The term diplegia should be enhanced. Part III: Inter-observer reliability of the new rehabilitation oriented classification

R. Pascale, S. Perazza, G. Borelli, E. Bianchini, S. Alboresi, P. B. Paolicelli, A. Ferrari, G. Cioni

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim. The aim of this study was to validate a recent classification of gait in children with the spastic diplegic form of cerebral palsy (CP) by checking the reliability of different scorers in assigning subject walking performance to one of the four specific patterns described in the classification. Methods. The gait patterns of 50 children and adolescents with CP (23 males, 27 females; age range 3-17 years) were selected among patients whose videos were stored in the archives of the Pisa and Reggio Emilia Hospitals. Only video recordings of gait with homogeneous features (duration of at least 90 s, simultaneous recordings on sagittal and frontal views, and other criteria) were taken for examination. The videos were blindly scored using an observational gait scale, at first by two of the authors of the classification system (defined as "maximum experts"), then by ten expert observers, and finally by 206 professionals of rehabilitation after a one-day training on the classification. Cohen's kappa statistics (k) and intra class correlations (ICC) were calculated. Results. Kappa and ICC indicate an almost perfect agreement both between the two maximum experts and among the ten expert observers. Good results were also obtained in the group of one-day trained scorers. Only a few cases were assigned to the "unclassified" category. The profession of the observer (doctor or therapist) and previous knowledge of the classification had no significant influence on reliability scores. Conclusion. The results suggest that the proposed classification can be reliably applied, even utilizing short video recordings, to arrange diplegic children into different patterns. Further studies are needed to validate the use of this classification system for clinical and research aims.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)213-220
Number of pages8
JournalEuropean Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine
Volume44
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2008

Fingerprint

Rehabilitation
Gait
Video Recording
Cerebral Palsy
Walking
Research

Keywords

  • Cerebral palsy, classification
  • Cerebral palsy, diagnosis
  • Cerebral palsy, therapy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Rehabilitation
  • Physical Therapy, Sports Therapy and Rehabilitation

Cite this

The term diplegia should be enhanced. Part III : Inter-observer reliability of the new rehabilitation oriented classification. / Pascale, R.; Perazza, S.; Borelli, G.; Bianchini, E.; Alboresi, S.; Paolicelli, P. B.; Ferrari, A.; Cioni, G.

In: European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, Vol. 44, No. 2, 06.2008, p. 213-220.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{6a0575fc4ecd4c1c8b36f4045fca994d,
title = "The term diplegia should be enhanced. Part III: Inter-observer reliability of the new rehabilitation oriented classification",
abstract = "Aim. The aim of this study was to validate a recent classification of gait in children with the spastic diplegic form of cerebral palsy (CP) by checking the reliability of different scorers in assigning subject walking performance to one of the four specific patterns described in the classification. Methods. The gait patterns of 50 children and adolescents with CP (23 males, 27 females; age range 3-17 years) were selected among patients whose videos were stored in the archives of the Pisa and Reggio Emilia Hospitals. Only video recordings of gait with homogeneous features (duration of at least 90 s, simultaneous recordings on sagittal and frontal views, and other criteria) were taken for examination. The videos were blindly scored using an observational gait scale, at first by two of the authors of the classification system (defined as {"}maximum experts{"}), then by ten expert observers, and finally by 206 professionals of rehabilitation after a one-day training on the classification. Cohen's kappa statistics (k) and intra class correlations (ICC) were calculated. Results. Kappa and ICC indicate an almost perfect agreement both between the two maximum experts and among the ten expert observers. Good results were also obtained in the group of one-day trained scorers. Only a few cases were assigned to the {"}unclassified{"} category. The profession of the observer (doctor or therapist) and previous knowledge of the classification had no significant influence on reliability scores. Conclusion. The results suggest that the proposed classification can be reliably applied, even utilizing short video recordings, to arrange diplegic children into different patterns. Further studies are needed to validate the use of this classification system for clinical and research aims.",
keywords = "Cerebral palsy, classification, Cerebral palsy, diagnosis, Cerebral palsy, therapy",
author = "R. Pascale and S. Perazza and G. Borelli and E. Bianchini and S. Alboresi and Paolicelli, {P. B.} and A. Ferrari and G. Cioni",
year = "2008",
month = "6",
language = "English",
volume = "44",
pages = "213--220",
journal = "European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine",
issn = "1973-9087",
publisher = "Edizioni Minerva Medica S.p.A.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The term diplegia should be enhanced. Part III

