The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics

Paolo Fattorini, Carlo Previderè, Solange Sorçaburu-Cigliero, Giorgio Marrubini, Milena Alù, Anna M. Barbaro, Eugenia Carnevali, Angel Carracedo, Lucia Casarino, Lara Consoloni, Silvia Corato, Ranieri Domenici, Matteo Fabbri, Emiliano Giardina, Pierangela Grignani, Stefania Lonero Baldassarra, Marco Moratti, Vanessa Nicolin, Susi Pelotti, Andrea Piccinini & 16 others Paola Pitacco, Laura Plizza, Nicoletta Resta, Ugo Ricci, Carlo Robino, Luca Salvaderi, Francesca Scarnicci, Peter M. Schneider, Gregorio Seidita, Lucia Trizzino, Chiara Turchi, Stefania Turrina, Paolo Vatta, Carla Vecchiotti, Andrea Verzeletti, Francesco De Stefano

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The role of DNA damage in PCR processivity/fidelity is a relevant topic in molecular investigation of aged/forensic samples. In order to reproduce one of the most common lesions occurring in postmortem tissues, a new protocol based on aqueous hydrolysis of the DNA was developed in vitro. Twenty-five forensic laboratories were then provided with 3.0 μg of a trial sample (TS) exhibiting, in mean, the loss of 1 base of 20, and a molecular weight below 300 bp. Each participating laboratory could freely choose any combination of methods, leading to the quantification and to the definition of the STR profile of the TS, through the documentation of each step of the analytical approaches selected. The results of the TS quantification by qPCR showed significant differences in the amount of DNA recorded by the participating laboratories using different commercial kits. These data show that only DNA quantification "relative" to the used kit (probe) is possible, being the "absolute" amount of DNA inversely related to the length of the target region (r2 = 0.891). In addition, our results indicate that the absence of a shared stable and certified reference quantitative standard is also likely involved. STR profiling was carried out selecting five different commercial kits and amplifying the TS for a total number of 212 multiplex PCRs, thus representing an interesting overview of the different analytical protocols used by the participating laboratories. Nine laboratories decided to characterize the TS using a single kit, with a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 12, obtaining only partial STR profiles. Most of the participants determined partial or full profiles using a combination of two or more kits, and a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 27. The performance of each laboratory was described in terms of number of correctly characterized loci, dropped-out markers, unreliable genotypes, and incorrect results. The incidence of unreliable and incorrect genotypes was found to be higher for participants carrying out a limited number of amplifications, insufficient to define the correct genotypes from damaged DNA samples such as the TS. Finally, from a dataset containing about 4500 amplicons, the frequency of PCR artifacts (allele dropout, allele drop-in, and allelic imbalance) was calculated for each kit showing that the new chemistry of the kits is not able to overcome the concern of template-related factors. The results of this collaborative exercise emphasize the advantages of using a standardized degraded DNA sample in the definition of which analytical parameters are critical for the outcome of the STR profiles.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)3134-3144
Number of pages11
JournalElectrophoresis
Volume35
Issue number21-22
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 1 2014

Fingerprint

Forensic Genetics
Reproducibility of Results
DNA
Amplification
Genotype
Alleles
Allelic Imbalance
Polymerase Chain Reaction
Multiplex Polymerase Chain Reaction
Documentation
Artifacts
DNA Damage
Genetics
Hydrolysis
Molecular Weight
Molecular weight
Tissue
Incidence

Keywords

  • DNA depurination
  • Forensic genetics
  • PCR fidelity
  • STR typing

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry
  • Clinical Biochemistry
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Fattorini, P., Previderè, C., Sorçaburu-Cigliero, S., Marrubini, G., Alù, M., Barbaro, A. M., ... De Stefano, F. (2014). The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics. Electrophoresis, 35(21-22), 3134-3144. https://doi.org/10.1002/elps.201400141

