Reliability of medial-longitudinal-arch measures for skin-markers based kinematic analysis

Paolo Caravaggi, Alessandra B Matias, Ulisses T Taddei, Maurizio Ortolani, Alberto Leardini, Isabel C N Sacco

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The medial-longitudinal arch (MLA) is perhaps the most important feature characterizing foot morphology. While current skin-markers based models of the MLA angle used in stereophotogrammetry allow to estimate foot arch shape and deformation, these do not always appear consistent with foot anatomy and with standard clinical definitions. The aim of this study was to propose novel skin-markers based measures of MLA angle and investigate their reliability during common motor tasks. Markers on the calcaneus, navicular tuberosity, first metatarsal head and base, and on the two malleoli were exploited to test eight definitions of MLA angle consistent with foot anatomy, both as angles between two 3-dimensional vectors and as corresponding projections on the sagittal plane of the foot. The inter-trial, inter-session and inter-examiner reliability of each definition was assessed in multiple walking and running trials of two volunteers, tested by four examiners in three sessions. Inter-trial variability in walking was in the range 0.7-1.2 deg, the inter-session 2.8-7.5 deg, and the inter-examiner in the range 3.7-9.3 deg across all MLA definitions. The Rizzoli Foot Model definition showed the lowest inter-session and inter-examiner variability. MLA measures presented similar variability in walking and running. This study provides preliminary information on the reliability of MLA measurements based on skin-markers. According to the present study, angles between 3-dimensional vectors and minimal marker sets should be preferred over sagittal-plane projections. Further studies should be sought to investigate which definition is more accurate with respect to the real MLA deformation in different loading conditions.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Biomechanics
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - Mar 18 2019

Fingerprint

Arches
Biomechanical Phenomena
Foot
Skin
Kinematics
Walking
Running
Anatomy
Photogrammetry
Calcaneus
Metatarsal Bones
Volunteers

Keywords

  • Foot kinematics
  • Medial longitudinal arch
  • Reliability
  • Running
  • Skin-markers
  • Walking

Cite this

Reliability of medial-longitudinal-arch measures for skin-markers based kinematic analysis. / Caravaggi, Paolo; Matias, Alessandra B; Taddei, Ulisses T; Ortolani, Maurizio; Leardini, Alberto; Sacco, Isabel C N.

In: Journal of Biomechanics, 18.03.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7a3eed944d474ddd95e30c3c8f4b6c8f,
title = "Reliability of medial-longitudinal-arch measures for skin-markers based kinematic analysis",
abstract = "The medial-longitudinal arch (MLA) is perhaps the most important feature characterizing foot morphology. While current skin-markers based models of the MLA angle used in stereophotogrammetry allow to estimate foot arch shape and deformation, these do not always appear consistent with foot anatomy and with standard clinical definitions. The aim of this study was to propose novel skin-markers based measures of MLA angle and investigate their reliability during common motor tasks. Markers on the calcaneus, navicular tuberosity, first metatarsal head and base, and on the two malleoli were exploited to test eight definitions of MLA angle consistent with foot anatomy, both as angles between two 3-dimensional vectors and as corresponding projections on the sagittal plane of the foot. The inter-trial, inter-session and inter-examiner reliability of each definition was assessed in multiple walking and running trials of two volunteers, tested by four examiners in three sessions. Inter-trial variability in walking was in the range 0.7-1.2 deg, the inter-session 2.8-7.5 deg, and the inter-examiner in the range 3.7-9.3 deg across all MLA definitions. The Rizzoli Foot Model definition showed the lowest inter-session and inter-examiner variability. MLA measures presented similar variability in walking and running. This study provides preliminary information on the reliability of MLA measurements based on skin-markers. According to the present study, angles between 3-dimensional vectors and minimal marker sets should be preferred over sagittal-plane projections. Further studies should be sought to investigate which definition is more accurate with respect to the real MLA deformation in different loading conditions.",
keywords = "Foot kinematics, Medial longitudinal arch, Reliability, Running, Skin-markers, Walking",
author = "Paolo Caravaggi and Matias, {Alessandra B} and Taddei, {Ulisses T} and Maurizio Ortolani and Alberto Leardini and Sacco, {Isabel C N}",
note = "Copyright {\circledC} 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "18",
doi = "10.1016/j.jbiomech.2019.03.017",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Biomechanics",
issn = "0021-9290",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reliability of medial-longitudinal-arch measures for skin-markers based kinematic analysis

