The detection of malingered amnesia: An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime

Stefano Zago, Emanuela Piacquadio, Merylin Monaro, Graziella Orrù, Erika Sampaolo, Teresa Difonzo, Andrea Toncini, Eugenio Heinzl

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The nature of amnesia in the context of crime has been the subject of a prolonged debate. It is not uncommon that after committing a violent crime, the offender either does not have any memory of the event or recalls it with some gaps in its recollection. A number of studies have been conducted in order to differentiate between simulated and genuine amnesia. The recognition of probable malingering requires several inferential methods. For instance, it typically involves the defendant’s medical records, self-reports, the observed behavior, and the results of a comprehensive neuropsychological examination. In addition, a variety of procedures that may detect very specific malingered amnesia in crime have been developed. In this paper, we investigated the efficacy of three techniques, facial thermography, kinematic analysis, and symptom validity testing in detecting malingering of amnesia in crime. Participants were randomly assigned to two different experimental conditions: a group was instructed to simulate amnesia after a mock homicide, and a second group was simply asked to behave honestly after committing the mock homicide. The outcomes show that kinematic analysis and symptom validity testing achieve significant accuracy in detecting feigned amnesia, while thermal imaging does not provide converging evidence. Results are encouraging and may provide a first step towards the application of these procedures in a multimethod approach on crime-specific cases of amnesia.

Original languageEnglish
Article number424
JournalFrontiers in Psychiatry
Volume10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Amnesia
Crime
Malingering
Homicide
Biomechanical Phenomena
Self Report
Medical Records
Hot Temperature

Keywords

  • Amnesia
  • Crime
  • Malingering
  • Malingering detection techniques
  • Mock crime

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

The detection of malingered amnesia : An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime. / Zago, Stefano; Piacquadio, Emanuela; Monaro, Merylin; Orrù, Graziella; Sampaolo, Erika; Difonzo, Teresa; Toncini, Andrea; Heinzl, Eugenio.

In: Frontiers in Psychiatry, Vol. 10, 424, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Zago, S, Piacquadio, E, Monaro, M, Orrù, G, Sampaolo, E, Difonzo, T, Toncini, A & Heinzl, E 2019, 'The detection of malingered amnesia: An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime', Frontiers in Psychiatry, vol. 10, 424. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00424
Zago, Stefano ; Piacquadio, Emanuela ; Monaro, Merylin ; Orrù, Graziella ; Sampaolo, Erika ; Difonzo, Teresa ; Toncini, Andrea ; Heinzl, Eugenio. / The detection of malingered amnesia : An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime. In: Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2019 ; Vol. 10.
@article{00157c3b0a424f468262c424ebf179e2,
title = "The detection of malingered amnesia: An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime",
abstract = "The nature of amnesia in the context of crime has been the subject of a prolonged debate. It is not uncommon that after committing a violent crime, the offender either does not have any memory of the event or recalls it with some gaps in its recollection. A number of studies have been conducted in order to differentiate between simulated and genuine amnesia. The recognition of probable malingering requires several inferential methods. For instance, it typically involves the defendant’s medical records, self-reports, the observed behavior, and the results of a comprehensive neuropsychological examination. In addition, a variety of procedures that may detect very specific malingered amnesia in crime have been developed. In this paper, we investigated the efficacy of three techniques, facial thermography, kinematic analysis, and symptom validity testing in detecting malingering of amnesia in crime. Participants were randomly assigned to two different experimental conditions: a group was instructed to simulate amnesia after a mock homicide, and a second group was simply asked to behave honestly after committing the mock homicide. The outcomes show that kinematic analysis and symptom validity testing achieve significant accuracy in detecting feigned amnesia, while thermal imaging does not provide converging evidence. Results are encouraging and may provide a first step towards the application of these procedures in a multimethod approach on crime-specific cases of amnesia.",
keywords = "Amnesia, Crime, Malingering, Malingering detection techniques, Mock crime",
author = "Stefano Zago and Emanuela Piacquadio and Merylin Monaro and Graziella Orr{\`u} and Erika Sampaolo and Teresa Difonzo and Andrea Toncini and Eugenio Heinzl",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00424",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
journal = "Frontiers in Psychiatry",
issn = "1664-0640",
publisher = "Frontiers Research Foundation",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The detection of malingered amnesia

T2 - An approach involving multiple strategies in a mock crime

AU - Zago, Stefano

AU - Piacquadio, Emanuela

AU - Monaro, Merylin

AU - Orrù, Graziella

AU - Sampaolo, Erika

AU - Difonzo, Teresa

AU - Toncini, Andrea

AU - Heinzl, Eugenio

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - The nature of amnesia in the context of crime has been the subject of a prolonged debate. It is not uncommon that after committing a violent crime, the offender either does not have any memory of the event or recalls it with some gaps in its recollection. A number of studies have been conducted in order to differentiate between simulated and genuine amnesia. The recognition of probable malingering requires several inferential methods. For instance, it typically involves the defendant’s medical records, self-reports, the observed behavior, and the results of a comprehensive neuropsychological examination. In addition, a variety of procedures that may detect very specific malingered amnesia in crime have been developed. In this paper, we investigated the efficacy of three techniques, facial thermography, kinematic analysis, and symptom validity testing in detecting malingering of amnesia in crime. Participants were randomly assigned to two different experimental conditions: a group was instructed to simulate amnesia after a mock homicide, and a second group was simply asked to behave honestly after committing the mock homicide. The outcomes show that kinematic analysis and symptom validity testing achieve significant accuracy in detecting feigned amnesia, while thermal imaging does not provide converging evidence. Results are encouraging and may provide a first step towards the application of these procedures in a multimethod approach on crime-specific cases of amnesia.

AB - The nature of amnesia in the context of crime has been the subject of a prolonged debate. It is not uncommon that after committing a violent crime, the offender either does not have any memory of the event or recalls it with some gaps in its recollection. A number of studies have been conducted in order to differentiate between simulated and genuine amnesia. The recognition of probable malingering requires several inferential methods. For instance, it typically involves the defendant’s medical records, self-reports, the observed behavior, and the results of a comprehensive neuropsychological examination. In addition, a variety of procedures that may detect very specific malingered amnesia in crime have been developed. In this paper, we investigated the efficacy of three techniques, facial thermography, kinematic analysis, and symptom validity testing in detecting malingering of amnesia in crime. Participants were randomly assigned to two different experimental conditions: a group was instructed to simulate amnesia after a mock homicide, and a second group was simply asked to behave honestly after committing the mock homicide. The outcomes show that kinematic analysis and symptom validity testing achieve significant accuracy in detecting feigned amnesia, while thermal imaging does not provide converging evidence. Results are encouraging and may provide a first step towards the application of these procedures in a multimethod approach on crime-specific cases of amnesia.

KW - Amnesia

KW - Crime

KW - Malingering

KW - Malingering detection techniques

KW - Mock crime

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85067817077&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85067817077&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00424

DO - 10.3389/fpsyt.2019.00424

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85067817077

VL - 10

JO - Frontiers in Psychiatry

JF - Frontiers in Psychiatry

SN - 1664-0640

M1 - 424

ER -