Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale: Una stretta relazione

Translated title of the contribution: Somatic symptoms and depression in general practice: A strict relation

M. Passamonti, M. Pigni, C. Fraticelli, G. Calori, A. Sessa, E. Alberti, A. Aranguren, G. Balzarini, F. Baranzini, A. Bianchi, M. Bianchi, G. Camboni, M. Caprari, F. Carnelli, A. Celora, G. Codega, A. Colombo, F. Colombo, V. Colombo, G. CorgatelliM. D'Anna, A. Dalla Villa, E. De Lorenzis, A. Dones, F. Elia, L. Felloni, M. Girola, A. Grassi, D. Guglielmo, E. Host Ivessich, L. Marangoni, A. Maretti, G. Mascheroni, D. Mauro, L. Monestier, A. Monti, M. Passamonti, R. Pericoli, M. Pigni, M. Pizzi, E. Rastelli, M. Rezzonico, O. Rinaldi, D. Rocca, L. Roviglio, M. Scaglioni, C. Scorba, A. Sessa, E. Testolin, G. Tilli, C. Torri, M. G. Venosta, D. Zacchini, L. Zanzi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Introduction. Mood disorders represent a crucial problem in the primary care setting, so that the general practitioner (Gp) must play an increasing role in their management. However, at present the management of depression does not seem appropriate in general practice, because of the many difficulties in recognizing this condition. Objective. A descriptive study on depression and somatic symptoms has been planned in order to value the incidence of depressive disorders in subjects suffering from somatic symptoms, without organic aetiology. Method. Every Gp taking part in the study recruited one day of the week, from 1st November 1999 to 30th June 2000, all patients attending his practice and meeting the criteria for inclusion. Depressed patients with non-organic somatic symptoms were detected using the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire and in those with final score >5 the WHO Checklist of depressive symptoms; depression was diagnosed following ICD-10 criteria. Chi-square test, Mann-Whitney or Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for statistical analysis. Results. 49 Gps took part in the study. Over 1576 days 521 subjects were recruited (1.61% of the patients seeking care); 309 (M/F 74/235) had a G.H.Q. >5; 268 of them had depression (87% - C.I. 95% 83-91): 10.1% mild, 49.2% moderate and 40.7% severe. Asthenia (p=0.001), gastrointestinal symptoms (p=0.03) (dyspepsia, constipation, diarrhoea) were more frequent in depressed patients than in non-depressed ones. The G.H.Q. score was higher in severely depressed patients. There was an increasing proportion of patients with headache, dyspnoea, constipation/diarrhoea, muscle-skeletal pain in classes of increasing severity of depression. Conclusion. The expression of depression in a somatic form is perhaps the commonest reason of under-recognition of depression in primary care. In our study 89.9% of patients with depression had a moderate or severe form. The study demonstrates the feasibility and utility of using the Italian version of the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire as a screening instrument in a general practice setting.

Original languageItalian
Pages (from-to)166-180
Number of pages15
JournalRicerca e Pratica
Volume17
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - 2001

Fingerprint

General Practice
Depression
Constipation
General Practitioners
Diarrhea
Primary Health Care
Medically Unexplained Symptoms
Asthenia
Dyspepsia
Myalgia
Feasibility Studies
International Classification of Diseases
Chi-Square Distribution
Depressive Disorder
Checklist
Mood Disorders
Dyspnea
Headache
Patient Care
Incidence

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pharmacology

Cite this

Passamonti, M., Pigni, M., Fraticelli, C., Calori, G., Sessa, A., Alberti, E., ... Zanzi, L. (2001). Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale: Una stretta relazione. Ricerca e Pratica, 17(4), 166-180.

Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale : Una stretta relazione. / Passamonti, M.; Pigni, M.; Fraticelli, C.; Calori, G.; Sessa, A.; Alberti, E.; Aranguren, A.; Balzarini, G.; Baranzini, F.; Bianchi, A.; Bianchi, M.; Camboni, G.; Caprari, M.; Carnelli, F.; Celora, A.; Codega, G.; Colombo, A.; Colombo, F.; Colombo, V.; Corgatelli, G.; D'Anna, M.; Dalla Villa, A.; De Lorenzis, E.; Dones, A.; Elia, F.; Felloni, L.; Girola, M.; Grassi, A.; Guglielmo, D.; Host Ivessich, E.; Marangoni, L.; Maretti, A.; Mascheroni, G.; Mauro, D.; Monestier, L.; Monti, A.; Passamonti, M.; Pericoli, R.; Pigni, M.; Pizzi, M.; Rastelli, E.; Rezzonico, M.; Rinaldi, O.; Rocca, D.; Roviglio, L.; Scaglioni, M.; Scorba, C.; Sessa, A.; Testolin, E.; Tilli, G.; Torri, C.; Venosta, M. G.; Zacchini, D.; Zanzi, L.

In: Ricerca e Pratica, Vol. 17, No. 4, 2001, p. 166-180.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Passamonti, M, Pigni, M, Fraticelli, C, Calori, G, Sessa, A, Alberti, E, Aranguren, A, Balzarini, G, Baranzini, F, Bianchi, A, Bianchi, M, Camboni, G, Caprari, M, Carnelli, F, Celora, A, Codega, G, Colombo, A, Colombo, F, Colombo, V, Corgatelli, G, D'Anna, M, Dalla Villa, A, De Lorenzis, E, Dones, A, Elia, F, Felloni, L, Girola, M, Grassi, A, Guglielmo, D, Host Ivessich, E, Marangoni, L, Maretti, A, Mascheroni, G, Mauro, D, Monestier, L, Monti, A, Passamonti, M, Pericoli, R, Pigni, M, Pizzi, M, Rastelli, E, Rezzonico, M, Rinaldi, O, Rocca, D, Roviglio, L, Scaglioni, M, Scorba, C, Sessa, A, Testolin, E, Tilli, G, Torri, C, Venosta, MG, Zacchini, D & Zanzi, L 2001, 'Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale: Una stretta relazione', Ricerca e Pratica, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 166-180.
Passamonti M, Pigni M, Fraticelli C, Calori G, Sessa A, Alberti E et al. Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale: Una stretta relazione. Ricerca e Pratica. 2001;17(4):166-180.
Passamonti, M. ; Pigni, M. ; Fraticelli, C. ; Calori, G. ; Sessa, A. ; Alberti, E. ; Aranguren, A. ; Balzarini, G. ; Baranzini, F. ; Bianchi, A. ; Bianchi, M. ; Camboni, G. ; Caprari, M. ; Carnelli, F. ; Celora, A. ; Codega, G. ; Colombo, A. ; Colombo, F. ; Colombo, V. ; Corgatelli, G. ; D'Anna, M. ; Dalla Villa, A. ; De Lorenzis, E. ; Dones, A. ; Elia, F. ; Felloni, L. ; Girola, M. ; Grassi, A. ; Guglielmo, D. ; Host Ivessich, E. ; Marangoni, L. ; Maretti, A. ; Mascheroni, G. ; Mauro, D. ; Monestier, L. ; Monti, A. ; Passamonti, M. ; Pericoli, R. ; Pigni, M. ; Pizzi, M. ; Rastelli, E. ; Rezzonico, M. ; Rinaldi, O. ; Rocca, D. ; Roviglio, L. ; Scaglioni, M. ; Scorba, C. ; Sessa, A. ; Testolin, E. ; Tilli, G. ; Torri, C. ; Venosta, M. G. ; Zacchini, D. ; Zanzi, L. / Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale : Una stretta relazione. In: Ricerca e Pratica. 2001 ; Vol. 17, No. 4. pp. 166-180.
@article{8273b03dd58642669a0bd36a8b869b55,
title = "Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale: Una stretta relazione",
abstract = "Introduction. Mood disorders represent a crucial problem in the primary care setting, so that the general practitioner (Gp) must play an increasing role in their management. However, at present the management of depression does not seem appropriate in general practice, because of the many difficulties in recognizing this condition. Objective. A descriptive study on depression and somatic symptoms has been planned in order to value the incidence of depressive disorders in subjects suffering from somatic symptoms, without organic aetiology. Method. Every Gp taking part in the study recruited one day of the week, from 1st November 1999 to 30th June 2000, all patients attending his practice and meeting the criteria for inclusion. Depressed patients with non-organic somatic symptoms were detected using the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire and in those with final score >5 the WHO Checklist of depressive symptoms; depression was diagnosed following ICD-10 criteria. Chi-square test, Mann-Whitney or Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for statistical analysis. Results. 49 Gps took part in the study. Over 1576 days 521 subjects were recruited (1.61{\%} of the patients seeking care); 309 (M/F 74/235) had a G.H.Q. >5; 268 of them had depression (87{\%} - C.I. 95{\%} 83-91): 10.1{\%} mild, 49.2{\%} moderate and 40.7{\%} severe. Asthenia (p=0.001), gastrointestinal symptoms (p=0.03) (dyspepsia, constipation, diarrhoea) were more frequent in depressed patients than in non-depressed ones. The G.H.Q. score was higher in severely depressed patients. There was an increasing proportion of patients with headache, dyspnoea, constipation/diarrhoea, muscle-skeletal pain in classes of increasing severity of depression. Conclusion. The expression of depression in a somatic form is perhaps the commonest reason of under-recognition of depression in primary care. In our study 89.9{\%} of patients with depression had a moderate or severe form. The study demonstrates the feasibility and utility of using the Italian version of the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire as a screening instrument in a general practice setting.",
author = "M. Passamonti and M. Pigni and C. Fraticelli and G. Calori and A. Sessa and E. Alberti and A. Aranguren and G. Balzarini and F. Baranzini and A. Bianchi and M. Bianchi and G. Camboni and M. Caprari and F. Carnelli and A. Celora and G. Codega and A. Colombo and F. Colombo and V. Colombo and G. Corgatelli and M. D'Anna and {Dalla Villa}, A. and {De Lorenzis}, E. and A. Dones and F. Elia and L. Felloni and M. Girola and A. Grassi and D. Guglielmo and {Host Ivessich}, E. and L. Marangoni and A. Maretti and G. Mascheroni and D. Mauro and L. Monestier and A. Monti and M. Passamonti and R. Pericoli and M. Pigni and M. Pizzi and E. Rastelli and M. Rezzonico and O. Rinaldi and D. Rocca and L. Roviglio and M. Scaglioni and C. Scorba and A. Sessa and E. Testolin and G. Tilli and C. Torri and Venosta, {M. G.} and D. Zacchini and L. Zanzi",
year = "2001",
language = "Italian",
volume = "17",
pages = "166--180",
journal = "Ricerca e Pratica",
issn = "1120-379X",
publisher = "Il Pensiero Scientifico Editore s.r.l.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Sintomi somatici e depressione in medicina generale

