The ARGA study with general practitioners

Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management

Sandra Baldacci, Sara Maio, Marzia Simoni, Sonia Cerrai, Giuseppe Sarno, Patrizia Silvi, Francesco Di Pede, Marco Borbotti, Anna Paola Pala, Megon Bresciani, Giovanni Viegi, Anna Antonietta Angino, Laura Carrozzi, Maurizio Mangione, Franca Martini, Bona Barbara Piegaia, Francesco Pistelli, Elena Bacci, Lorenza Bancalari, Federico Dente & 41 others Maria Pia Foschino, Gianna Moscato, Pierluigi Paggiaro, Andrea Pelucchi, Pasquale Pierimarchi, Barbara Brunetto, Patrizia Iacovacci, Carlo Pini, Raffaella Tinghino, Francesco Forastiere, Carlo Alberto Perucci, Riccardo Pistelli, Daniela Porta, Laura Ancona, Sara Protasi, Barbara Lazazzera, Valentina Ziroli, Eleonora D'Armini, Sabella Festa Campanile, Monica Ferri, Paola Lorusso, Rita Salotti, Marco Santagati, Elisabetta Agea, Chiara Casciari, Nicola Murgia, Fabrizio Spinozzi, Floriano Bonifazi, Leonardo Antonicelli, Maria Chiara Braschi, Valeria Conti, Amelia Filippelli, Grazia Maria Corbi, Giusy Russomanno, Fulvio Braido, Walter Canonica, Ilaria Baiardini, Balbi Francesco, Isa Cerveri, Angelo Corsico, Amelia Grosso

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim: To evaluate the impact of a medical education course (MEC) on the behaviour of general practitioners (GPs) to treat asthma and allergic rhinitis (AR). Methods: Data on 1820 patients (mean age 41yrs ± 17yrs) with asthma or AR were collected by 107 Italian GPs: 50% attended a MEC and 50% didn't (group B). The adherence for AR and asthma treatment was evaluated according to ARIA and GINA guidelines (GL). Results: AR and asthma were diagnosed in 78% and 56% of patients; 34% had concomitant AR and asthma. Regardless of the MEC, the adherence to GL was significantly higher for AR than for asthma treatment (52 versus 19%). Group B GPs were more compliant to ARIA guidelines in the treatment of mild AR, whereas group A were more compliant in the treatment of moderate-severe AR; the adherence didn't differ between the groups for AR patients with comorbid asthma. Adherence to GINA GL for asthma treatment did not differ between GPs of groups A and B, independently from concomitant AR. Though insignificantly, group A were more compliant to GINA GL in the treatment of patients with only severe persistent asthma (63 versus 46%) as group B were for patients with severe persistent asthma and concomitant AR. Conclusions: GPs often tend to treat patients independently from GL. The impact of a single MEC did not improve adherence to GL in treating less severe AR and asthma patients, while there was a trend towards the opposite attitude in more severe AR patients without concomitant asthma.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)777-785
Number of pages9
JournalRespiratory Medicine
Volume106
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2012

Fingerprint

Rhinitis
Medical Education
General Practitioners
Asthma
Guidelines
Guideline Adherence
Allergic Rhinitis
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Allergic rhinitis
  • ARIA guidelines
  • Asthma
  • Drugs
  • GINA guidelines
  • Prescription adherence

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pulmonary and Respiratory Medicine

Cite this

Baldacci, S., Maio, S., Simoni, M., Cerrai, S., Sarno, G., Silvi, P., ... Grosso, A. (2012). The ARGA study with general practitioners: Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management. Respiratory Medicine, 106(6), 777-785. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rmed.2012.02.013

