TY - JOUR
T1 - Rubella IgM antibody determination
T2 - comparison of two indirect and two capture commercial enzyme immunoassays.
AU - Revello, M. G.
AU - Percivalle, E.
AU - Zavattoni, M.
AU - Gerna, G.
PY - 1987/10
Y1 - 1987/10
N2 - A new capture ELISA kit (ETI-Rubek-M) for rubella IgM antibody determination was compared with a commercial reverse (Rubenostika IgM) and two indirect ELISAs (Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M). Of the 89 sera from 38 patients with acute rubella infection, 70 gave identical results with the four assays (78% concordance), 74 were in agreement in the two indirect ELISAs, and 83 concorded in the reverse assays (83% and 93% concordance, respectively). On the whole, ETI-Rubek-M and Rubenostika IgM proved equally sensitive; sensitivity of the indirect ELISA kits was lower, Rubazyme-M being slightly more sensitive than Rubelisa M. Specificity of the two reverse assays was 100%, whereas Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M showed a specificity of 88.8% and 93.3%, respectively. In indirect ELISAs, false positive IgM results were mainly observed in cytomegalovirus IgM-positive sera from patients recovering from a primary cytomegalovirus infection. Two sequential sera from one of these patients with IgM to cytomegalovirus were found to be true positive for rubella-specific IgM antibody with ETI-Rubek-M, Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M.
AB - A new capture ELISA kit (ETI-Rubek-M) for rubella IgM antibody determination was compared with a commercial reverse (Rubenostika IgM) and two indirect ELISAs (Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M). Of the 89 sera from 38 patients with acute rubella infection, 70 gave identical results with the four assays (78% concordance), 74 were in agreement in the two indirect ELISAs, and 83 concorded in the reverse assays (83% and 93% concordance, respectively). On the whole, ETI-Rubek-M and Rubenostika IgM proved equally sensitive; sensitivity of the indirect ELISA kits was lower, Rubazyme-M being slightly more sensitive than Rubelisa M. Specificity of the two reverse assays was 100%, whereas Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M showed a specificity of 88.8% and 93.3%, respectively. In indirect ELISAs, false positive IgM results were mainly observed in cytomegalovirus IgM-positive sera from patients recovering from a primary cytomegalovirus infection. Two sequential sera from one of these patients with IgM to cytomegalovirus were found to be true positive for rubella-specific IgM antibody with ETI-Rubek-M, Rubelisa M and Rubazyme-M.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0023426098&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0023426098&partnerID=8YFLogxK
M3 - Article
C2 - 2826972
AN - SCOPUS:0023426098
VL - 10
SP - 393
EP - 401
JO - Microbiologica
JF - Microbiologica
SN - 0391-5352
IS - 4
ER -