T2 - Una stretta relazione

AU - Passamonti, M.

AU - Pigni, M.

AU - Fraticelli, C.

AU - Calori, G.

AU - Sessa, A.

AU - Alberti, E.

AU - Aranguren, A.

AU - Balzarini, G.

AU - Baranzini, F.

AU - Bianchi, A.

AU - Bianchi, M.

AU - Camboni, G.

AU - Caprari, M.

AU - Carnelli, F.

AU - Celora, A.

AU - Codega, G.

AU - Colombo, A.

AU - Colombo, F.

AU - Colombo, V.

AU - Corgatelli, G.

AU - D'Anna, M.

AU - Dalla Villa, A.

AU - De Lorenzis, E.

AU - Dones, A.

AU - Elia, F.

AU - Felloni, L.

AU - Girola, M.

AU - Grassi, A.

AU - Guglielmo, D.

AU - Host Ivessich, E.

AU - Marangoni, L.

AU - Maretti, A.

AU - Mascheroni, G.

AU - Mauro, D.

AU - Monestier, L.

AU - Monti, A.

AU - Passamonti, M.

AU - Pericoli, R.

AU - Pigni, M.

AU - Pizzi, M.

AU - Rastelli, E.

AU - Rezzonico, M.

AU - Rinaldi, O.

AU - Rocca, D.

AU - Roviglio, L.