The ARGA study with general practitioners : Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management. / Baldacci, Sandra; Maio, Sara; Simoni, Marzia; Cerrai, Sonia; Sarno, Giuseppe; Silvi, Patrizia; Di Pede, Francesco; Borbotti, Marco; Paola Pala, Anna; Bresciani, Megon; Viegi, Giovanni; Antonietta Angino, Anna; Carrozzi, Laura; Mangione, Maurizio; Martini, Franca; Barbara Piegaia, Bona; Pistelli, Francesco; Bacci, Elena; Bancalari, Lorenza; Dente, Federico; Pia Foschino, Maria; Moscato, Gianna; Paggiaro, Pierluigi; Pelucchi, Andrea; Pierimarchi, Pasquale; Brunetto, Barbara; Iacovacci, Patrizia; Pini, Carlo; Tinghino, Raffaella; Forastiere, Francesco; Alberto Perucci, Carlo; Pistelli, Riccardo; Porta, Daniela; Ancona, Laura; Protasi, Sara; Lazazzera, Barbara; Ziroli, Valentina; D'Armini, Eleonora; Festa Campanile, Sabella; Ferri, Monica; Lorusso, Paola; Salotti, Rita; Santagati, Marco; Agea, Elisabetta; Casciari, Chiara; Murgia, Nicola; Spinozzi, Fabrizio; Bonifazi, Floriano; Antonicelli, Leonardo; Chiara Braschi, Maria; Conti, Valeria; Filippelli, Amelia; Maria Corbi, Grazia; Russomanno, Giusy; Braido, Fulvio; Canonica, Walter; Baiardini, Ilaria; Francesco, Balbi; Cerveri, Isa; Corsico, Angelo; Grosso, Amelia.

In: Respiratory Medicine, Vol. 106, No. 6, 06.2012, p. 777-785.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Baldacci, S, Maio, S, Simoni, M, Cerrai, S, Sarno, G, Silvi, P, Di Pede, F, Borbotti, M, Paola Pala, A, Bresciani, M, Viegi, G, Antonietta Angino, A, Carrozzi, L, Mangione, M, Martini, F, Barbara Piegaia, B, Pistelli, F, Bacci, E, Bancalari, L, Dente, F, Pia Foschino, M, Moscato, G, Paggiaro, P, Pelucchi, A, Pierimarchi, P, Brunetto, B, Iacovacci, P, Pini, C, Tinghino, R, Forastiere, F, Alberto Perucci, C, Pistelli, R, Porta, D, Ancona, L, Protasi, S, Lazazzera, B, Ziroli, V, D'Armini, E, Festa Campanile, S, Ferri, M, Lorusso, P, Salotti, R, Santagati, M, Agea, E, Casciari, C, Murgia, N, Spinozzi, F, Bonifazi, F, Antonicelli, L, Chiara Braschi, M, Conti, V, Filippelli, A, Maria Corbi, G, Russomanno, G, Braido, F, Canonica, W, Baiardini, I, Francesco, B, Cerveri, I, Corsico, A & Grosso, A 2012, 'The ARGA study with general practitioners: Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management', Respiratory Medicine, vol. 106, no. 6, pp. 777-785. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rmed.2012.02.013
Baldacci, Sandra ; Maio, Sara ; Simoni, Marzia ; Cerrai, Sonia ; Sarno, Giuseppe ; Silvi, Patrizia ; Di Pede, Francesco ; Borbotti, Marco ; Paola Pala, Anna ; Bresciani, Megon ; Viegi, Giovanni ; Antonietta Angino, Anna ; Carrozzi, Laura ; Mangione, Maurizio ; Martini, Franca ; Barbara Piegaia, Bona ; Pistelli, Francesco ; Bacci, Elena ; Bancalari, Lorenza ; Dente, Federico ; Pia Foschino, Maria ; Moscato, Gianna ; Paggiaro, Pierluigi ; Pelucchi, Andrea ; Pierimarchi, Pasquale ; Brunetto, Barbara ; Iacovacci, Patrizia ; Pini, Carlo ; Tinghino, Raffaella ; Forastiere, Francesco ; Alberto Perucci, Carlo ; Pistelli, Riccardo ; Porta, Daniela ; Ancona, Laura ; Protasi, Sara ; Lazazzera, Barbara ; Ziroli, Valentina ; D'Armini, Eleonora ; Festa Campanile, Sabella ; Ferri, Monica ; Lorusso, Paola ; Salotti, Rita ; Santagati, Marco ; Agea, Elisabetta ; Casciari, Chiara ; Murgia, Nicola ; Spinozzi, Fabrizio ; Bonifazi, Floriano ; Antonicelli, Leonardo ; Chiara Braschi, Maria ; Conti, Valeria ; Filippelli, Amelia ; Maria Corbi, Grazia ; Russomanno, Giusy ; Braido, Fulvio ; Canonica, Walter ; Baiardini, Ilaria ; Francesco, Balbi ; Cerveri, Isa ; Corsico, Angelo ; Grosso, Amelia. / The ARGA study with general practitioners : Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management. In: Respiratory Medicine. 2012 ; Vol. 106, No. 6. pp. 777-785.
