The good-hearted and the clever

Clinical medicine at the bottom of the barrel of science

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Clinical medicine, the work of listening to and curing the ill or disabled person, is falling progressively into scientific disrepute. Biomedicine and public health dominate the scientific and cultural scene. These disciplines may be seen as variants of the reductionism scientific model. From an extremist perspective, this overshadows the reality of phenomena as a whole, and imposes a never-ending search for causes within increasingly smaller parts. The model has tremendous efficacy where parts can be repaired, yet it fails to come to face with whole-person problems like psychiatric illnesses, acute and chronic disabilities, ageing problems and terminal conditions. The medical model should recuperate its original scientific high ranking, mostly through innovative teaching models, starting at the academic level. It is contended that (a) research should respect the specificity of the medical model; (b) this, in turn, must remain within the boundaries of the contemporary scientific model; (c) upgrading cannot be done simply by adding ethical constraints or, claiming that Medicine is "more than science"; (d) advanced research instruments and methods should be borrowed whenever possible from the social sciences; (e) inductive reasoning, research methods, teaching and psychological skills should become explicit components of the clinicians' curriculum; and (f) medical training should provide that there be early branching into biomedical, clinical and population health specializations. Clinical specializations should be organized into areas sharing the level of interpersonal relationship rather than technical peculiarities.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)103-111
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Medicine and the Person
Volume8
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

Clinical Medicine
Teaching
Research
Social Sciences
Disabled Persons
Curriculum
Psychiatry
Chronic Disease
Public Health
Medicine
Psychology
Health
Population

Keywords

  • Biomedical model
  • Clinical model
  • Medical education
  • Research methods

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Health Policy

Cite this

The good-hearted and the clever : Clinical medicine at the bottom of the barrel of science. / Tesio, Luigi.

In: Journal of Medicine and the Person, Vol. 8, No. 3, 2010, p. 103-111.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{7edcd9cb9c9947a4938dc9e7cffb783a,
title = "The good-hearted and the clever: Clinical medicine at the bottom of the barrel of science",
abstract = "Clinical medicine, the work of listening to and curing the ill or disabled person, is falling progressively into scientific disrepute. Biomedicine and public health dominate the scientific and cultural scene. These disciplines may be seen as variants of the reductionism scientific model. From an extremist perspective, this overshadows the reality of phenomena as a whole, and imposes a never-ending search for causes within increasingly smaller parts. The model has tremendous efficacy where parts can be repaired, yet it fails to come to face with whole-person problems like psychiatric illnesses, acute and chronic disabilities, ageing problems and terminal conditions. The medical model should recuperate its original scientific high ranking, mostly through innovative teaching models, starting at the academic level. It is contended that (a) research should respect the specificity of the medical model; (b) this, in turn, must remain within the boundaries of the contemporary scientific model; (c) upgrading cannot be done simply by adding ethical constraints or, claiming that Medicine is {"}more than science{"}; (d) advanced research instruments and methods should be borrowed whenever possible from the social sciences; (e) inductive reasoning, research methods, teaching and psychological skills should become explicit components of the clinicians' curriculum; and (f) medical training should provide that there be early branching into biomedical, clinical and population health specializations. Clinical specializations should be organized into areas sharing the level of interpersonal relationship rather than technical peculiarities.",
keywords = "Biomedical model, Clinical model, Medical education, Research methods",
author = "Luigi Tesio",
year = "2010",
doi = "10.1007/s12682-010-0063-5",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "103--111",
journal = "Journal of Medicine and the Person",
issn = "2035-9411",
publisher = "Springer-Verlag Italia",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The good-hearted and the clever

T2 - Clinical medicine at the bottom of the barrel of science

AU - Tesio, Luigi

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Clinical medicine, the work of listening to and curing the ill or disabled person, is falling progressively into scientific disrepute. Biomedicine and public health dominate the scientific and cultural scene. These disciplines may be seen as variants of the reductionism scientific model. From an extremist perspective, this overshadows the reality of phenomena as a whole, and imposes a never-ending search for causes within increasingly smaller parts. The model has tremendous efficacy where parts can be repaired, yet it fails to come to face with whole-person problems like psychiatric illnesses, acute and chronic disabilities, ageing problems and terminal conditions. The medical model should recuperate its original scientific high ranking, mostly through innovative teaching models, starting at the academic level. It is contended that (a) research should respect the specificity of the medical model; (b) this, in turn, must remain within the boundaries of the contemporary scientific model; (c) upgrading cannot be done simply by adding ethical constraints or, claiming that Medicine is "more than science"; (d) advanced research instruments and methods should be borrowed whenever possible from the social sciences; (e) inductive reasoning, research methods, teaching and psychological skills should become explicit components of the clinicians' curriculum; and (f) medical training should provide that there be early branching into biomedical, clinical and population health specializations. Clinical specializations should be organized into areas sharing the level of interpersonal relationship rather than technical peculiarities.

AB - Clinical medicine, the work of listening to and curing the ill or disabled person, is falling progressively into scientific disrepute. Biomedicine and public health dominate the scientific and cultural scene. These disciplines may be seen as variants of the reductionism scientific model. From an extremist perspective, this overshadows the reality of phenomena as a whole, and imposes a never-ending search for causes within increasingly smaller parts. The model has tremendous efficacy where parts can be repaired, yet it fails to come to face with whole-person problems like psychiatric illnesses, acute and chronic disabilities, ageing problems and terminal conditions. The medical model should recuperate its original scientific high ranking, mostly through innovative teaching models, starting at the academic level. It is contended that (a) research should respect the specificity of the medical model; (b) this, in turn, must remain within the boundaries of the contemporary scientific model; (c) upgrading cannot be done simply by adding ethical constraints or, claiming that Medicine is "more than science"; (d) advanced research instruments and methods should be borrowed whenever possible from the social sciences; (e) inductive reasoning, research methods, teaching and psychological skills should become explicit components of the clinicians' curriculum; and (f) medical training should provide that there be early branching into biomedical, clinical and population health specializations. Clinical specializations should be organized into areas sharing the level of interpersonal relationship rather than technical peculiarities.

KW - Biomedical model

KW - Clinical model

KW - Medical education

KW - Research methods

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84857170684&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84857170684&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s12682-010-0063-5

DO - 10.1007/s12682-010-0063-5

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 103

EP - 111

JO - Journal of Medicine and the Person

JF - Journal of Medicine and the Person

SN - 2035-9411

IS - 3

ER -