T2 - Inter-observer reliability of the new rehabilitation oriented classification

AU - Pascale, R.

AU - Perazza, S.

AU - Borelli, G.

AU - Bianchini, E.

AU - Alboresi, S.

AU - Paolicelli, P. B.

AU - Ferrari, A.

AU - Cioni, G.

PY - 2008/6

Y1 - 2008/6

N2 - Aim. The aim of this study was to validate a recent classification of gait in children with the spastic diplegic form of cerebral palsy (CP) by checking the reliability of different scorers in assigning subject walking performance to one of the four specific patterns described in the classification. Methods. The gait patterns of 50 children and adolescents with CP (23 males, 27 females; age range 3-17 years) were selected among patients whose videos were stored in the archives of the Pisa and Reggio Emilia Hospitals. Only video recordings of gait with homogeneous features (duration of at least 90 s, simultaneous recordings on sagittal and frontal views, and other criteria) were taken for examination. The videos were blindly scored using an observational gait scale, at first by two of the authors of the classification system (defined as "maximum experts"), then by ten expert observers, and finally by 206 professionals of rehabilitation after a one-day training on the classification. Cohen's kappa statistics (k) and intra class correlations (ICC) were calculated. Results. Kappa and ICC indicate an almost perfect agreement both between the two maximum experts and among the ten expert observers. Good results were also obtained in the group of one-day trained scorers. Only a few cases were assigned to the "unclassified" category. The profession of the observer (doctor or therapist) and previous knowledge of the classification had no significant influence on reliability scores. Conclusion. The results suggest that the proposed classification can be reliably applied, even utilizing short video recordings, to arrange diplegic children into different patterns. Further studies are needed to validate the use of this classification system for clinical and research aims.

AB - Aim. The aim of this study was to validate a recent classification of gait in children with the spastic diplegic form of cerebral palsy (CP) by checking the reliability of different scorers in assigning subject walking performance to one of the four specific patterns described in the classification. Methods. The gait patterns of 50 children and adolescents with CP (23 males, 27 females; age range 3-17 years) were selected among patients whose videos were stored in the archives of the Pisa and Reggio Emilia Hospitals. Only video recordings of gait with homogeneous features (duration of at least 90 s, simultaneous recordings on sagittal and frontal views, and other criteria) were taken for examination. The videos were blindly scored using an observational gait scale, at first by two of the authors of the classification system (defined as "maximum experts"), then by ten expert observers, and finally by 206 professionals of rehabilitation after a one-day training on the classification. Cohen's kappa statistics (k) and intra class correlations (ICC) were calculated. Results. Kappa and ICC indicate an almost perfect agreement both between the two maximum experts and among the ten expert observers. Good results were also obtained in the group of one-day trained scorers. Only a few cases were assigned to the "unclassified" category. The profession of the observer (doctor or therapist) and previous knowledge of the classification had no significant influence on reliability scores. Conclusion. The results suggest that the proposed classification can be reliably applied, even utilizing short video recordings, to arrange diplegic children into different patterns. Further studies are needed to validate the use of this classification system for clinical and research aims.

KW - Cerebral palsy, classification

KW - Cerebral palsy, diagnosis

KW - Cerebral palsy, therapy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=45549084844&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=45549084844&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 18418341

AN - SCOPUS:45549084844

VL - 44

SP - 213

EP - 220

JO - European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine

JF - European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine

SN - 1973-9087

IS - 2

ER -