The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics. / Fattorini, Paolo; Previderè, Carlo; Sorçaburu-Cigliero, Solange; Marrubini, Giorgio; Alù, Milena; Barbaro, Anna M.; Carnevali, Eugenia; Carracedo, Angel; Casarino, Lucia; Consoloni, Lara; Corato, Silvia; Domenici, Ranieri; Fabbri, Matteo; Giardina, Emiliano; Grignani, Pierangela; Baldassarra, Stefania Lonero; Moratti, Marco; Nicolin, Vanessa; Pelotti, Susi; Piccinini, Andrea; Pitacco, Paola; Plizza, Laura; Resta, Nicoletta; Ricci, Ugo; Robino, Carlo; Salvaderi, Luca; Scarnicci, Francesca; Schneider, Peter M.; Seidita, Gregorio; Trizzino, Lucia; Turchi, Chiara; Turrina, Stefania; Vatta, Paolo; Vecchiotti, Carla; Verzeletti, Andrea; De Stefano, Francesco.

In: Electrophoresis, Vol. 35, No. 21-22, 01.11.2014, p. 3134-3144.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Fattorini, P, Previderè, C, Sorçaburu-Cigliero, S, Marrubini, G, Alù, M, Barbaro, AM, Carnevali, E, Carracedo, A, Casarino, L, Consoloni, L, Corato, S, Domenici, R, Fabbri, M, Giardina, E, Grignani, P, Baldassarra, SL, Moratti, M, Nicolin, V, Pelotti, S, Piccinini, A, Pitacco, P, Plizza, L, Resta, N, Ricci, U, Robino, C, Salvaderi, L, Scarnicci, F, Schneider, PM, Seidita, G, Trizzino, L, Turchi, C, Turrina, S, Vatta, P, Vecchiotti, C, Verzeletti, A & De Stefano, F 2014, 'The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics', Electrophoresis, vol. 35, no. 21-22, pp. 3134-3144. https://doi.org/10.1002/elps.201400141
Fattorini, Paolo ; Previderè, Carlo ; Sorçaburu-Cigliero, Solange ; Marrubini, Giorgio ; Alù, Milena ; Barbaro, Anna M. ; Carnevali, Eugenia ; Carracedo, Angel ; Casarino, Lucia ; Consoloni, Lara ; Corato, Silvia ; Domenici, Ranieri ; Fabbri, Matteo ; Giardina, Emiliano ; Grignani, Pierangela ; Baldassarra, Stefania Lonero ; Moratti, Marco ; Nicolin, Vanessa ; Pelotti, Susi ; Piccinini, Andrea ; Pitacco, Paola ; Plizza, Laura ; Resta, Nicoletta ; Ricci, Ugo ; Robino, Carlo ; Salvaderi, Luca ; Scarnicci, Francesca ; Schneider, Peter M. ; Seidita, Gregorio ; Trizzino, Lucia ; Turchi, Chiara ; Turrina, Stefania ; Vatta, Paolo ; Vecchiotti, Carla ; Verzeletti, Andrea ; De Stefano, Francesco. / The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics. In: Electrophoresis. 2014 ; Vol. 35, No. 21-22. pp. 3134-3144.
@article{64b8b97233a44602ba50d878108548f7,
title = "The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics",
abstract = "The role of DNA damage in PCR processivity/fidelity is a relevant topic in molecular investigation of aged/forensic samples. In order to reproduce one of the most common lesions occurring in postmortem tissues, a new protocol based on aqueous hydrolysis of the DNA was developed in vitro. Twenty-five forensic laboratories were then provided with 3.0 μg of a trial sample (TS) exhibiting, in mean, the loss of 1 base of 20, and a molecular weight below 300 bp. Each participating laboratory could freely choose any combination of methods, leading to the quantification and to the definition of the STR profile of the TS, through the documentation of each step of the analytical approaches selected. The results of the TS quantification by qPCR showed significant differences in the