Soluzione salina ipertonica in corso di bronchiolite acuta: fare meno è fare di più?

Translated title of the contribution: Treatment with nebulized hypertonic solution in children with acute bronchiolitis: "Less is more"

Sara Pusceddu, Giorgio Cozzi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Since 2013, all the published trials, without any exception, showed that treatment with nebulized hypertonic solution did not reduce the length of stay in hospital (LOS) of children with acute bronchiolitis. Trials published before 2013 were flawed by significant methodological weakness e.g. no uniform bronchiolitis definition, heterogeneity of interventions or clinical scoring and, above all, the inclusion of children older than 12 months. Nevertheless, considering all trials, the supposed reduction in the LOS is nearly of 11 hours only. Since 2013, only one trial, at high risk of patients' selection bias, showed a benefit of this treatment to reduce the risk of hospitalization of these children. The most recent and better methodologically designed trials do not support the use of nebulized hypertonic solution in children with acute bronchiolitis. Therefore, available evidence does not allow to consider hypertonic solution potentially effective and well tolerated for acute bronchiolitis neither does justify its routinely use in clinical practice.

Original languageItalian
Pages (from-to)581-584
Number of pages4
JournalMedico e Bambino
Volume34
Issue number9
Publication statusPublished - Nov 1 2015

Fingerprint

Hypertonic Solutions
Bronchiolitis
Selection Bias
Therapeutics
Patient Selection
Length of Stay
Hospitalization

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health

Cite this

Soluzione salina ipertonica in corso di bronchiolite acuta : fare meno è fare di più? / Pusceddu, Sara; Cozzi, Giorgio.

In: Medico e Bambino, Vol. 34, No. 9, 01.11.2015, p. 581-584.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ed44c7df521b4e3aba20b542f9c51eb7,
title = "Soluzione salina ipertonica in corso di bronchiolite acuta: fare meno {\`e} fare di pi{\`u}?",
abstract = "Since 2013, all the published trials, without any exception, showed that treatment with nebulized hypertonic solution did not reduce the length of stay in hospital (LOS) of children with acute bronchiolitis. Trials published before 2013 were flawed by significant methodological weakness e.g. no uniform bronchiolitis definition, heterogeneity of interventions or clinical scoring and, above all, the inclusion of children older than 12 months. Nevertheless, considering all trials, the supposed reduction in the LOS is nearly of 11 hours only. Since 2013, only one trial, at high risk of patients' selection bias, showed a benefit of this treatment to reduce the risk of hospitalization of these children. The most recent and better methodologically designed trials do not support the use of nebulized hypertonic solution in children with acute bronchiolitis. Therefore, available evidence does not allow to consider hypertonic solution potentially effective and well tolerated for acute bronchiolitis neither does justify its routinely use in clinical practice.",
keywords = "Acute bronchiolitis, Length of stay in hospital, Nebulized hypertonic solution",
author = "Sara Pusceddu and Giorgio Cozzi",
year = "2015",
month = "11",
day = "1",
language = "Italian",
volume = "34",
pages = "581--584",
journal = "Medico e Bambino",
issn = "1591-3090",
publisher = "Medico e Bambino",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Soluzione salina ipertonica in corso di bronchiolite acuta

T2 - fare meno è fare di più?

AU - Pusceddu, Sara

AU - Cozzi, Giorgio

PY - 2015/11/1

Y1 - 2015/11/1

N2 - Since 2013, all the published trials, without any exception, showed that treatment with nebulized hypertonic solution did not reduce the length of stay in hospital (LOS) of children with acute bronchiolitis. Trials published before 2013 were flawed by significant methodological weakness e.g. no uniform bronchiolitis definition, heterogeneity of interventions or clinical scoring and, above all, the inclusion of children older than 12 months. Nevertheless, considering all trials, the supposed reduction in the LOS is nearly of 11 hours only. Since 2013, only one trial, at high risk of patients' selection bias, showed a benefit of this treatment to reduce the risk of hospitalization of these children. The most recent and better methodologically designed trials do not support the use of nebulized hypertonic solution in children with acute bronchiolitis. Therefore, available evidence does not allow to consider hypertonic solution potentially effective and well tolerated for acute bronchiolitis neither does justify its routinely use in clinical practice.

AB - Since 2013, all the published trials, without any exception, showed that treatment with nebulized hypertonic solution did not reduce the length of stay in hospital (LOS) of children with acute bronchiolitis. Trials published before 2013 were flawed by significant methodological weakness e.g. no uniform bronchiolitis definition, heterogeneity of interventions or clinical scoring and, above all, the inclusion of children older than 12 months. Nevertheless, considering all trials, the supposed reduction in the LOS is nearly of 11 hours only. Since 2013, only one trial, at high risk of patients' selection bias, showed a benefit of this treatment to reduce the risk of hospitalization of these children. The most recent and better methodologically designed trials do not support the use of nebulized hypertonic solution in children with acute bronchiolitis. Therefore, available evidence does not allow to consider hypertonic solution potentially effective and well tolerated for acute bronchiolitis neither does justify its routinely use in clinical practice.

KW - Acute bronchiolitis

KW - Length of stay in hospital

KW - Nebulized hypertonic solution

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84948685860&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84948685860&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Articolo

AN - SCOPUS:84948685860

VL - 34

SP - 581

EP - 584

JO - Medico e Bambino

JF - Medico e Bambino

SN - 1591-3090

IS - 9

ER -