AU - Caravaggi, Paolo

AU - Matias, Alessandra B

AU - Taddei, Ulisses T

AU - Ortolani, Maurizio

AU - Leardini, Alberto

AU - Sacco, Isabel C N

N1 - Copyright © 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

PY - 2019/3/18

Y1 - 2019/3/18

N2 - The medial-longitudinal arch (MLA) is perhaps the most important feature characterizing foot morphology. While current skin-markers based models of the MLA angle used in stereophotogrammetry allow to estimate foot arch shape and deformation, these do not always appear consistent with foot anatomy and with standard clinical definitions. The aim of this study was to propose novel skin-markers based measures of MLA angle and investigate their reliability during common motor tasks. Markers on the calcaneus, navicular tuberosity, first metatarsal head and base, and on the two malleoli were exploited to test eight definitions of MLA angle consistent with foot anatomy, both as angles between two 3-dimensional vectors and as corresponding projections on the sagittal plane of the foot. The inter-trial, inter-session and inter-examiner reliability of each definition was assessed in multiple walking and running trials of two volunteers, tested by four examiners in three sessions. Inter-trial variability in walking was in the range 0.7-1.2 deg, the inter-session 2.8-7.5 deg, and the inter-examiner in the range 3.7-9.3 deg across all MLA definitions. The Rizzoli Foot Model definition showed the lowest inter-session and inter-examiner variability. MLA measures presented similar variability in walking and running. This study provides preliminary information on the reliability of MLA measurements based on skin-markers. According to the present study, angles between 3-dimensional vectors and minimal marker sets should be preferred over sagittal-plane projections. Further studies should be sought to investigate which definition is more accurate with respect to the real MLA deformation in different loading conditions.

AB - The medial-longitudinal arch (MLA) is perhaps the most important feature characterizing foot morphology. While current skin-markers based models of the MLA angle used in stereophotogrammetry allow to estimate foot arch shape and deformation, these do not always appear consistent with foot anatomy and with standard clinical definitions. The aim of this study was to propose novel skin-markers based measures of MLA angle and investigate their reliability during common motor tasks. Markers on the calcaneus, navicular tuberosity, first metatarsal head and base, and on the two malleoli were exploited to test eight definitions of MLA angle consistent with foot anatomy, both as angles between two 3-dimensional vectors and as corresponding projections on the sagittal plane of the foot. The inter-trial, inter-session and inter-examiner reliability of each definition was assessed in multiple walking and running trials of two volunteers, tested by four examiners in three sessions. Inter-trial variability in walking was in the range 0.7-1.2 deg, the inter-session 2.8-7.5 deg, and the inter-examiner in the range 3.7-9.3 deg across all MLA definitions. The Rizzoli Foot Model definition showed the lowest inter-session and inter-examiner variability. MLA measures presented similar variability in walking and running. This study provides preliminary information on the reliability of MLA measurements based on skin-markers. According to the present study, angles between 3-dimensional vectors and minimal marker sets should be preferred over sagittal-plane projections. Further studies should be sought to investigate which definition is more accurate with respect to the real MLA deformation in different loading conditions.

KW - Foot kinematics

KW - Medial longitudinal arch

KW - Reliability

KW - Running

KW - Skin-markers

KW - Walking

U2 - 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2019.03.017

DO - 10.1016/j.jbiomech.2019.03.017

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Biomechanics

JF - Journal of Biomechanics

SN - 0021-9290

ER -