@article{d55038e9da2f491badab4be71519361d,
title = "The ARGA study with general practitioners: Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management",
abstract = "Aim: To evaluate the impact of a medical education course (MEC) on the behaviour of general practitioners (GPs) to treat asthma and allergic rhinitis (AR). Methods: Data on 1820 patients (mean age 41yrs ± 17yrs) with asthma or AR were collected by 107 Italian GPs: 50{\%} attended a MEC and 50{\%} didn't (group B). The adherence for AR and asthma treatment was evaluated according to ARIA and GINA guidelines (GL). Results: AR and asthma were diagnosed in 78{\%} and 56{\%} of patients; 34{\%} had concomitant AR and asthma. Regardless of the MEC, the adherence to GL was significantly higher for AR than for asthma treatment (52 versus 19{\%}). Group B GPs were more compliant to ARIA guidelines in the treatment of mild AR, whereas group A were more compliant in the treatment of moderate-severe AR; the adherence didn't differ between the groups for AR patients with comorbid asthma. Adherence to GINA GL for asthma treatment did not differ between GPs of groups A and B, independently from concomitant AR. Though insignificantly, group A were more compliant to GINA GL in the treatment of patients with only severe persistent asthma (63 versus 46{\%}) as group B were for patients with severe persistent asthma and concomitant AR. Conclusions: GPs often tend to treat patients independently from GL. The impact of a single MEC did not improve adherence to GL in treating less severe AR and asthma patients, while there was a trend towards the opposite attitude in more severe AR patients without concomitant asthma.",
keywords = "Allergic rhinitis, ARIA guidelines, Asthma, Drugs, GINA guidelines, Prescription adherence",
author = "Sandra Baldacci and Sara Maio and Marzia Simoni and Sonia Cerrai and Giuseppe Sarno and Patrizia Silvi and {Di Pede}, Francesco and Marco Borbotti and {Paola Pala}, Anna and Megon Bresciani and Giovanni Viegi and {Antonietta Angino}, Anna and Laura Carrozzi and Maurizio Mangione and Franca Martini and {Barbara Piegaia}, Bona and Francesco Pistelli and Elena Bacci and Lorenza Bancalari and Federico Dente and {Pia Foschino}, Maria and Gianna Moscato and Pierluigi Paggiaro and Andrea Pelucchi and Pasquale Pierimarchi and Barbara Brunetto and Patrizia Iacovacci and Carlo Pini and Raffaella Tinghino and Francesco Forastiere and {Alberto Perucci}, Carlo and Riccardo Pistelli and Daniela Porta and Laura Ancona and Sara Protasi and Barbara Lazazzera and Valentina Ziroli and Eleonora D'Armini and {Festa Campanile}, Sabella and Monica Ferri and Paola Lorusso and Rita Salotti and Marco Santagati and Elisabetta Agea and Chiara Casciari and Nicola Murgia and Fabrizio Spinozzi and Floriano Bonifazi and Leonardo Antonicelli and {Chiara Braschi}, Maria and Valeria Conti and Amelia Filippelli and {Maria Corbi}, Grazia and Giusy Russomanno and Fulvio Braido and Walter Canonica and Ilaria Baiardini and Balbi Francesco and Isa Cerveri and Angelo Corsico and Amelia Grosso",
year = "2012",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.rmed.2012.02.013",
language = "English",
volume = "106",
pages = "777--785",
journal = "Respiratory Medicine",
issn = "0954-6111",
publisher = "W.B. Saunders Ltd",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The ARGA study with general practitioners