AU - Scaglioni, M.

AU - Scorba, C.

AU - Sessa, A.

AU - Testolin, E.

AU - Tilli, G.

AU - Torri, C.

AU - Venosta, M. G.

AU - Zacchini, D.

AU - Zanzi, L.

PY - 2001

Y1 - 2001

N2 - Introduction. Mood disorders represent a crucial problem in the primary care setting, so that the general practitioner (Gp) must play an increasing role in their management. However, at present the management of depression does not seem appropriate in general practice, because of the many difficulties in recognizing this condition. Objective. A descriptive study on depression and somatic symptoms has been planned in order to value the incidence of depressive disorders in subjects suffering from somatic symptoms, without organic aetiology. Method. Every Gp taking part in the study recruited one day of the week, from 1st November 1999 to 30th June 2000, all patients attending his practice and meeting the criteria for inclusion. Depressed patients with non-organic somatic symptoms were detected using the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire and in those with final score >5 the WHO Checklist of depressive symptoms; depression was diagnosed following ICD-10 criteria. Chi-square test, Mann-Whitney or Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for statistical analysis. Results. 49 Gps took part in the study. Over 1576 days 521 subjects were recruited (1.61% of the patients seeking care); 309 (M/F 74/235) had a G.H.Q. >5; 268 of them had depression (87% - C.I. 95% 83-91): 10.1% mild, 49.2% moderate and 40.7% severe. Asthenia (p=0.001), gastrointestinal symptoms (p=0.03) (dyspepsia, constipation, diarrhoea) were more frequent in depressed patients than in non-depressed ones. The G.H.Q. score was higher in severely depressed patients. There was an increasing proportion of patients with headache, dyspnoea, constipation/diarrhoea, muscle-skeletal pain in classes of increasing severity of depression. Conclusion. The expression of depression in a somatic form is perhaps the commonest reason of under-recognition of depression in primary care. In our study 89.9% of patients with depression had a moderate or severe form. The study demonstrates the feasibility and utility of using the Italian version of the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire as a screening instrument in a general practice setting.

AB - Introduction. Mood disorders represent a crucial problem in the primary care setting, so that the general practitioner (Gp) must play an increasing role in their management. However, at present the management of depression does not seem appropriate in general practice, because of the many difficulties in recognizing this condition. Objective. A descriptive study on depression and somatic symptoms has been planned in order to value the incidence of depressive disorders in subjects suffering from somatic symptoms, without organic aetiology. Method. Every Gp taking part in the study recruited one day of the week, from 1st November 1999 to 30th June 2000, all patients attending his practice and meeting the criteria for inclusion. Depressed patients with non-organic somatic symptoms were detected using the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire and in those with final score >5 the WHO Checklist of depressive symptoms; depression was diagnosed following ICD-10 criteria. Chi-square test, Mann-Whitney or Kruskal-Wallis tests were used for statistical analysis. Results. 49 Gps took part in the study. Over 1576 days 521 subjects were recruited (1.61% of the patients seeking care); 309 (M/F 74/235) had a G.H.Q. >5; 268 of them had depression (87% - C.I. 95% 83-91): 10.1% mild, 49.2% moderate and 40.7% severe. Asthenia (p=0.001), gastrointestinal symptoms (p=0.03) (dyspepsia, constipation, diarrhoea) were more frequent in depressed patients than in non-depressed ones. The G.H.Q. score was higher in severely depressed patients. There was an increasing proportion of patients with headache, dyspnoea, constipation/diarrhoea, muscle-skeletal pain in classes of increasing severity of depression. Conclusion. The expression of depression in a somatic form is perhaps the commonest reason of under-recognition of depression in primary care. In our study 89.9% of patients with depression had a moderate or severe form. The study demonstrates the feasibility and utility of using the Italian version of the G.H.Q.-12 questionnaire as a screening instrument in a general practice setting.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034797198&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034797198&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Articolo

AN - SCOPUS:0034797198

VL - 17

SP - 166

EP - 180

JO - Ricerca e Pratica

JF - Ricerca e Pratica

SN - 1120-379X

IS - 4

ER -