amount of DNA recorded by the participating laboratories using different commercial kits. These data show that only DNA quantification {"}relative{"} to the used kit (probe) is possible, being the {"}absolute{"} amount of DNA inversely related to the length of the target region (r2 = 0.891). In addition, our results indicate that the absence of a shared stable and certified reference quantitative standard is also likely involved. STR profiling was carried out selecting five different commercial kits and amplifying the TS for a total number of 212 multiplex PCRs, thus representing an interesting overview of the different analytical protocols used by the participating laboratories. Nine laboratories decided to characterize the TS using a single kit, with a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 12, obtaining only partial STR profiles. Most of the participants determined partial or full profiles using a combination of two or more kits, and a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 27. The performance of each laboratory was described in terms of number of correctly characterized loci, dropped-out markers, unreliable genotypes, and incorrect results. The incidence of unreliable and incorrect genotypes was found to be higher for participants carrying out a limited number of amplifications, insufficient to define the correct genotypes from damaged DNA samples such as the TS. Finally, from a dataset containing about 4500 amplicons, the frequency of PCR artifacts (allele dropout, allele drop-in, and allelic imbalance) was calculated for each kit showing that the new chemistry of the kits is not able to overcome the concern of template-related factors. The results of this collaborative exercise emphasize the advantages of using a standardized degraded DNA sample in the definition of which analytical parameters are critical for the outcome of the STR profiles.",
keywords = "DNA depurination, Forensic genetics, PCR fidelity, STR typing",
author = "Paolo Fattorini and Carlo Previder{\`e} and Solange Sor{\cc}aburu-Cigliero and Giorgio Marrubini and Milena Al{\`u} and Barbaro, {Anna M.} and Eugenia Carnevali and Angel Carracedo and Lucia Casarino and Lara Consoloni and Silvia Corato and Ranieri Domenici and Matteo Fabbri and Emiliano Giardina and Pierangela Grignani and Baldassarra, {Stefania Lonero} and Marco Moratti and Vanessa Nicolin and Susi Pelotti and Andrea Piccinini and Paola Pitacco and Laura Plizza and Nicoletta Resta and Ugo Ricci and Carlo Robino and Luca Salvaderi and Francesca Scarnicci and Schneider, {Peter M.} and Gregorio Seidita and Lucia Trizzino and Chiara Turchi and Stefania Turrina and Paolo Vatta and Carla Vecchiotti and Andrea Verzeletti and {De Stefano}, Francesco",
year = "2014",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/elps.201400141",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "3134--3144",
journal = "Electrophoresis",
issn = "0173-0835",
publisher = "Wiley-VCH Verlag",
number = "21-22",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The molecular characterization of a depurinated trial DNA sample can be a model to understand the reliability of the results in forensic genetics

