocol of a QA programme targeting the clinical quality of colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening service in an administrative region of northern Italy. Methods/design. After a situation analysis of local colposcopy audit practices and previous QA initiatives, a permanent web-based QA programme was developed. The design places more emphasis on providing education and feedback to participants than on testing them. The technical core is a log-in web application accessible on the website of the regional Administration. The primary objectives are to provide (1) a practical opportunity for retraining of screening colposcopists, and (2) a platform for them to interact with colposcopists from other settings and regions through exchange and discussion of digital colposcopic images. The retraining function is based on repeated QA sessions in which the registered colposcopists log-in, classify a posted set of colpophotographs, and receive on line a set of personal feedback data. Each session ends with a plenary seminar featuring the presentation of overall results and an interactive review of the test set of colpophotographs. This is meant to be a forum for an open exchange of views that may lead to more knowledge and more diagnostic homogeneity. The protocol includes the criteria for selection of colpophotographs and the rationale for colposcopic gold standards. Discussion. This programme is an ongoing initiative open to further developments, in particular in the area of basic training. It uses the infrastructure of the internet to give a novel solution to technical problems affecting colposcopy QA in population-based screening services.",
keywords = "Cervical Cancer Screening, Colposcopy, Digital, Internet, Interobserver Agreement, Quality Assurance",
author = "Lauro Bucchi and Paolo Cristiani and Silvano Costa and Patrizia Schincaglia and Paola Garutti and {Sassoli De Bianchi}, Priscilla and Carlo Naldoni and Oswaldo Olea and Mario Sideri",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1186/1472-6963-13-237",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "BMC Health Services Research",
issn = "1472-6963",
publisher = "BioMed Central Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rationale and development of an on-line quality assurance programme for colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening setting in Italy

AU - Bucchi, Lauro

AU - Cristiani, Paolo

AU - Costa, Silvano

AU - Schincaglia, Patrizia

AU - Garutti, Paola

AU - Sassoli De Bianchi, Priscilla

AU - Naldoni, Carlo

AU - Olea, Oswaldo

AU - Sideri, Mario

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Abstract. Background: Colposcopy, the key step in the management of women with abnormal Pap smear results, is a visual technique prone to observer variation, which implies the need for prolonged apprenticeship, continuous training, and quality assurance (QA) measures. Colposcopy QA programmes vary in level of responsibility of organizing subjects, geographic coverage, scope, model, and type of actions. The programmes addressing the clinical standards of colposcopy (quality of examination and appropriateness of clinical decisions) are more limited in space and less sustainable over time than those focused on the provision of the service (resources, accessibility, etc.). This article reports on the protocol of a QA programme targeting the clinical quality of colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening service in an administrative region of northern Italy. Methods/design. After a situation analysis of local colposcopy audit practices and previous QA initiatives, a permanent web-based QA programme was developed. The design places more emphasis on providing education and feedback to participants than on testing them. The technical core is a log-in web application accessible on the website of the regional Administration. The primary objectives are to provide (1) a practical opportunity for retraining of screening colposcopists, and (2) a platform for them to interact with colposcopists from other settings and regions through exchange and discussion of digital colposcopic images. The retraining function is based on repeated QA sessions in which the registered colposcopists log-in, classify a posted set of colpophotographs, and receive on line a set of personal feedback data. Each session ends with a plenary seminar featuring the presentation of overall results and an interactive review of the test set of colpophotographs. This is meant to be a forum for an open exchange of views that may lead to more knowledge and more diagnostic homogeneity. The protocol includes the criteria for selection of colpophotographs and the rationale for colposcopic gold standards. Discussion. This programme is an ongoing initiative open to further developments, in particular in the area of basic training. It uses the infrastructure of the internet to give a novel solution to technical problems affecting colposcopy QA in population-based screening services.

AB - Abstract. Background: Colposcopy, the key step in the management of women with abnormal Pap smear results, is a visual technique prone to observer variation, which implies the need for prolonged apprenticeship, continuous training, and quality assurance (QA) measures. Colposcopy QA programmes vary in level of responsibility of organizing subjects, geographic coverage, scope, model, and type of actions. The programmes addressing the clinical standards of colposcopy (quality of examination and appropriateness of clinical decisions) are more limited in space and less sustainable over time than those focused on the provision of the service (resources, accessibility, etc.). This article reports on the protocol of a QA programme targeting the clinical quality of colposcopy in a population-based cervical screening service in an administrative region of northern Italy. Methods/design. After a situation analysis of local colposcopy audit practices and previous QA initiatives, a permanent web-based QA programme was developed. The design places more emphasis on providing education and feedback to participants than on testing them. The technical core is a log-in web application accessible on the website of the regional Administration. The primary objectives are to provide (1) a practical opportunity for retraining of screening colposcopists, and (2) a platform for them to interact with colposcopists from other settings and regions through exchange and discussion of digital colposcopic images. The retraining function is based on repeated QA sessions in which the registered colposcopists log-in, classify a posted set of colpophotographs, and receive on line a set of personal feedback data. Each session ends with a plenary seminar featuring the presentation of overall results and an interactive review of the test set of colpophotographs. This is meant to be a forum for an open exchange of views that may lead to more knowledge and more diagnostic homogeneity. The protocol includes the criteria for selection of colpophotographs and the rationale for colposcopic gold standards. Discussion. This programme is an ongoing initiative open to further developments, in particular in the area of basic training. It uses the infrastructure of the internet to give a novel solution to technical problems affecting colposcopy QA in population-based screening services.

KW - Cervical Cancer Screening

KW - Colposcopy

KW - Digital

KW - Internet

KW - Interobserver Agreement

KW - Quality Assurance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84879424989&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84879424989&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/1472-6963-13-237

DO - 10.1186/1472-6963-13-237

M3 - Article

C2 - 23809615

AN - SCOPUS:84879424989

VL - 13

JO - BMC Health Services Research

JF - BMC Health Services Research

SN - 1472-6963

IS - 1

M1 - 237

ER -