T2 - Impact of medical education on asthma/rhinitis management

AU - Baldacci, Sandra

AU - Maio, Sara

AU - Simoni, Marzia

AU - Cerrai, Sonia

AU - Sarno, Giuseppe

AU - Silvi, Patrizia

AU - Di Pede, Francesco

AU - Borbotti, Marco

AU - Paola Pala, Anna

AU - Bresciani, Megon

AU - Viegi, Giovanni

AU - Antonietta Angino, Anna

AU - Carrozzi, Laura

AU - Mangione, Maurizio

AU - Martini, Franca

AU - Barbara Piegaia, Bona

AU - Pistelli, Francesco

AU - Bacci, Elena

AU - Bancalari, Lorenza

AU - Dente, Federico

AU - Pia Foschino, Maria

AU - Moscato, Gianna

AU - Paggiaro, Pierluigi

AU - Pelucchi, Andrea

AU - Pierimarchi, Pasquale

AU - Brunetto, Barbara

AU - Iacovacci, Patrizia

AU - Pini, Carlo

AU - Tinghino, Raffaella

AU - Forastiere, Francesco

AU - Alberto Perucci, Carlo

AU - Pistelli, Riccardo

AU - Porta, Daniela

AU - Ancona, Laura

AU - Protasi, Sara

AU - Lazazzera, Barbara

AU - Ziroli, Valentina

AU - D'Armini, Eleonora

AU - Festa Campanile, Sabella

AU - Ferri, Monica

AU - Lorusso, Paola

AU - Salotti, Rita

AU - Santagati, Marco

AU - Agea, Elisabetta

AU - Casciari, Chiara

AU - Murgia, Nicola

AU - Spinozzi, Fabrizio

AU - Bonifazi, Floriano

AU - Antonicelli, Leonardo

AU - Chiara Braschi, Maria

AU - Conti, Valeria

AU - Filippelli, Amelia

AU - Maria Corbi, Grazia

AU - Russomanno, Giusy

AU - Braido, Fulvio

AU - Canonica, Walter

AU - Baiardini, Ilaria

AU - Francesco, Balbi

AU - Cerveri, Isa

AU - Corsico, Angelo

AU - Grosso, Amelia

PY - 2012/6

Y1 - 2012/6

N2 - Aim: To evaluate the impact of a medical education course (MEC) on the behaviour of general practitioners (GPs) to treat asthma and allergic rhinitis (AR). Methods: Data on 1820 patients (mean age 41yrs ± 17yrs) with asthma or AR were collected by 107 Italian GPs: 50% attended a MEC and 50% didn't (group B). The adherence for AR and asthma treatment was evaluated according to ARIA and GINA guidelines (GL). Results: AR and asthma were diagnosed in 78% and 56% of patients; 34% had concomitant AR and asthma. Regardless of the MEC, the adherence to GL was significantly higher for AR than for asthma treatment (52 versus 19%). Group B GPs were more compliant to ARIA guidelines in the treatment of mild AR, whereas group A were more compliant in the treatment of moderate-severe AR; the adherence didn't differ between the groups for AR patients with comorbid asthma. Adherence to GINA GL for asthma treatment did not differ between GPs of groups A and B, independently from concomitant AR. Though insignificantly, group A were more compliant to GINA GL in the treatment of patients with only severe persistent asthma (63 versus 46%) as group B were for patients with severe persistent asthma and concomitant AR. Conclusions: GPs often tend to treat patients independently from GL. The impact of a single MEC did not improve adherence to GL in treating less severe AR and asthma patients, while there was a trend towards the opposite attitude in more severe AR patients without concomitant asthma.

AB - Aim: To evaluate the impact of a medical education course (MEC) on the behaviour of general practitioners (GPs) to treat asthma and allergic rhinitis (AR). Methods: Data on 1820 patients (mean age 41yrs ± 17yrs) with asthma or AR were collected by 107 Italian GPs: 50% attended a MEC and 50% didn't (group B). The adherence for AR and asthma treatment was evaluated according to ARIA and GINA guidelines (GL). Results: AR and asthma were diagnosed in 78% and 56% of patients; 34% had concomitant AR and asthma. Regardless of the MEC, the adherence to GL was significantly higher for AR than for asthma treatment (52 versus 19%). Group B GPs were more compliant to ARIA guidelines in the treatment of mild AR, whereas group A were more compliant in the treatment of moderate-severe AR; the adherence didn't differ between the groups for AR patients with comorbid asthma. Adherence to GINA GL for asthma treatment did not differ between GPs of groups A and B, independently from concomitant AR. Though insignificantly, group A were more compliant to GINA GL in the treatment of patients with only severe persistent asthma (63 versus 46%) as group B were for patients with severe persistent asthma and concomitant AR. Conclusions: GPs often tend to treat patients independently from GL. The impact of a single MEC did not improve adherence to GL in treating less severe AR and asthma patients, while there was a trend towards the opposite attitude in more severe AR patients without concomitant asthma.

KW - Allergic rhinitis

KW - ARIA guidelines

KW - Asthma

KW - Drugs

KW - GINA guidelines

KW - Prescription adherence

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84859793605&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84859793605&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.rmed.2012.02.013

DO - 10.1016/j.rmed.2012.02.013

M3 - Article

VL - 106

SP - 777

EP - 785

JO - Respiratory Medicine

JF - Respiratory Medicine

SN - 0954-6111

IS - 6

ER -