AU - Fattorini, Paolo

AU - Previderè, Carlo

AU - Sorçaburu-Cigliero, Solange

AU - Marrubini, Giorgio

AU - Alù, Milena

AU - Barbaro, Anna M.

AU - Carnevali, Eugenia

AU - Carracedo, Angel

AU - Casarino, Lucia

AU - Consoloni, Lara

AU - Corato, Silvia

AU - Domenici, Ranieri

AU - Fabbri, Matteo

AU - Giardina, Emiliano

AU - Grignani, Pierangela

AU - Baldassarra, Stefania Lonero

AU - Moratti, Marco

AU - Nicolin, Vanessa

AU - Pelotti, Susi

AU - Piccinini, Andrea

AU - Pitacco, Paola

AU - Plizza, Laura

AU - Resta, Nicoletta

AU - Ricci, Ugo

AU - Robino, Carlo

AU - Salvaderi, Luca

AU - Scarnicci, Francesca

AU - Schneider, Peter M.

AU - Seidita, Gregorio

AU - Trizzino, Lucia

AU - Turchi, Chiara

AU - Turrina, Stefania

AU - Vatta, Paolo

AU - Vecchiotti, Carla

AU - Verzeletti, Andrea

AU - De Stefano, Francesco

PY - 2014/11/1

Y1 - 2014/11/1

N2 - The role of DNA damage in PCR processivity/fidelity is a relevant topic in molecular investigation of aged/forensic samples. In order to reproduce one of the most common lesions occurring in postmortem tissues, a new protocol based on aqueous hydrolysis of the DNA was developed in vitro. Twenty-five forensic laboratories were then provided with 3.0 μg of a trial sample (TS) exhibiting, in mean, the loss of 1 base of 20, and a molecular weight below 300 bp. Each participating laboratory could freely choose any combination of methods, leading to the quantification and to the definition of the STR profile of the TS, through the documentation of each step of the analytical approaches selected. The results of the TS quantification by qPCR showed significant differences in the amount of DNA recorded by the participating laboratories using different commercial kits. These data show that only DNA quantification "relative" to the used kit (probe) is possible, being the "absolute" amount of DNA inversely related to the length of the target region (r2 = 0.891). In addition, our results indicate that the absence of a shared stable and certified reference quantitative standard is also likely involved. STR profiling was carried out selecting five different commercial kits and amplifying the TS for a total number of 212 multiplex PCRs, thus representing an interesting overview of the different analytical protocols used by the participating laboratories. Nine laboratories decided to characterize the TS using a single kit, with a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 12, obtaining only partial STR profiles. Most of the participants determined partial or full profiles using a combination of two or more kits, and a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 27. The performance of each laboratory was described in terms of number of correctly characterized loci, dropped-out markers, unreliable genotypes, and incorrect results. The incidence of unreliable and incorrect genotypes was found to be higher for participants carrying out a limited number of amplifications, insufficient to define the correct genotypes from damaged DNA samples such as the TS. Finally, from a dataset containing about 4500 amplicons, the frequency of PCR artifacts (allele dropout, allele drop-in, and allelic imbalance) was calculated for each kit showing that the new chemistry of the kits is not able to overcome the concern of template-related factors. The results of this collaborative exercise emphasize the advantages of using a standardized degraded DNA sample in the definition of which analytical parameters are critical for the outcome of the STR profiles.

AB - The role of DNA damage in PCR processivity/fidelity is a relevant topic in molecular investigation of aged/forensic samples. In order to reproduce one of the most common lesions occurring in postmortem tissues, a new protocol based on aqueous hydrolysis of the DNA was developed in vitro. Twenty-five forensic laboratories were then provided with 3.0 μg of a trial sample (TS) exhibiting, in mean, the loss of 1 base of 20, and a molecular weight below 300 bp. Each participating laboratory could freely choose any combination of methods, leading to the quantification and to the definition of the STR profile of the TS, through the documentation of each step of the analytical approaches selected. The results of the TS quantification by qPCR showed significant differences in the amount of DNA recorded by the participating laboratories using different commercial kits. These data show that only DNA quantification "relative" to the used kit (probe) is possible, being the "absolute" amount of DNA inversely related to the length of the target region (r2 = 0.891). In addition, our results indicate that the absence of a shared stable and certified reference quantitative standard is also likely involved. STR profiling was carried out selecting five different commercial kits and amplifying the TS for a total number of 212 multiplex PCRs, thus representing an interesting overview of the different analytical protocols used by the participating laboratories. Nine laboratories decided to characterize the TS using a single kit, with a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 12, obtaining only partial STR profiles. Most of the participants determined partial or full profiles using a combination of two or more kits, and a number of amplifications varying from 2 to 27. The performance of each laboratory was described in terms of number of correctly characterized loci, dropped-out markers, unreliable genotypes, and incorrect results. The incidence of unreliable and incorrect genotypes was found to be higher for participants carrying out a limited number of amplifications, insufficient to define the correct genotypes from damaged DNA samples such as the TS. Finally, from a dataset containing about 4500 amplicons, the frequency of PCR artifacts (allele dropout, allele drop-in, and allelic imbalance) was calculated for each kit showing that the new chemistry of the kits is not able to overcome the concern of template-related factors. The results of this collaborative exercise emphasize the advantages of using a standardized degraded DNA sample in the definition of which analytical parameters are critical for the outcome of the STR profiles.

KW - DNA depurination

KW - Forensic genetics

KW - PCR fidelity

KW - STR typing

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84916918682&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84916918682&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/elps.201400141

DO - 10.1002/elps.201400141

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 3134

EP - 3144

JO - Electrophoresis

JF - Electrophoresis

SN - 0173-0835

IS - 21-22

ER -